Dinosaur blood on CNN…but calm down, creationists

It’s an election day, but still CNN managed to post a lengthy article titled “Scientists say they’ve found the strongest evidence yet of red blood cells in a dinosaur bone”, which is nice. I like to see more science presented to the public. Most commendably, though, I read the entire article and nowhere does it question the age of the Earth, nor does it go scurrying to some dumbass creationist to get a quote. That’s very good and a journalistic step up!

I’m still trying to figure out why we should care — what soft tissue they find is grossly degraded and very little information can be extracted from it. It’s also contentious because of that great degradation. The blobs they identify as red blood cells are seriously deformed, and make me wonder how they identified them as cells in the first place.

(A) SEM image of 24 h HCl treated bone; and ii to xiii, SEM images showing selected RBC-like structures (Scale bar, 10 μm); (B) Photogrammetric 3D reconstruction of a selected RBC-like structure, generated from 72 SEM images

OK, those could be red blood cells. Maybe. I could be persuaded. But the CNN article also consulted Mary Schweitzer, the one person most associated with finding soft tissue in dinosaur bones, and she has reservations.

It’s also possible that the structures might not be remnants of red blood cells at all.

The findings do not meet established standards for identifying fossilized blood cells, said Mary Schweitzer, professor emeritus in the department of biological sciences at North Carolina State University. She was not involved in the study.

She questioned whether the structures’ shape and size sufficiently match red blood cells in living relatives of dinosaurs as well as the significance of hausmannite, the type of manganese oxide the study authors predominantly found. Schweitzer noted that this substance is not detected in living red blood cells.

So it’s a big maybe, but still, these are issues worth pursuing. The authors of the source paper are similarly cautious in their conclusions.

Mineralized RBCs from dinosaurs have not previously been reported, and their fossil morphology remains unknown; this work provides evidence for their appearance in this preserved form. These findings support the identification of the oldest known mineralized dinosaur RBCs containing molecules derived from heme.

Saying “containing molecules derived from heme” is a rather weak interpretation. It’s not surprising that there were chemicals in the living bone (of course!) and that they deteriorated over many tens of millions of years into modified chemical products — they didn’t evaporate or dematerialize — which is exactly what anyone should expect.

What do we do next with this corrupted information? I don’t know yet.

A discussion with Aron Ra

Aron Ra has been battling a particularly pretentious creationist who insist that he has evidence for creationism. Here’s the short list of his arguments:

  1. Taxonomically Restricted Essential Genes (orphan genes)
  2. pervasive molecular convergence
  3. upstream development gene regulatory networks cannot be mutated without lethal disturbance

Aron sent me a more thorough summary of his claims that I’ll include below the fold, but it was really a lot of pompous noise from a guy who had been gleaning scientific terms from the creationist literature, which he presented as evidence that refuted evolution and therefore, in creationist illogic, proved creation.

So we had a little dialogue about these claims. It could have been a debate, but the creationist ran away and refused to join the conversation.

[Read more…]

Biology don’t care

Stumbling across an online conversation between AI advocates is so weird, because they are using the language and concepts of evolutionary biology, but in such a crude, mangled, ignorant way that ultimately, they’ve stripped away the biology to replace it with a religious eschatology. There is a whole fantastic mythology they’ve developed in which they are battling for a paradisial end goal in which they become gods, fused with their technology of Artificial Super Intelligence (ASI) which doesn’t actually exist, but hey, we can measure our progress by looking at NVIDIA’s profit growth.

All they really care about is capitalism’s march into the future, and they’ll ignore all the little details. Build more data centers! If we don’t, we’ll stop all our evolutionary progress. I just want to yell at them that there is no such thing as evolutionary “progress,” and that you can’t change it, you can only vary environmental conditions such that you get a different outcome, and it won’t be the one you expect. They have a belief that they can control how they “evolve,” while not really understanding how evolution works.

So right now they are banging on about human extinction, and how AI can be either a boon or a bane to humanity, and how they need power to shape its direction Of course, that’s what it’s really about: power. They’ve got no idea what they’re doing except that getting legal and financial power over their technology is necessary to keep them rich and happy. It’s all a massive misdirection to whimper about the threat of AI while clutching at the power they want, which is mainly a childish illusion taken from science fiction (see Elon Musk for the premiere example of that.)

Dr. Émile P. Torres is one of the people opposing the nonsense, and I mostly agree with his take on it, but sometimes I feel like he’s so deep into it that he is losing track of how silly these people are. He’s expecting people to recognize how profoundly stupid the debate AI proponents are by attempting to explain their terminology, but then it ends up being an effort to define their terms.

