Lawrence Krauss is becoming a bit of a firebrand

Not that he’s ever been soft on religion, but this recent column in SciAm makes him sound like one of those shrill, militant, rabid, dangerous Gnu Atheists.

I don’t know which is more dangerous, that religious beliefs force some people to choose between knowledge and myth or that pointing out how religion can purvey ignorance is taboo. To do so risks being branded as intolerant of religion. The kindly Dalai Lama, in a recent New York Times editorial, juxtaposed the statement that “radical atheists issue blanket condemnations of those who hold religious beliefs” with his censure of the extremist intolerance, murderous actions and religious hatred in the Middle East. Aside from the distinction between questioning beliefs and beheading or bombing people, the “radical atheists” in question rarely condemn individuals but rather actions and ideas that deserve to be challenged.

Surprisingly, the strongest reticence to speak out often comes from those who should be most worried about silence. Last May I attended a conference on science and public policy at which a representative of the Vatican’s Pontifical Academy of Sciences gave a keynote address. When I questioned how he reconciled his own reasonable views about science with the sometimes absurd and unjust activities of the Church—from false claims about condoms and AIDS in Africa to pedophilia among the clergy—I was denounced by one speaker after another for my intolerance.

Religious leaders need to be held accountable for their ideas. In my state of Arizona, Sister Margaret McBride, a senior administrator at St. Joseph’s Hospital in Phoenix, recently authorized a legal abortion to save the life of a 27-year-old mother of four who was 11 weeks pregnant and suffering from severe complications of pulmonary hypertension; she made that decision after consultation with the mother’s family, her doctors and the local ethics committee. Yet the bishop of Phoenix, Thomas Olm­sted, immediately excommunicated Sister Mary, saying, “The mother’s life cannot be preferred over the child’s.” Ordinarily, a man who would callously let a woman die and orphan her children would be called a monster; this should not change just because he is a cleric.

Slapping around the Dalai Lama? Good on you, Dr Krauss.

And a bright and cheery good morning to you, too!

You know, every morning I get up and try to plow through the flood of email I get overnight, and it’s always full of these dire stories and horrible events. So here I will share with you a little sense of how I feel when I open my mailbox.

It’s amazing that I’m still such a happy fellow. I think the giggles are a consequence of being punch-drunk, though.

Belief can be dangerous

Gullibility really does destroy lives. A Vietnamese couple in Australia, the Trans, were missing a purse, so they made mistake #1: they went to a fortune teller to find out where it was. Really, magic doesn’t work.

Mistake #2: the fortune teller told them that a young woman, Leilani dos Santos, who was living with them had stolen it. The fortune teller had no way of knowing, but made this potentially destructive accusation anyway.

Mistake #3: The Trans believed the fortune teller.

Mistake #4, and this is the really big one: The Trans believed that torture was an appropriate method of getting the purse back.

Ms Tran also allegedly told Ms dos Santos they would cut off her fingers, but they loved her and would inject her with heroin, so she would not feel it.

Ms dos Santos said Mr Tran beat her in the back with a meat cleaver, threatened her with a samurai sword and burnt her arm with a cigarette.

Ms dos Santos said the couple had a Lady Gaga CD playing loudly. “I was screaming,” she said. “I was hoping maybe somebody would break down the door and help me.”

Ms dos Santos eventually escaped, and the Trans are currently on trial. Let’s hope the court doesn’t make mistake #5 and let those insane people go — the Trans are clearly infected with a delusional belief system that they use to justify horrific acts against others.

I mean, really…Lady Gaga?

I am the wrong person to answer this email

I am not a fan of homeschooling; in fact, if I had my way, I’d make it illegal. Too often it’s an excuse to isolate kids and hammer them full of ideological nonsense, and in a troubled public school system, it doesn’t help to strip students and money from a struggling district — it should be part of the social contract that we ought to provide a good education to everyone.

