Salil Tripathi gives his view.
Last night I asked Doniger what she thought about her publisher’s decision. Deeply concerned, she told me: “Penguin has indeed given up the lawsuit, and will no longer publish the book. Of course, anyone with a computer can get the Kindle edition from Penguin, NY, and it’s probably cheaper, too. It is simply no longer possible to ban books in the age of the Internet. For that, and for all the people who have expressed outrage over this, I am deeply grateful.”
I also asked Penguin for its response. At the time of writing, Chiki Sarkar, Penguin’s publisher, had not replied.
Those who disagreed with Doniger had options—to protest, to argue, to publish their own book as response, and if they had a copy, to shut it. Nobody is being forced to read it. Now, go to your electronic readers, buy it, download it, read it; if you go abroad, get copies—there’s no ban on its import; and reinforce the idea that a pluralistic India does not have singular views. India thrives in its diversity and plurality—its culture and its opinions.
As freedom of expression itself is under threat, and India undergoes its own period of darkness and chaos, Doniger’s philosophical equanimity offers hope, that this, too, shall pass. It must, otherwise it is another country.
I hope so.
Before reading these posts, I had never heard of “The Hindus: An Alternative History.”
If I had heard of it, it’s unlikely that I would have wanted to read it, since its subject matter lies outside my interests or knowledge.
Now it’s in my laptop and my smart phone — to be read ASAP.
Way to go, moronic censors.
With this publicity, sales are sure to go up.
Ophelia Benson says
I had that thought. But…sales of ebooks aren’t the same as sales of books. The book on the bookshelf is a special thing.
Argle Bargle says
I’ll be reading this book as soon as I finish the book I’m reading now.
I ended up getting it as well. Should arrive next week – which conveniently is a holiday.