With all this talk about human extinction right now, I am BEGGING people to understand the difference between TERMINAL and FINAL extinction. TESCREALists *only* care about final extinction, but nearly the entire public *misinterprets* them as warning about terminal extinction.

Oy. I always have to look up what stands for — it’s not a very intuitive acronym.

TESCREAL is a neologism proposed by computer scientist Timnit Gebru and philosopher Émile P. Torres. An acronym, it stands for Transhumanism, Extropianism, Singularitarianism, (modern) Cosmism, Rationalism (denoting the ideology of the rationalist community), Effective Altruism, and Longtermism. Gebru and Torres argue that these ideologies should be treated as an “interconnected and overlapping” group with shared origins. They claim these constitute a movement that allows its proponents to use the threat of human extinction to justify expensive or detrimental projects and consider it pervasive in social and academic circles in Silicon Valley centered on artificial intelligence. As such, the acronym is sometimes used to criticize a perceived belief system associated with Big Tech.

It’s a garbage pail word used to hold a lot of garbage, in other words, making it not particularly memorable. It’s also always disappointing because none of the letters stand for “Eugenics,” which is actually what it means, with all the argle-bargle nonsense philosophy assembled to hide that reality.

Torres goes on to explain the distinction between terminal and final extinction.

Terminal extinction is the disappearance of our species, full stop. Final extinction is the disappearance of our species such that we don’t leave behind any (worthy) posthuman successors. Since TESCREALists want a cosmic utopia/posthuman paradise through “aligned” ASI, what
they really mean when they say, “We must avoid human extinction” is: “We must avoid final human extinction.” Once posthumanity arrives, most don’t give a SHIT whether OUR SPECIES persists. Indeed, as I have documented in tremendous detail, many WANT terminal extinction to happen
once posthumanity arrives via “aligned” ASI. If what you care about is our species’ survival — i.e., avoiding terminal extinction — then these people are literal *pro-extinctionists*. DO NOT BE FOOLED by their rhetoric; by the sneaky language games they play!! They are NOT on
Team Human. They are on Team Posthuman. They care about our species surviving long enough to create “aligned” ASI. Once that happens, our species SHOULD die out. These people are not your friends–they are your enemies, insofar as you value humanity. All the quotes can be found
here. Read it and be very terrified that TESCREALists are running the AI companies and monopolizing the conversation. This is so deeply fucked up.

This handy diagram helps explain what he means. It’s a cartoon sketch of a cartoon concept held by a bunch of clowns.

What bugs me about the diagram is that it treats extinction and the branch point as two moments, sharp and discrete, in the history of the species, and ignores the fact that each line is actually a cloud of human variation bumbling its way into the future, and that what happens in extinction is actually a slow sad decline in the face of multiple environmental threats, and the branch point is just the gradual separation of the cloud. With some members of each cloud continuing to interbreed. There would be lots of exchange of genetic material.

In fact, in this longish essay on all these philosophies, the TESCREALists scarcely acknowledge the existence of genes, and seem to think their goal is to shed their genetics and abandon biology altogether.

Pro-extinctionist views go back to the very origins of the TESCREAL movement. In a 1989 article, published around the time Extropianism was taking shape, roboticist Hans Moravec describes himself as “an author who cheerfully concludes that the human race is in its last century, and goes on to suggest how to help the process along.” He claims that we’re developing “intelligent” machines that will soon “be able to manage their own design and construction, freeing them from the last vestiges of their biological scaffolding, the society of flesh and blood humans that gave them their birth.” He then proclaims that “this is the end,” as “our genes, engaged for four billion theirs in a relentless, spiraling arms race with one another, have finally outsmarted themselves”—by enabling the rise of world-dominating digital posthumans. But we shouldn’t fear this transition, he insists, because “post-biological life” in the form of advanced AIS, which he describes as “the children of our minds,” will prosper and flourish.

I hate to tell Moravec the troubling reality that there, beneath the shadow of his crystalline silicon post-human digital paradise, people will go on rutting in the earthy foundation, and that apparently his reality is going to rely on that biological foundation to hold it all up. The genes will go on, since they aren’t going to depend on venture capitalists and vast amounts of energy, water, and rare minerals to keep on going.

To me, it sounds like the AI weirdos are clinging to an outmoded model of orthogenesis, where evolution is linear and progressive, and wouldn’t even recognize the terms anagenesis (the gradual accumulation of variation in a single lineage) and cladogenesis (the splitting of a lineage into two). They’re too busy inventing nonsensical terminologies that aren’t contingent on understanding the reality of the process.

It’s all very silly, except for the fact that these bozos are trying to take over our government and economy.


I may be wrong. I didn’t wait for the STRONG AND SMART (High IQ!) person to weigh in on the matter.