Before you start protesting (aw, who am I kidding? Some will be howling in protest anyway) I know that there are good homeschool programs, and I have students who were homeschooled and were better prepared than kids coming out of the public school system. You may be one of them. But I don’t think sending everyone to be taught by your mom and dad is a good solution, and I think we’re better off investing in good public education.

OK, but now on to the email. Here’s a sincere and worthy request from a homeschooling mom in Arizona.

Next summer, Ken Ham of Answers in Genesis is coming to Phoenix to speak at the local homeschool convention. As a secular homeschooler in Phoenix, I am appalled. I feel like I must respond in some way, stand up and say, “This guy does not represent me or others like me!”

I am interested in creating some kind of large, public response, but not sure where to begin. I thought that one of you might have some ideas.

See what I mean? This is one of the big problems of homeschooling: for every good, science-oriented parent, there are dozens or hundreds who buy into the awful, horrible, no-good nonsense peddled by Ken Ham and other creationists.

So I recuse myself as an opponent of homeschooling, but I appreciate that as long as we are going to have homeschoolers, something needs to be done about this ridiculous association between homeschooling and bad education. I turn it over to the readers here: what should be done? What can be done in the short term to protest damning choices like bringing Ham in to speak to a convention, and what can be done in the long run to get better quality science into homeschool programs? That last one will be a real challenge, given that my impression of the majority of homeschoolers is that they’re doing it specifically to indoctrinate their kids in a specific conservative Christian ideology.

Are constant reminders OK, too?

Writing about the role of the NAACP in swatting down the endemic racism in the Republican party, Ta-Nehisi Coates writes something beautiful.

I have, in my writing, a tendency to become theoretically cute, and overly enamored with my own fair-mindedness. Such vanity has lately been manifested in the form of phrases like “it’s worth saying” and “it strikes me that…” or “respectfully…”

When engaging your adversaries, that approach has its place. But it’s worth saying that there are other approaches and other places. Among them–respectfully administering the occasional reminder as to the precise nature of the motherfuckers you are dealing with.

It’s worth saying, respectfully, that I have never been overly enamored with my fair-mindedness, so it’s the second paragraph that resonates most strongly with me.

(via Mike the Mad Biologist)

Engineering lungs

i-e88a953e59c2ce6c5e2ac4568c7f0c36-rb.png

This past weekend, I attended my 35th high school reunion. It’s a strange phenomenon to be meeting people you haven’t seen since you were 18, and further weirdness ensues when we discover that most of them are already grandparents. There have been a lot of life changes in 35 years. Saddest of all, though, is the ritual listing of the deceased…and I learned that one of my former classmates died in her late 40s of emphysema, a progressive and irreversible lung disease that leads to the near complete loss of lung function. The only cure right now is a lung transplant, and patients who’ve been suffering with emphysema for long typically have so many other problems that they’re poor candidates for surgery, not to mention that the waiting list for organs is long, and a transplant means a life-long commitment to anti-rejection drug treatments.

There will come a day, though, when new lungs can be built and replacement surgeries more common. That day is definitely not yet here, though, but there are promising signs on the horizon. One such sign is recent work in tissue engineering to grow lungs in a dish.

We can grow functional rat lungs in a tissue culture chamber now, which show some limited ability to support respiration when transplanted back into another rat. Here’s an overview of the procedure; I’ll go through it step by step.

i-94f24633ccc6b3c56daf6f749a7c58c3-lung_engineering-thumb-428x200-54105.jpeg
Schema for lung tissue engineering. (A) Native adult rat lung is cannulated in the pulmonary artery and trachea for infusion of decellularization solutions. (B) Acellular lung matrix is devoid of cells after 2 to 3 hours of treatment. (C) Acellular matrix is mounted inside a biomimetic bioreactor that allows seeding of vascular endothelium into the pulmonary artery and pulmonary epithelium into the trachea. (D) After 4 to 8 days of culture, the engineered lung is removed from the bioreactor and is suitable for implantation into (E) the syngeneic rat recipient.

