It’s all about the context » « Tangled Bank this week

Klinghoffer splattered

Well, I was going to do something with that awful, horrible, ignorant Klinghoffer piece that the Discovery Institute was pushing, but my distracting weekend kept me occupied, and
Pro-Science,
Thoughts in a Haystack, and
Salt on Everything
all demolished it for me. Anything I could say at this point would just be bouncing gibs around.

It’s all about the context » « Tangled Bank this week

Comments

  1. Sobex says

    Bouncing gibs, eh? I hope you honed your FPS skills on standard fare like the Quake/Unreal series rather than Left Behind: Eternal Forces.

  4. says

    But an atheist society could not survive.

    A religious society can survive, see, while an atheist society could not survive (witness communism’s demise. Uh-huh, the old rightist claim was that it was all economics). But atheism is a religion, cause you know, Buddhism can be atheistic (try using a Vin diagram to show how atheism thus becomes religion, Davie).

    So yes, religions (he really only credits his God, but surely even he’d admit that other religious societies have lasted–rather longer than monotheistic societies have) are needed for society to survive, atheism is a religion, therefore atheistic society cannot survive. Slipped a cog there, Davie.

    Glen D
    http://tinyurl.com/35s39o

  5. Shoeguy says

    There is an ultimate authority on what is and is not a religion. That authority is the Internal Revenue Service. Show me any atheist community that is classified as a tax exempt religious group and I will crawl back under my rock.
    BTW. There are some obnoxious, massively egotistical public athiests, mostly radio personalities. As an atheist I contribute to secular charities, have been a foster parent, and done years of work (name a board, and I’ve served) for my community while never denying my denial of the local gods.

  8. dzd says

    Honestly, Klinghoffer would have had it much easier if he had just written it out as the series of cliches it is.

    Graf 1: Science is just another religion.
    Graf 2: Courtier’s Reply.
    Graf 3: Better dead than Red.
    End article.

  9. says

    I kinda wish people would stop calling communist regimes atheistic. Not Christian, sure, but all they did was substitute the State and the Beloved Leader for God. Pretty religious “framing” there, you ask me.

  10. dzd says

    Yeah, but if you say that to the fundagelicals, their next move is always to claim equivalency–that Darwin/Dawkins/science/whatever are being substituted for $DEITY. It’s so tiresome.

  11. says

    Aw, man, and I was planning on writing something about it tonight. Oh well, more time for, well, whatever it is I do.

  12. Stephen Ockham says

    Bouncing the gibs eh?

    PZ, I wonder if you could satisfy my curiousity.

    Please tell me if you picked this up from direct contact with first person shooter culture, or if it came to you indirectly. If indirectly, do you recall the scenario, or do you have an impression of how many generations of alienation are between your using it and Quake-era games.

    I am facinated by the transmission of internet/computer game slang and neologisms.

  13. Tina B. says

    If you like science check out SKEPTISISM EXPERT AND AUTHOR

    MICHAEL SHERMER: Lectures at CAl Tech, Pasadena (student prices)
    Check out webpages-Skeptic Michael Shermer

    Publisher, Editor, Author> SKEPTIC MAGAZINE

    featured symbolism between cultural ideas about religion, and the ideas of scientific evidence including his accounts of researching the philosophy to his remedy of the argument:
    SCIENCE VS RELIGION

    Gives great examples.
    Author if many inspiring and well formatted books.
    A MUST SEE!!!

    Thanx
    T>B