Octopuses do not have psychic powers

A “psychic” octopus named Paul is predicting the outcome of World Cup games, some Germans claim. I don’t believe it. Why would an octopus be at all interested in a game where you can’t use your arms?

i-08f48dc443ef7e78068b2fd9f8c53b13-psychic_octopus.jpeg

I don’t believe in precognition, but I do think octopuses are smart. It’s more likely that Paul is sneaking out of his tank at night to read the sports magazines, and then makes informed decisions about likely results of the matches.

Bravo, Belgium!

The Belgian police have raided offices of the Catholic church in search of evidence of the usual Catholic crime — raping children. (It’s funny: ask someone to name a Catholic crime, and what’s the first thing they think of? It’s the worst PR in the world.)

I’m hoping that they’re just warming up for the big one — I’d like to see a UN raid of the Vatican, with a whole line of shame-faced old men in dresses led out to the paddy wagons like a transvestite Mafia mob.

That’s not a shoehorn, it’s a sledgehammer

The apologetic gang at BioLogos is complaining again — Jerry Coyne, Richard Dawkins and I didn’t understand their recent piece by Daniel Harrell on Adam and Eve, and oh, it is so hard to be the ones in the middle of all those atheist and creationist extremists.

Note to BioLogos: squatting in between those on the side of reason and evidence and those worshipping superstition and myth is not a better place. It just means you’re halfway to crazy town.

The core of Falk’s article consists of complaining that we didn’t understand what they were talking about, and took their article out of context. Unfortunately, as Falk attempts to restate the original bogus argument, it becomes apparent that the only ones who were clueless and confused were the theistic evolutionists. What they were doing in the original article was distinguishing between two alternatives: #1, Adam and Eve were created literally as the Bible says, and #2, that Adam and Eve were historical figures who were chosen by God out of existing populations that had evolved as science explains. #1 is patently ridiculous, as they admit, and comically, they argue that #2 is eminently reasonable and supportable by science, and assume that therefore all our criticisms must have been made under the misapprehension that we thought BioLogos was endorsing #1. No! We can read, and we could see exactly what they were saying with their goofy dichotomy, and we’re saying the whole effort to reconcile science with the book of Genesis is a misbegotten waste of time — we were addressing #2, not #1. (Although Harrell also argues that #1 could be true, since his god can do anything).

#1 and #2 are both wrong, and there is also a #3. There was no Adam and Eve. There is no reason to believe there was; the authors of the book of Genesis had no source of information about prehistory, no authority to outline anything but their own recent history, which they were only able to do rather poorly and inaccurately, and the whole story was simply made up. Furthermore, this fable of a few unique individuals founding the whole human race is contradicted by the evidence: we are descended from populations with a pattern of continuous variation, grading over long ages from species to species to species. Not only is it irreconcilable with the Genesis myth, but there is no reason to expect it would be.

What they are attempting to do is shoehorn the evidence into their theological preconceptions. They need to face up to facts: it’s not a shoehorn in this case. When you’re reduced to using a hatchet and a sledgehammer to wedge the divine foot in, the shoe simply doesn’t fit.

How insects and crustaceans molt

I was mildly surprised at the reaction to this cool timelapse video of a molting crab — some people didn’t understand how arthropods work. The only thing to do, of course, is to explain the molting process of insects and crustaceans, called ecdysis.

Let’s go back to the basics first. In the beginning was the epithelium, a continuous sheet of linked cells that envelops multicellular organisms. These are living, dividing, dynamic cells that are flexible, can repair damage to themselves, and represent the boundary between the carefully maintained internal environment of the organism, and the more variable and often hostile external environment. And that’s where the problem lies: living cells are relatively fragile and sensitive, and in particular don’t cope well with drying out. Cells like it wet, yet if you look at insects and people, we live under horrible conditions for living cells, surrounded by dryness and heat and cold.

Our external epithelia have evolved different solutions to this problem of the basic inhospitability of terrestrial life. In us, our bounding epithelia divide frequently, pushing new cells outward. As these cells move, they commit suicide, producing a fibrous protein called keratin which forms dense, matted tangles inside the cells; these cells also build tight protein connections between their neighbors. It is these dead, protein-packed cells that face the outside world, protecting the delicate interior. These cells are steadily worn away and cast off — dandruff flakes, for instance, are sheets of these dead epithelial cells — and new protective cells produced by cell division and pushed up from the inside out to replace them. It’s a good solution that allows for constant growth and flexibility.