The first step is to collect a donor rat lung. The organ is cut out of a living rat, who will quickly become a dead rat; this part of the procedure probably can’t be scaled up to human transplantations, for obvious reasons. However, lungs from dead people or perhaps even lungs from appropriately sized animals will be adequate.

This donor lung is then stripped of all of its living cells. This is done by perfusing it with a detergent solution. Membranes dissolve and rupture in the presence of detergent, so all of the cells in the lung are basically destroyed, their contents, including cytoplasm, nucleus and DNA, and membranes and organelles are washed away.

What’s left then? Connective tissue and extracellular proteins. All that’s left is a frothy, fragile matrix of fibers like collagen and elastin, and imbedded signaling proteins that will be useful in supporting the growth of new cells. It leaves behind a kind of porous, pale ghost lung, a collection of microscopic struts that just needs to be draped with new cells.

This is the key step. Lungs are complicated, delicate membranous structures, and it would be hard to regrow it entirely from scratch. Starting with an acellular scaffold, though, a kind of skeleton of a lung that sketches out the arrangement of alveoli and blood vessels gives the tissue engineering a head start. It really is amazing how much of the organization of the lung is still left when all of the cells are removed: the photos below show the air spaces left behind (on the left) and the major blood vessels (on the right). There are no cells here! This is just an outline of the structure left by the still extant connective tissue!

i-1792794f176e5f94f701c02d7aa540cf-lung_matrix.jpeg

What’s promising about this so far is that almost all of the antigenic components of the lung are removed; if this lacework of proteins were transplanted into another animal, it probably wouldn’t provoke an immune response. Of course, it also wouldn’t work as a lung, because there are no gas exchange surfaces present, and everything is leaky. It’s only a skeleton of a lung, remember…so let’s fix that.

The next step is to suspend the lung framework in a chamber, with tubes attached to the airways and to the blood vessels. Living, isolated lung epithelial cells are then introduced into the airways, and lung endothelial cells (the cells that line blood vessels) are introduced into the pulmonary arteries and veins. These cells stick to the scaffolds and grow. They actually grow better in the lung matrix than they do in a petri dish, probably because of the presence of growth factor proteins lurking in the acellular scaffold.

The new cells use the matrix as a guide and repopulate and rebuild the cellular structure of the lung. During this whole process, the tissue culture medium is pumped through the arteries to mimic the effects of blood pressure, and air is pumped into the airways. It works beautifully. New columnar epithelial cells grow to line alveoli, and endothelial cells line the blood vessels appropriately, and the cells produce the right secreted proteins, like surfactants that reduce surface tension and are important for allow lungs to inflate. It takes about a week for the new lung tissues to form, and they are robust, producing sheets of cells that can tolerate the same pressures as intact, normal lungs.

Now for the real test. The regrown lungs were transplanted into living rats for 45 minutes to two hours. They worked! Everything stitched together nicely, and the engineered tissues pinked up nicely as blood flowed into them. Blood was visibly oxygenated as it passed through the new lung, and measurements of the partial pressure of oxygen and carbon dioxide in the blood showed that the former went up and the latter went down, exactly as it is supposed to do.

This is all very promising, but the transplantation times were very short, and you might be wondering why. These lungs aren’t perfect. There was bleeding from the blood vessels into the airways, and also some blood clotting — for this to work, the barrier membranes have to be essentially perfect, and they aren’t, yet. The poor rats’ lungs would have spluttered and fallen apart with prolonged use, and the blood clots would have led to thrombosis eventually.

Another problem, and one that has to be solved eventually if this is ever to work for human transplantations, is the source of the cellular components. The connective tissue stuff is only weakly antigenic, so isn’t going to provoke a strong immune response, but repopulating it with foreign cells brings the rejection problem roaring right back. What we need next for long term success is to find a source of lung adult stem cells, or a way to induce pluripotent stem cells to make the cell types needed.

