“It came from the 1950s!,” the title of my future horror novel


I think we can all agree that the movie Starship Troopers was a satire of fascism, one that was explicitly mocking fascism, right down to the Nazi-styled Hugo Boss uniforms. I can appreciate that, but am still dismayed that other people turned it into a direct-to-video franchise that celebrated the fascism.

I read the book Starship Troopers way back in the 1970s. I didn’t like it, and it made me a confirmed anti-fan of Robert Heinlein. It was blatantly pro Libertarian with a capital L, it was ridiculously pro-military, and it was comically cartoonish in its plot — it’s all about alien Bugs, with the only possible resolution of its conflict being genocide. I read it once, threw it away, and have never ever been tempted to re-read it.

But apparently some tabloid columnist used it as fodder for an article claiming that leftists see fascists everywhere they look, even in the book Starship Troopers, which he claimed wasn’t at all fascist. Shaun saw this as a challenge, and went back to re-read the book, to see if it was as innocuous as this conservative columnist claimed, then posted a video which included sections of the book.

It was even worse than I remembered.

No wonder Paul Verhoeven thought it was ripe for parodying in a movie! The video also documents Heinlein’s wild anti-communist fanaticism, in which he was writing op-eds arguing that being willing to engage in a nuclear war that would annihilate half the country was a fine and glorious thing, although he was simultaneously claiming that radiation wasn’t as bad as those weak, wimpy liberals thought. In his novel, he wrote about a paradise planet with low background radiation as a subtly dangerous place for a civilization.

Or will they worry about the fate of their
descendants and dose themselves regularly with X-
rays or maybe set off lots of dirty-type nuclear
explosions each year to build up a fall-out reservoir
in their atmosphere? (Accepting, of course, the
immediate dangers of radiation to themselves in order
to provide a proper genetic heritage of mutation for
the benefit of their descendants.)

Oh. Wow. I had a few distant John Bircher relatives who were always embracing anti-science nonsense like that, who would probably be proud MAGA/MAHA kooks now (I haven’t talked with that branch of the family since the 1990s). I suspect the Heinlein/Campbell axis of conservative idiocy poisoned a lot of minds we have to reckon with now.

Comments

  1. Dunc says

    I think we can all agree that the movie Starship Troopers was a satire of fascism, one that was explicitly mocking fascism, right down to the Nazi-styled Hugo Boss uniforms.

    You’d like to think so, but in every online discussion of it I’ve ever seen, there are always a surprising number of people who say they either didn’t realise it was satire originally, or that they’re not really sure it’s actually satire.

    On the other hand, those discussions also always feature people who think the satire is far too obvious and heavy-handed.

    I can only conclude that a lot of people are really, really bad at recognising satire.

  2. raven says

    I read the book Starship Troopers way back in the 1970s. I didn’t like it, …

    I read it as a kid in the early 1960s. I think I was around 12.
    I did like it and remember it well to this day.
    At least for a kid it was easy to understand. Starship troopers with powered armor suits are good and the alien Bugs are bad. We win.
    I doubt I would like it today. Didn’t see the movie either.

    In his novel, he wrote about a paradise planet with low background radiation as a subtly dangerous place for a civilization.

    I remember this part as well.

    It is just wrong in the science.
    Evolutionary changes are natural selection pressures acting on the mutation pool.
    The mutation rates aren’t rate limiting. Selection pressures are what are rate limiting.
    This is a complicated claim but one example will show this.
    Adaptive radiation.
    Whenever an ecological niche or a whole large number of them open up, often by natural disasters or chance events, there are adaptive radiations of species.
    Look at what the mammals and birds did after the nonavian dinosaurs got wiped out in the Chicxulub event, galapogus tortoises and cacti, African cichlid fishes, etc..

Leave a Reply