Herein I’m going to breeze through the discography of Nirvana. I’m ashamed to admit that the first time I heard them, I didn’t get it. I’d come out of conventional rock. Nirvana is remembered as the first big grunge band, but they were easy for me to ignore for a minute – Pearl Jam, Alice in Chains, and Soundgarden were all successful by the time I first heard a Nirvana song (all had major albums drop in 1991!), and they all seemed like a straightforward evolutions of rockity roll. Soundgarden was like Sabbath by way of more psychedelic rock; Pearl Jam was like a no-homo version of that romantic eighties UK post-punk, by way of a drug-affected bar band; Alice in Chains was the bar-bandiest of the big boys, but like, a bar band that discovered heroin and forgot sex and booze exist. What the fuck was Nirvana then?
I still don’t know how I’d characterize them exactly. Grunge was an artificial label for a range of styles that didn’t necessarily overlap. Nirvana was more punk descended, with a big influence of some very underground eighties alternative bands, mostly from the UK or SST Records in the US. Who were these people and what were they doing, and what did Nirvana do with that influence that set them apart? I dunno. I’m no expert.
Clearly they were not unprecedented, just unprecedented in popular consciousness. They just hit the right balance of doing what other punk descendants around the world were doing, hit the right radio and TV stations at the right time to explode. It wasn’t going to be The Meat Puppets or The Vaselines or The Violent Femmes, as beloved as those bands are to the people who know them. Maybe it had to be Nirvana.
Back to my experience, of not getting it. I didn’t know anything but the radio dial, and even then, not its darkest recesses. That meant Nirvana was a radical realignment of my expectations of what music could be. Once I started giving them a chance – I feel like that only took a few months – I found that they were murdering Pearl Jam in my esteem. AiC and Soundgarden were unharmed by the realignment, but PJ could not survive. They were too maudlin and conventional, and kept pushing in that direction. I used to love Pearl Jam so much, what even happened there?
Nirvana is more real, speaks to the world as I know it. Indignity, piss, shit, vomit, mold and moss. Everybody is tainted, everybody fucked something up for somebody else, fucked something up for themselves. Love and relationships are for guilt and humiliation. Looking at humanity is looking a giant pile of mutant meat that thinks it’s a prom queen.
And it’s rock and roll, so that’s always nice.
–
Bleach (1989)
Nirvana’s debut album was from 1989?! I didn’t remember that. I’m with the literal millions of people who didn’t hear a single song off of Bleach until after Nevermind blew up, when we were wanting more. It’s very recognizably Nirvana, but more punk rock, less experimental than Nevermind. Since a major appeal of Nirvana is their reality, their primal energy, a more primal version of their sound has complete merit. I wouldn’t want to be in a world without their evolution, without the way they sounded in the end, but I like that we have this as well.
Classics
***** “Blew” kicks off the album with hot grindy energy. “If you wouldn’t mind I would like to breathe…” Perfectly constructed, no part I dislike, and it ends strong. I have no fuckin’ idea what he’s talking about. It makes for a mood, but I’m not going to try to put that into words. The band already has me struggling.
**** “Floyd the barber” is one of the few Nirvana songs with a narrative, a plot. The cast of The Andy Griffith Show rapes and murders Kurt while he feels too humiliated to move. Kinda graphic. The death blow is the worst, some Marquis de Sade shit. This has to be a dream, of course. But what kind of life would cause one to have a dream like this? It’s an edgelordly good ronk song, but it also provokes some sympathy in me.
***** Broadly considered one of their best, “About a Girl” feels romantic but abusively so, like a bad courtship. As I’m going through these songs in order, it is their only song I can think of that comes at all close to expressing love. Isn’t it?
***** No recess! No receeeesss. No recess! “School” is another song dreamlike because it says “You’re in high school again,” which we do dream about, don’t we? For those who hated high school, is there ever really an escape from that version of society? Aside from hermitage.
Good Stuff
**** “Love Buzz” … Wait another song about courtship? I forgot. It features an orientalist riff, to no thematic end I could discern. Stands out as different from the rest of the album… because it’s a cover song? I didn’t know that until the cursory googlage just now.
**** “Papercuts” is the first trip downtempo. Very dark vibe. Not a clear meaning. Main lyrics I can pick out are “They come with flashing lights and take my family away,” and “My whole existence is for your amusement.” Feels like somewhere I’ve been.
**** “Negative creep” brings the tempo back up, and has a hammering repetitive refrain of “Daddy’s little girl ain’t a girl no more.” Based on everything I know about Kurt and his scene, there is zero reason for a transgender interpretation of that. It’s an old euphemism for losing virginity. But if a trans dude wants to see himself in the grimly begrunged song? I’m for it.
**** “Gimme back my alcohol,” Kurt demands in another chorus that repeats a mantra until it loses meaning. “In your eyes, I’m not worth it…” “Scoff” is essential Nirvana.
