I hope you are not bored with my writing about knife making yet. It is not that I do not care about other things, but knife making is where most of my focus is right now. And this week I had barely the strength to do anything else at all.
I have started a new batch of blades, 18 pieces altogether – 4 small hunting knives, 4 badger knives, 5 chef knives (prototyping new design), and 5 universal kitchen knives. So this whole week I was drilling, cutting, and grinding steel every day. I have progressed reasonably fast, despite being also slow. Because I simply cannot handle more than 6 hours net a day at the grinder, and I have to make a substantial pause every two hours. My hands are doing reasonably OK and I have been pain-free for a few months by now (despite never having a diagnosis about what was wrong last year), but even so, the vibrations are a strain on the fingers. And after two hours not only the glasses start getting foggy – the mind does so as well and thus the risk of injury increases.
Today was a big finale of that busy week and all knives went into quench and tempering. This time I have decided to use quenching foil on all blades, despite bad experience on some blades the last time. I have decided to do so because the protective coating that I have concocted did work well but also was a real pain in the ass to remove afterward. And that did cost me a lot of time and I destroyed two belts before I figured it out. But I have tried plate quench with on this steel with moderate success), and I have hoped, really, really hoped, that doing plate quench on newly ground and straight blanks will lead to straight blades without having to scrub off a hard crust.
And following the maxim of Scrooge McDuck “Work smarter, not harder”, I have done my best to make the plate quench easy and reliable – I have built myself a jig. The construction is very simple and it did only take me a few hours. I have used the locking pliers and aluminum plates from last time, but I have connected it all into one piece that can be easily used in one hand. So instead of one hinge in the middle of the plates, I have added two hinges on the sides. Then I have drilled holes in the fixed jaw of the pliers (and re-ground it a bit) so I can screw one of the plates to it with two M4 screws. The movable jaw is not fixed to the second plate, but it does fit into a groove cut in it and it was also re-ground for a better fit at the angle where most blades will be gripped.
The idea was that I will hold this jig in my left hand, with my right hand I pull a blade out of the forge, insert it between the plates (still in the foil), lock the pliers and dunk the whole thing into a bucket of water. And it worked well! None of the knives came out of the quench with a perm or as a banana-imitation, none have cracked either, at least I did not notice it yet. All but one blade quenched properly (and that one I have re-quenched OK the second time) with hardness above 55 HRC, most even over 62.
Hardening all these blades took me only 15-16 minutes per blade, so even with all that foil wrapping, I was well within a reasonable time. There was only one small problem towards the end – my new burner worked really well and I have reached and held 1.050-1.080°C without problem with four blades in the forge, but after a few hours, it started to struggle. I thought at first that I am running out of propane, but that was not the case. As it turns out, the propane bottle got too cold (just 10°C) after that long continuous decompression, and the gas was evaporating less. I am not sure yet how to solve that problem for the future.
Now the blades are in the second tempering cycle (each cycle two hours at circa 180°C) and they did not seem to develop any bends or curls in the oven either. So far, so good, let us hope it stays that way since I am going to try some new techniques with this project again.
Marcus Ranum says
As it turns out, the propane bottle got too cold (just 10°C) after that long continuous decompression, and the gas was evaporating less. I am not sure yet how to solve that problem for the future.
Typically I’ve seen this solved by increasing the thermal mass of the propane bottle: put it in a larger container of water.
Not bored at all. Fascinated in fact.
Propane boils at minus 40 degrees C so it may just be a case of your regulator being too small for the job. A larger regulator will flow more with low intake pressure. Maybe arrange some of the waste heat to keep a kettle of water hot, pour some on the propane tank occasionally. I’ve seen large propane tanks outside a public hall on a cold night get so chilled that your hands would stick to them if you dared touched them. I’ve also seen people use automotive grade propane/butane mixture to save money, the butane fraction boils at zero C and has very little pressure after the propane component has boiled off first.
Great American Satan says
I love the impression this gives of FtB -- you and Ranum knifing up the joint.
Anne, Cranky Cat Lady says
Not bored at all. I love learning how things are made, even if (or because) I’m not likely to try the art myself.
Bored? I am amazed by your craftyness and skills!
What Marcus said. I have seen a propane-butane-mix bottle form snow on the outside, which insulated it, obviously :)
Not bored at all with your knife making, I’m a huge fan of yours!
Find a tub about 200 mm larger in diameter, set in an “empty” propane bottle, and fill with water until the empty bottle just floats. Remove .25 liter of water, and that should be enough of a heat sink to keep your bottle from freezing up, and safe from your bottle floating, and tipping over. Mark that level on the inside of the tub, so you have a mark to re-fill as water evaporates.
Works for me, using propane burner to boil wort when making beer.
I may not always understand your knife making posts, but I enjoy them nevertheless.
I too enjoy your knife making posts.
I’m glad to hear that your hands are doing ok, it’s frustrating to not know why they caused you all the problems they did, but here’s hoping it was not something that will return so you get to make lots of lovely knives and we get to read about you making them!
Ice Swimmer says
Your knife making posts are always interesting.