Our movement was founded in part on islamophobia, so it’s unsurprising a number of our blogs beat that drum occasionally – at least, before the fash sealed their control of the country. Nobody formally announced we were cooling it on muslims, but it seemed to happen spontaneously among the blogs that were left standing. It still happens, but with appropriate caveats.
With regard to islam, one FtBlog in particular stood out to me. Sadly, one of our few ladies. She left the network to join the terf community, consigning herself to the most miserable company this side of the interweb. Before that, she would post about the evils of islam just about every single day.
And those evils were evil! They deserve to be reported. But in our country, where islamophobia was one of the levers used to help the nazis win, this reportage was equivalent to campaigning for the GOP. It can simultaneously be true information about shit that deserves to be known, and a bad fucking thing to talk about with that frequency.
It’s the same principle as Breitbart’s “black crime watch.” Take things that are really happening, shine a relentless enough spotlight on them, serve nazi ends. We should be aware of why we’re talking about the things we’re choosing to talk about, and what ends we serve by doing so.
Now it’s time to discuss an uncomfortable subject. Bear with me. You ever seen a gay pride float that was a massive sexually explicit sculpture? Topless dykes on bikes? This sort of thing? Have you ever sought out furry spaces online to indulge your inner bugs bunny, and found an overwhelming amount of sexual content there? LGBTetc subcultures have a long history of “horny on main” behavior – flaunting the sexuality the kyriarchy wants to suppress. This is fine, within certain contexts.
The online culture of transgender women has been long and closely associated with anime, which can sometimes include “lolicon” – sexualized depictions of girls (meaning children) in Japanese-style art. I’m not going to defend that shit here, but I’m going to equivocate on it a bit. There are many subcultures of erotica on the internet that involve shit that should just not be done, and as bad as lolicon is, it’s not worse than reading and writing about sexual cannibalism. You can find a lot of cis women who are into that, if you go looking, and they’re not catching the same shit trans women are catching these days.
Is all that excusable as long as it stays in the realm of fiction? Not a debate I’m interested in having because it’s far outside of my chosen topic. There are other places for you to discuss it if you’re interested. It’s relevant here in that it is a thing some people get up to that hits most of us in the same feelings as epstein revelations. In some places it really is a crime, and it is something some trans women have publicly expressed enjoyment in.
As we speak, it’s one of the crimes that are getting mentioned in vigilante harassment campaigns against trans women. But let’s look at cultural context for a minute. Transgender women are part of that LGBTetc culture of forward sexuality. For years when they talked about sexual things they’re into, it’s been cheers and bonhomie from the online company they’ve kept. (Huge overlap with furry culture, it bears mentioning.) It’s been normalized for them to just be as horny as they wanna be, all day all night, on their respective social media accounts.
This whole time, their political foes have been taking notes. Terfs, nazis, and just anybody they got into an argument with. Observe Bidoof’s Law (not censored per my ableism policy in favor of accuracy): “will there ever be anything more timelessly funnier on this site than seeing some joyless idiot asserting their stupid controversial worldviews internet toughguy style and then checking their blog and they’re just, completely openly and shamelessly addicted to hentai”
The tumblr user who originated that post was talking about conservatives and their public horniness, but I’ve seen the same from people over less acrimonious discourse. Someone gets their political point disputed by a trans woman, visits her blog, and finds a wall of creepy fetish content. They remember that shit.
The chickens have come home to roost. Arguably the first shot fired was when tumblr’s CEO Mxtt Mxllenweg (who has way too much power over the platform of wordpress, on which you’re reading this) got sniped at by a trans woman on twitter and responded by using his admin privileges to list every fetish sideblog she’d ever created.
Now finding excuses to hound trans women to suicide has become the hot sport of the moment on the internet, and thanks to that horny culture they’ve engaged in for years, there is no shortage of rope with which to hang them.
This, I would argue, is overpolicing, in the same way our own Terfelia Benson once overpoliced the muslim community, and Breitshart overpoliced the black community. Might there be transgender women who have expressed dubious sexual thoughts, even frequently and publicly? Yes, but so have a huge number of other people who are not getting persecuted for it right now.
Again, look at the emotional motive, look at the consequences. This supports the agenda of painting all trans women as pedophiles. This disappears trans women from the public sphere. This supports the nazism that now has the world under its nuclear-first-strike-capable thumb.
You are likely to see callout posts / articles / videos about trans women in the near future, if you haven’t already. I am not asking you to set aside your principles, any more than I’d ask you to give boko haram a pass for their shit. I’m just asking you not to add to the dogpile.
Don’t be part of the problem of fascism. These dogpiles are going to happen whether you contribute or not, but by choosing to opt out, you’re making them a little bit smaller, a little less impactful. Just dip on it. If you don’t feel up to defending these ladies, don’t bother. Do activism that works for you.
Just don’t add to the chorus – at this point including no small amount of progressives, political leftists, and even trans people – bringing ruinous attention down on trans women, in a way that makes us all look like pedophiles. In a way that gives the death camp crew more pitchforks for the pile.
Thank you for your consideration.
And to any sex weirdos in my readership who have done horny things online, just pay attention to what’s happening here, and consider again what you want your digital hoofprint to look like. I have, in my day, seen no small amount of genuinely amateur pornography. People who were old, young, fat, disabled, unacceptable to the ghost puritan dominating our national pysche, but who felt for a shining “felt cute, might delete later” moment that they were a sexy creature who deserved to be sexually appreciated by strangers, and laid it all out for people like me.
Mwah. Love you. But very little is ever truly deleted. Just think twice before posting horny on main.
–