That’s right, we need more human stem cell research. If you need a new lung, and we’re going to have to reengineer one for you in a dish, we’ll need a population of autologous cells — cells from you — to reseed an acellular matrix taken from a cadaver or a pig with lung tissue that won’t trigger an immune response.

This is a long way from being useful for humans, with two big problems still facing us, refinement of the tissue-engineering technique to produce more reliable and complete membranes, and the all-important stem cell research to allow us to create sources of immunologically-compatible cells, but the cool thing is that the questions that need to be answered are in crystal-clear focus, and there are strategies to get us the answers. Time and money and a less restrictive regulatory environment for stem cell work is all that is needed.


Petersen TH, Calle EA, Zhao L, Lee EJ, Gui L, Raredon MB, Gavrilov K, Yi T, Zhuang ZW, Breuer C, Herzog E, Niklason LE (2010) Tissue-engineered lungs for in vivo implantation. Science 329(5991):538-41.

The Problem With Science Is Dumb Non-Scientists

Man, that Heffernan article is turning out to be such an excellent marker for stupid. Now some Catholic wanker is citing it as supporting his claim that scientists are all nasty people, claiming that the problem with science is scientists. Being Catholic, you know exactly who he is going to complain about.

Heffernan writes about the meltdown over at Science Blogs. “Science Blogs”, as you may well remember is the home of blogger PZ Myers who is famous for advancing science by desecrating the Eucharist. While Myers is the most read of the misogamists at Science Blogs, his penchant for the unpleasant is rather standard fare.

“Science Blogs” has recently seen many of its bloggers leave in protest over the addition of a new nutrition blog called Food Frontiers. Science Blogs’ sin that PepsiCo sponsors the site. It is indubitable that nobody does righteous indignation quite like the ungodly.

Wow. Every sentence is wrong.

  1. There is no meltdown. There was risk of one, but Seed got their act together, and we’re all working away productively now.

  2. Cracker abuse is so 2008. Get over it. And no, that wasn’t science, nor did I claim it was: it was a protest against the inanity of reactionary Catholics.

  3. Misogamist? Moi? I’ve been happily married for over 30 years!

  4. Nobody quit over the addition of Food Frontiers.

  5. It was not a sin that Pepsi sponsored the site. The problem was that it was not labeled as an advertisement, and blurred a boundary between advertisement and content. That’s what got people upset, as well as a pattern of infrastructure neglect.

  6. Funny about that ungodly business. I’m definitely ungodly; I’m still here. So is Greg Laden. ERV thought it was all a tempest in a teacup. Jason Rosenhouse didn’t even seem to notice. The biggest ungodliest bloggers here seem to have had a range of reactions; and several of the people who decamped were theists.

Like I said, everyone who cites the Heffernan noise positively seems to be factually incompetent, including Heffernan herself.

The rest of that wanker’s article is just as bad. To defend his claim that scientists are all rotten people, he cites two examples. Galileo: not as nice as you’d think! After all, the Catholic church didn’t behead him, but only sentenced him to a life of confinement, and he had been very rude in mocking the Pope by putting his words into the mouth of a character called Simplicio in his dialogue.

His second case is Alfred Wegener, who he claims was persecuted by a scientific inquisition (every bit as bad as the Catholic inquisition, apparently — despite the fact that we don’t use thumbscrews). Here’s what scientists did to the discoverer of continental drift:

For his insight, Wegener was mocked and criticized and ultimately ostracized by the mainstream scientific establishment. Ultimately he died virtually unknown on an expedition trying to prove his theory.

Well, no. He was a well-respected meteorologist who died on an expedition to Greenland to study Arctic weather. He wasn’t ostracized at all, but was a working scientist right up until his death. His theory of continental drift was criticized and rejected in his lifetime, because he had no mechanism and because his evidence was all circumstantial. That’s what scientists are supposed to do — demand solid evidence. And when that evidence came in after Wegener’s death, the theory was accepted.

I’m kind of impressed. That Heffernan article is smoking out a lot of nobodies who are proudly standing up to demonstrate how stupid they are.