Sure is fun when superheroes punch. Nobody gets brain damaged or killed by it. Biff bam boom. This is less true when you get into edgier edges of the genre, like martial arts films where the punching goes on for hours and eventually some people get killed. But if Captain America is punching a guy? Spiderman? Batman? They just fly away and bounce, knocked out. Beddy-bye time.
This was my problem with R Batts, as much excitement as that revisit to batmannery generated. The initial trailer showed him beating on a guy to the point where IRL he’d be looking like Emmett Till, emphasizing that by having the other dudes in the gang watch the violence in mute horror.
This comes up in my dreams. Last night I dreamed I was Spiderman, and I had to beat these super-powered bad guys. But when does a beating stop? In comics and movies it stops with the KO. In my dreams, much like in real life, a person isn’t necessarily going to lose consciousness before the point where they become crippled or die. So I punch this guy until he’s at a disadvantage and he’s still tusslin’. Then I push his head against the ground hoping he’ll black out. Instead his superpower finds final expression when he phases through the ground all the way to hell. I said, damn, tell me he didn’t die! I don’t want to kill people! But his girlfriend was like, no, he’s dead.
The dream followed him into hell then, where he woke up feeling refreshed, the damage of violence falling away. But he was in hell, so more tussling ahead.
My husband never liked superheroes because he identified more with the kind of weirdos they fight against. The late Wesley Willis was not consistent about this, but it did come up a lot in his poetry. Fighting with superheroes, not thinking of yourself as the person they would save. This was not my point of view growing up. I could be a superhero in my imagination. I’m starting to feel it tho. The idea one can punch this fucked up world into making sense is absurd on its face. The face you’re punching.
Now we have Watchmen, The Boys, Damage Control, etc., looking at the other side of superheroics, with varying degrees of success and varying degrees of horror content. I’m not really into those either. I’m just pointing out a thing, not making any case for a way to address it, or saying it needs to be changed. In the vast realm of comics I haven’t read, there is almost certainly one that would make me say Yeah, that’s it, but I’m not enough of a comic fan to be all that curious about it. Feel free to drop recs anyway, or just talk about related subjects.
–