The mass extinction of languages

My university offers courses in several languages with a relatively tiny population base, like Anishinaabe, the language of the indigenous peoples of the upper Midwest. I’m sometimes, but not often, asked why we bother, because these languages are so “impractical”, and it’s because they’re good for sharing the culture and history of groups of people, or because someone wants to understand their grandfather’s perspective (or the Teachings of the Seven Grandfathers). We should value the diverse ways of the multitude of different groups that have grown and changed throughout history. Unfortunately, many of these languages are dying out, and being replaced by a small number of “behemoth languages,” and we’re losing world languages at a steady rate — which is why it’s important to preserve as much as we can. This paper, The rise and fall of language diversity through the Holocene, tries to model the appearance and loss of languages over the last few millennia.

There are ~7500 languages signed and spoken in the world today, and they have a wide range of grammatical structures, vocabularies, speech sounds, signs, and usage rules. The study of language diversity has brought distinctive insights into how human behavior and cognition are shaped by ecological, social, and communicative pressures. The observable limits of linguistic diversity—features that are either universally present or absent in the world’s languages—have been at the core of what makes humans a distinctive species. Insights into language have also been used to understand other dimensions of human variation and homogeneity, including cultural and psychological traits. Over the past 500 years, all evidence points to a large systematic decrease in linguistic diversity, in parallel with the spread of a handful of behemoth languages, such as English, Spanish, Mandarin, Arabic, and Hindi. Nearly 5 billion people use at least 1 of the 10 most common languages, whereas half of the world’s languages are now endangered, and about four become dormant every year. This results in the loss of cultural and scientific knowledge embedded in minority languages and contributes to the unequal development in science, technology, medicine, and education that predominantly benefits speakers of the world’s largest languages.

I’m sure speakers of Anishinaabe recognize the definite advantages of speaking English, or maybe Mandarin in a few years, but they still want to retain a connection with their ancestors. Something similar happened to my immigrant great-great-grandparents — they spoke Norwegian, lived in communities of fellow Norwegian immigrants, and right up to my great-grandparents generation, were learning Norwegian and speaking it in church and family gatherings, but my generation has completely adopted the dominant English language of my region. We might still occasionally say “uff-da” or have lutefisk and lefse on holidays, but otherwise, we’re totally assimilated.

So about 4 languages a year are disappearing. The authors of that paper have attempted to quantitatively estimate the number of languages spoken over our history, and it’s surprising how much we’ve lost.

Fig. 4. Marginal results of our model aggregated across all conditions.
(A) The number of languages through the Holocene. Lighter shades of the curve correspond to progressively wider intervals comprising 10 to 90% of the predictions. Black lines indicate the interval containing 70% of the predictions.

Whoa. That’s a pretty sharp peak and a rather precipitous decline. The authors propose an explanation of what was going on.

Typically, the total number of languages has been increasing for most of the Holocene, mimicking the global expansion of human populations. This suggests that the rise of large-scale regional powers 4000 years ago did not generally and immediately deter the growth of linguistic diversity. Instead, most trajectories reached a maximum of 1000 to 3000 yr B.P. Although there is wide uncertainty in our estimates, most trajectories display an approximately 10-fold increase in the number of languages between the early Holocene and this point. This period, harboring tens of thousands of languages, has escaped previous theorizing.
In our model, this “golden age” was followed by an extremely rapid decrease in linguistic diversity, especially over the last two millennia. The process unfolded so quickly that the rate of language loss must have been even faster than the current pessimistic forecasts for the year 2100.

As populations grew, the number of languages also grew…until the rise of large empires and increased trade and communication, when a few successful dominant groups swallowed up the smaller populations. This model also makes the evolution of various languages non-adaptationist — some languages thrive, not because they are superior to other languages, but because they are piggy-backing on other properties of their population. Don’t bother trying to argue that English is better than Spanish, because what really matters is the strength and success of the population speaking the language. Languages don’t die because they’re inferior, but because they’re taken over by an expanding population.

It follows that this massive and biased reduction in linguistic diversity has shaped the relative abundance of different language traits. However, functional factors (such as learnability, efficient communication, or computational costs) are typically invoked instead to explain why some language traits are more common than others. But the intensity and recency of the linguistic diversity bottleneck make it a clear nonfunctional null hypothesis for understanding any skewed linguistic distribution.

Cool. I do have to envy linguists because at least they don’t get stupid demands like “Show me an Italian giving birth to a baby speaking Thai.” A lot of the elements of language evolution are similar to the properties of biological evolution, and seem to be equally incomprehensible to the ignorant.

Everything is the way it is because it got that way

My favorite quote/concept of all time is this one:

Everything is the way it is because it got that way.