Arthropods, on the other hand, start with a similar sheet of living epithelial cells, but do something completely different. Instead of pushing out a continuous column of dying cells, they secrete dense layers of complex chemical compounds that harden into a tough cuticle. The exoskeleton of an insect or crustacean is acellular — the living cells have protected themselves by secreting an initially fluid set of chemicals that harden like epoxy to form a tough protective armor around themselves. We protect ourselves with sheets of leather; arthropods make plates like fiberglass on their outsides.

And there’s the rub. The cuticles of insects do not gradually slough away, replaced steadily by the addition of new material from the inside. They’re mostly fixed and rigid and static. This does have the advantage of providing a solid protective armor and a rigid framework for muscles, but isn’t so great for accommodating growth. Fiberglass isn’t stretchy and flexible!

Here’s a closer look at the structure of the arthropod cuticle.

i-a88f42ffb262a0197ecc68e2a68e00f9-molting-thumb-450x148-51727.jpg

In the diagram on the left, the living epithelium is at the bottom, labeled “epidermis”. Above it are multiple acellular layers called the cuticle made up of substances like chitin and waxes (notice that it is also perforated by pores containing ducts of the glands that secrete the chemical substances, and also places where hairs called setae can dangle into the exterior.

In order to grow, the animal must discard the old cuticle and build a new one from the inside out. In (b), this process begins by peeling away the living epidermal cells from the dead cuticle, creating a gap called the exuvial space, which is filled with a fluid called molting fluid. The cells then begin secreting a new cuticle from underneath, which is initially flexible.

What is poorly shown in these diagrams is that the new cuticle can be larger than the old. What that means is that epithelium inside the old cuticle is wrinkled and convoluted to have a larger surface area. Again, it is soft, not hard, so it can wrinkle up freely to fit. Also, to make room, the molting fluid in (c) is busily digesting the old cuticle from underneath, and the protein components are absorbed and reused to build the new cuticle.

In (d), the new cuticle is nearly fully formed, the old cuticle has been reduced to a thinner rind, and the two are separated by a thin fluid-filled space. Ecdysis, the actual molt, then occurs, and the old cuticle is discarded. Free of its confining shell, the animal inflates itself to extend the wrinkled new cuticle into larger smoothness, and the process of sclerotization, or hardening of the cuticle, begins from the outside in. Tanning agents, like polyphenols are secreted through ducts onto the surface, where they are oxidized into quinones, which trigger chemical reactions that cross-link the various substances of the cuticle into a rigid structure.

If you’ve ever eaten soft-shell crabs, you’ve caught the poor creature just after a molt and before its cuticle has hardened — in large arthropods, it can take several days for the post-molt cuticle to be fully cured. The hardening is also regional. Next time you’re eating a crab leg, notice that the shaft of the limb is rigid and strong and a bit brittle, but it grades into softer, less thickly sclerotized material at the joints called arthrodial membranes, which retains the flexibility of the pre-molt cuticle.

Now go watch the video again, and it should make more sense. What you’re seeing near the end is the crab pulling soft and rubbery limbs out of the shell of its old legs, and then resting as the new cuticle slowly hardens.

Congratulations, Australia!

Australia has a non-religious woman as prime minister! This is nominally promising, but we’ll have to wait and see if she actually follows through with some kind of commitment to secularism (the former PM, Kevin Rudd, was known for recruiting god to his party’s side).

Also, unfortunately, in all the hullabaloo about having two X chromosomes, red hair, no husband or children, and making a secular affirmation instead of a religious oath of office, I’m not hearing much about her politics, other than that she’s more or less expected to continue current Labor Party policies. Is that good or bad? I don’t know. Maybe some Australians can explain in the comments.

I wouldn’t care if she were a red-haired Hindu if she were doing good work, but the last thing we need is a godless prime minister who is also incompetent — and yes, that could happen!

Great Beards: God!

The fundraiser that will decide whether Big Dave and I will have to shave off our beards has passed the halfway mark — you have donated £805.33 for Barnardo’s children’s charity — but I notice that some people are still voting “no beard”, and we can’t have that. To counter these weak sallies into beardlessness, I’m going to have to regularly remind you of glorious beards, and today we start at the top.

i-bc5829f9672ae202bb215727d3f4aca7-god.jpeg

That’s right, people with beards have that aura of great majesty and power, just like Jehovah. Would you ask God to shave? Look at that glorious beard — it’s almost as good as Dan Dennett’s. You must vote for the beard.

Now you may be marshaling counterarguments in your head: “What about Buddha”, you’re thinking, and “Hardly any kind of god at all”, I reply, “When has Buddha ever annihilated a city with a column of fire?” Or you might be thinking “But I’m an atheist!” or “Hey, women don’t have beards, and they’re perfectly lovely”, to which I say “Satan! He’s got a beard, too.”

i-0a37499cc816ec0369091aeef84c63a1-satan.jpeg

And see? He’s apparently a lesbian as well, so the ladies can feel comfortable voting for the feminist bearded option.