**** Skipping ahead, “Big Cheese” is about office politics. Nirvana belongs under a bridge or in a firebombed flophouse huffing mold spores from a discarded papier-mâché Easter egg. The juxtaposition of who they are with the subject matter is meaningful. Kurt sounds a little like he’s about to vomit as he sings, “Mike says call the office.”
Filler
** “Swap Meet” doesn’t have a plot but does have characters, and it’s fine. I just don’t care about these particular boomers.
*** “Mr. Moustache” rocks but I can see being annoyed by it. I have no idea what it means.
**** “Sifting” was originally the last track on the album, but the version I’m most familiar with ends with “Big Cheese.” “Wet your bed; wouldn’t it be fun?” Again, no idea on meaning. The music makes specific meanings or interpretations less important. It’s a reasonable end of album vibe. Retire to your bedchamber with a miserable defeated yowl, and fade away.
Garbage
No garbage! This band was too fucking good. I once had a cheesy friend who said, shame about Kurt, but if he hadn’t died, would we have the much better Foo Fighters? Mademoiselle, that was deeply wrong.
–
Nevermind (1991)
1991 saw the release of Soundgarden’s Badmotorfinger, Pearl Jam’s Ten, and then… This album, which erased my ability to love Pearl Jam’s Ten. That’s still a trip to consider. Anyway, Nevermind is broadly considered one of the best albums ever, and if you were ever in a position to know it, you know it. These are just my extremely come-lately styled reactions to them.
Classics
***** “Smells Like Teen Spirit” was a perfect lead off track, lead single, lead of a revolution in music. I feel like I enjoyed it less for a few years after it came out, like I always used to skip it and a few other tracks that got excessive radio play. But I’ve long since returned to listening to the whole album in sequence. SLTS is rock and roll and it’s a joke at rock and roll’s expense. I love it.
**** “In Bloom” has great music and ok lyrics. Wait, wait… I’ve said a few times in this review so far, I don’t know what it means! The song is a diss track aimed at my asshole! Better than SLTS, they establish the band’s main themes on the album, and their oeuvre in general. It just got a tiny bit overplayed for my taste.
*** “Come as You Are” takes it down a notch and has a real unusual style. An excellent song, really, just not something I want to listen to very often. “Memoria,” he says. What’s it mean?
***** “Breed” is another romantic song, similar to “Fast Car” in that it’s about love as a dubious escape route, tho that is the end of similarity. Is epic.
***** “Drain You” establishes another recurring theme which will get deeper on In Utero. It’s interesting that someone who seems so disgusted with breeding A) bred, and B) had a sorta anti-abortion song on a later album.
***** “Stay Away” … One time my homeboy TryAnythingOnce Todd decided to yell edgy nonsense out the window of my shitty apartment, and opened with “I Am God.” The punchline of this particular Nirvana track is “god is gaaaay” and it was on the mind, so we were like, say “god is gay” next. He did, only clocking immediately after that he had called himself gay. All in good fun, but the time in his life that I liked him the least, he was angrily protesting the idea. I do think that he’s straighter than I ever would have been, good for him, but he bothered me with that shit at least once.
Joke rock novelty act Green Jellö put out a VHS tape of videos for their debut album, which was a fun time for edgy suburban white boys. I have a dim memory of a few honest moments later on the tape. There was a high angle shot of the cast and crew on set, burned out, laying on the ground, but banging their heads groggily to this song. Green Jellö were the embodiment of fakery in rock, of the unreal, of Hollywood laughing at itself. But they were musicians, and the opposite end of music from them – of reality, of catharsis – that was what moved them when they weren’t wearing papier-mâché titties and singing about Fred Flintstone.
***** “Something in the Way” is the one. This is where Kurt lays down at the end of the night, at the end of time. Underneath the bridge. Big PNW homeless mentally ill teenager energy. Black Hole.
Good Stuff
**** “Lithium” is a generic “im this crazzy guy” song, in that sense a cousin to “They’re Coming to Take Me Away.” The music is hella good.
*** I recognize that “Polly” is an excellent song, but it’s a torture ballad like some songs be murder ballads, and I’m not into it. Reportedly two shitty dudes raped a lady while singing this song at her, and Kurt took to the liner notes on the following album to tell those guys they’re a waste of life.
**** “Lounge Act” is about some kinda iffy relationships. If we went hunting for a Kurt Cobain song that was about romance with no hints of a dark side, hm, that would have to be “Breed.” Or would it? Are they all miserable? Whatever, this song is great too.
**** “On a Plain” is a good solid tune, decent penultimate track, winding down. “I love myself better than you; I know it’s wrong, but what should I do?”
**** “Endless, Nameless” is a secret track, appearing after minutes of silence at the end of the album. Nirvana was famous for intentionally making feedback happen before it was cool. This is the noise art to make up for how listenable the rest of the album was. Good job.
Filler
*** “Territorial Pissings” is real fun aggressive music, but the lyrics kinda suck ass.
Garbage
No garbage!
–
to be continued…
–