A picture posted by mother Jennifer Dorner has started yet another conversation about why not to wear costume headdresses. She took the image while dropping her children off for their first day of school at Montreal’s École Lajoie on Monday, August 29. The image shows a Grade 3 teacher in a headdress in front of the children, and according to Dorner, smaller headdresses were being handed out for the children to wear.
Sarah Dorner, Zoe’s mother, told thestar.com that her daughter refused to wear the headdress.
“We have been teaching our children that costumes like that are inappropriate,” Dorner also said. “The other kids in the class were all wearing them.”
“A lot of children aren’t necessarily taught cultural sensitivity or have much awareness about indigenous cultures,” she went on to say. “But in our family we have many indigenous friends, so it’s a conversation we’ve had many times.”
Gina Guillemette, a Margeurite-Bourgeoys school board spokesperson, told news outlets that the two teachers seen sporting headdresses have backgrounds in anthropology and history and are introducing indigenous history into the curriculum. Guillemette also told CBC News the headdresses worn by teachers were a way for the kids to know which “family, or class, to go to.”
Guillemette told the Gazette that “the teachers decided to wear hats to symbolize that they were Native chiefs,” to separate their students from another Grade 3 class.
Right. So naturally, you could not be bothered, as educators, to thoughtfully choose a particular tribe, maybe one in your actual part of the world, find out what their traditional regalia might be, and actually ask members of that tribe if it would be okay to dress in a certain item. Oh, that would be bringing Indians into things, and I guess you can’t have that in a school, it might poison young minds with the truth or something. As Adrienne Keene wrote on Native Appropriations, this is not a lightweight matter:
Adrienne K of Native Appropriations writes that a non-Indian casually wearing an Indian headdress “furthers the stereotype that Native peoples are one monolithic culture, when in fact there are 500+ distinct tribes with their own cultures. It also places Native people in the historic past, as something that cannot exist in modern society. We don’t walk around in ceremonial attire everyday, but we still exist and are still Native.” She also draws attention to the deep spiritual significance of a headdress and maintains that when a non-Indian wears one “it’s just like wearing blackface.”
Getting back to the teachers at École Lajoie, they seem to not only miss the point, they are determined to miss the point:
“No offence was intended—if any parents were offended, we apologize,” Guillemette told the Gazette. “We didn’t want to offend anyone. It was the opposite; we wanted to sensitize the students to the contributions of native communities.”
Oh For Fuck’s Sake! What about the children you offended, do they not count? And there’s that magical if – if you were offended, words of the classic notpology. You sensitize students to the contributions of native communities by appropriating a headdress unique to specific tribes, and mashing up all tribal cultures into one messy clump? You sure as hell don’t sound like educators to me, you sound like flaming assholes who live to perpetuate stereotypes.
“How can they possibly be teaching an authentic understanding of indigenous culture? Dorner asked thestar.com. “It doesn’t help their cause to say that. If anything, it makes it even more distressing.”
This isn’t the first time Dorner has addressed cultural sensitivity with the school either. In 2014, “they were doing a play where Santa goes to Africa and gets Ebola and gets sick and the local tribes are dancing around him and my daughter was going to be in blackface,” she told the Gazette.
“We managed to convince the school not to do blackface at the time, but they still kept the story line. Santa ends up being saved by scientists who come from the North Pole.”
She met with the school multiple times in 2014, according to the Gazette to discuss “cultural appropriation and this kind of insensitivity and was hoping that we had come to some kind of understanding, but apparently not. Which is why I’m particularly upset this time. The message doesn’t seem to be sinking in.”
Canadians, please, wake the fuck up. This school, and its staff, should be shamed into the ground by a whole lot of very angry people. Apparently, the open bigotry at this school strikes too many people as just fine, and that is seriously fucked up.
Full story at ICTMN.
rq says
I could scan you a picture of this year’s winning team at a nation-wide hunting festival… But I doubt it’s anything that would make your day. I don’t even know where to begin explaining the wrongness to them. (Oh, and apparently the #1 thing to wear at this year’s outdoor summer music festivals was, apparently, a feather headdress, because ‘the fad seems to be fading in (US)America, so why not keep it alive here’, or words to that effect…)
Siobhan says
French Canada is infamous for missing the whole multiculturalism memo. It’s about as bad as France in terms of shameless racism and xenophobia.
Caine says
rq:
Oh no it isn’t. Hipsters think wearing a plains war bonnet is cool.
rq says
Caine
I only regurgitate what local media says about it, apparently they’ve gotten the message that there’s a negative connotation to wearing headdresses for fun, but they don’t get the point of it, yet. Apparently there’s a developing stigma against it, but honestly, I think that’s the hard work of the right kind of media trying to get the message out rather than any societal change in opinion.
Caine says
rq @ 4, at least you have some media getting that message out. It’s not getting out at all in the states. At least 2 to 4 times a week, I see a photo of idiots in a pretend Plains headdress, here in uStates. It’s considered only to be a ‘hip’ costume. There’s a company dedicated to making rip offs, and selling them to all the ‘cool kids’.
Rob Grigjanis says
Siobhan @2: Yeah. Sadly, I’m not surprised at this level of cluelessness in a Québécois school. There was the turban ban imposed by the Quebec Soccer Federation (overturned after FIFA basically said “don’t be ridiculous”), and the Parti Québécois’ proposed Quebec Charter of Values, which was too much even for most Quebeckers.
rq says
Caine
Actually, it’s not our media getting the message out; it’s our media hearing the vague message from over there, and then saying the fuck with it, they’re ruining our fun, wear the headdress anyway because it looks so fabulous.
But anyway. I don’t want ot take away any more from the racism demonstrated in the OP.
Giliell, professional cynic -Ilk- says
And you naturally do that by wearing some dyed feather mockery no actual person to whose culture a headdress belongs would want to be seen dead in.
Makes total sense.
Also, that mum rocks.
Dunc says
What sort of background, and more importantly, during which century? I thought that generation of anthropologists were all long dead…
[blink] [blink] What the I can’t even…
whirlwitch says
Given that this is the Marguerite-Bourgeoys school board (French Catholic), I have a fix. The classes can be identified by birettas, mitres, and nun’s veils in different colours and styles. Nobody’s gonna object to that, right?
Also, how does anybody think a Christmas play should involve Santa getting Ebola? My flabber, she is gasted.