Do the right thing. Donate £2 or more, and vote FOR the beard.

P.S. The rules clearly state one vote per person, so if you’re thinking of maximizing your impact by donating £10 in 5 £2 votes, it won’t work. Just vote once. If you’ve already donated, you can ignore my pleas.

Jesus Christ, but I hate these slimebags

I got email just now from Evolutionary Leaders. The source sounds promising on the surface, so I opened it. Big mistake. Bad for my blood pressure.

Are you tired of sitting around while our environment is being destroyed?

Yes! Yes, I am!

Do you feel helpless, angry or powerless to make a difference
as you watch millions of gallons of oil pouring into the Gulf every day
with no end in sight and thousands losing their lives and their livelihoods?

Yes!

Join The Gulf Call to Sacred Action!

Yes! Wait…”sacred” action? Huh?

The Evolutionary Leaders: In Service to Conscious Evolution have joined together
to be a loud and important voice for all who feel powerless.

The People Need You ~ The Gulf Needs You

And then there’s some fol-de-rol about working via telephone and internet with tens of thousands taking action and making a “powerful impact for the good of humanity” without any of explanation about what will be done. Until we get to the meat of the story.

We begin by setting our collective intention. Join Deepak Chopra to set our powerful vision and participate in a worldwide Intention Experiment with renowned author and scientist Lynne McTaggart. Explore how our collective intention, our voice and our commitment can impact the cleanup of the oil spill. And then we will be graced by Jean Houston who will share with us why this time matters and why we matter.

Jebus. Deepak Chopra. They’re going to get a bunch of people to sit around and wish the problem away. These people are Newage dead weight.

Our collective prayers and thoughts have the power to cause a profound shift on the planet. Pray with some of the most powerful spiritual thought leaders — Reverend Michael Bernard Beckwith, Joan Borysenko, James O’Dea and more. Together we discover that we have the power to change the world.

Prayer will never, ever change the world. Prayer is an excuse to lie about doing nothing and pretend you are making a difference.

Open up and connect to the deeper heart of our planet where we hear our individual and collective call to action. Together with sacred activists Barbara Marx Hubbard, Gregg Braden, and Andrew Harvey, we will take back our power and move into powerful action that will forever change our lives and the lives of generations to come.

Demented fuckwits, every one. You know, none of these cretins are fundamentalists, they probably smile a lot, and what they all propose is absolutely harmless, in the sense that it doesn’t do anything, anything at all…but they are the killers, the mind-rot, the lazy brained lotus eaters who will watch civilization crumble away while chanting that we’re becoming closer and closer to Mother Nature. I’m less worried about the ranting theocrats and openly anti-science thugs than I am these numbing, mindless, happy-talking liars who lead the gullible down an easy, cheerful path to destruction. At least the fundie kooks do their best to make their way look really hateful and hideous.

Get in the feckin’ sack, Newage know-nothings.

There. Dara O’Briain always makes me feel a little better.

I don’t know that I like this song

Roy Zimmerman released this one today as appropriate to the dissent at the top in the conduct of the war in Afghanistan.

I have to applaud Rolling Stone for exposing the chaos in leadership in the war.

The Rolling Stone article highlights how President Obama has long had an even bigger decision to make. His Afghan team is widely regarded as dysfunctional. There is an astonishing web of animosities and rivalries between key civilian and military players.

McChrystal comes off as an honest — too honest — jerk who is so arrogant that he doesn’t care that the follies of the conduct of war are being exposed. It’s the kind of incompetence at diplomacy that make his firing righteous…but still, I’m so tired of our government lying about the state of the war in Afghanistan.

More worrying for American readers will be a passage in the article where Gen McChrystal visits a detachment of US soldiers on the ground in Afghanistan.

One of their number has been killed by a booby-trap bomb in an old house.

The local commander had asked permission several times to demolish the house to eradicate the risk to his men, but Gen McChrystal’s own rules of engagement mean that permission was denied.

When the general asks the soldiers if they think they are losing, one of them tells him that some of them do.

I really don’t like that song because one of my boys has elected to join the army, and is in basic training right now; he might well end up in this wretched war. I don’t want him or anyone to be the last man; I don’t want any Afghan citizens harmed in this futile exercise which isn’t likely to end happily for anyone. I don’t need reminders that we’re going to be heartsick with worry for a few years.

At least the song is protesting the war. I look at our leadership and feel only disappointment that Obama has increased our commitment to this nightmare, along with his pathetic efforts on domestic issues, and the only thing keeping me from disgust at having voted for him is the fact that our alternative was far, far worse.