D’Arcy Wentworth Thompson
(allegedly)

It affects everything I look at, and it’s the perfect sentiment for a developmental biologist/evolutionary biologist. It’s what I do for a living: see something, ask how it got that way (because that is the most important question), and try to track down the causal events that led to this outcome. It’s also the fundamental flaw in creationism, because they look at things and don’t care about the how or the process or the mechanism, it’s always explained by “god did it” with no interest in how their god did it.

But the quote always bugged me, too, because it’s not in On Growth and Form, Thompson’s awesome summary of his perspective. It’s a perfect expression of Thompson’s vision, so I continue to use it and think it, but it sure would be nice to know where it came from.

Fortunately, Glenn Branch tracked it down over a decade ago.

As far as I can tell, the line is actually due to Kenneth E. Boulding (1910–1993), whose obituary in The New York Times described him as “a much-honored but unorthodox economist, philosopher[,] and poet … renowned less for a single contribution to economics than for a large number of interesting intellectual and moral insights that both charmed and challenged his fellow social scientists.” In his 1953 “Toward a General Theory of Growth,” Boulding referred to “the D’Arcy Thomson [sic] principle … that at any moment the form of any object, organism, or organization is a result of its laws of growth up to that moment” (emphasis in original), citing On Growth and Form. (Boulding was a prolific writer, so there may be earlier statements of the principle that I missed.) By 1968, if not earlier, Boulding was using the familiar vernacular formulation, although he always credited the insight, if not the words, to Thompson.

It’s not hugely important — I’m not into hero-worship, although Thompson comes close to being a hero — but it’s nice to tidy up the record.

Mother of spiders!

Show me a 500 million year old chelicerate, and I’ll be happy for a day. Look at this beauty, Megachelicerax cousteaui, excavated from a Utah fossil bed.

Anatomic reconstructions of the dorsal (left) and ventral (right) morphologies. b, Artistic reconstructions by M. Hattori illustrating oblique views of the dorsal (top) and ventral (bottom) morphologies. The sanctacaridid-like morphology of the posteriormost body region is speculative. gi, gill (that is, a set of gill lamellae); te, telson.

Pretty cool, right? The best part of it is that pair of appendages at the very front of the animal — those are chelicerae, the biting/chomping/chewing/venom-injecting bits of a modern spider, that make them distinct from insects, which only have antennae at that end. That makes this the oldest known chelicerate ever discovered. It was a swimming marine animal, and doesn’t have the legs we associate with spiders — chelicerae evolved first, legs much later.

Also, this isn’t just the mother of spiders, but is also the mother of a huge family of cousins: horseshoe crabs, eurypterids, as well as spiders.

Megachelicerax documents the oldest stratigraphic occurrence of chelicerae (that is, uniramous, unichelate deutocerebral appendages) and bridges the simple body and limb organization of Cambrian megacheirans with the more derived anatomy of post-Cambrian synziphosurines and crown-group chelicerates. a, Simplified consensus topology based on Bayesian analysis (Mk model, 4 chains, 5,000,000 generations, 1/1,000 sampling resulting in 5,000 samples with 25% burn-in resulting in 3,750 samples retained); detailed results and comparison with parsimony provided in Extended Data Fig. 6. The numbers in parentheses correspond to the total number of podomeres and the number of chelae, respectively, present in the deutocerebral appendage. Taxa whose names are in bold font are illustrated in b–l. b–l, The morphology of the anterior body region in select taxa. b, Fuxianhuiid Chengjiangocaris kunmingensis (Cambrian, Stage 3). c, Artiopod Olenoides serratus (Cambrian, Wuliuan). d, Megacheiran Yohoia tenuis (Cambrian, Wuliuan). e, Megacheiran Haikoucaris ercaensis (Cambrian, Stage 3). f, Megacheiran Leanchoilia superlata (Cambrian, Wuliuan). g, Mollisoniid M. plenovenatrix (Cambrian, Wuliuan). h, Habeliid Habelia optata (Cambrian, Wuliuan). i, M. cousteaui (Cambrian, Drumian). j, Synziphosurine Dibasterium durgae (Silurian, Wenlock). k, Xiphosurid Limulus polyphemus (recent). l, Eurypterid Slimonia acuminata (Silurian, Llandovery–Wenlock).

That is one wildly successful tree. It just goes to show that you can go on to do great things even if your face looks like a nest of spiky clawed jointed tentacles.


Rudy Lerosey-Aubril, Javier Ortega-Hernández. A chelicera-bearing arthropod reveals the Cambrian origin of chelicerates. Nature, 2026; DOI: 10.1038/s41586-026-10284-2

Life from space? I have questions

Samples have been analyzed from two carbonaceous chondrites in space, Ryugu and Bennu, and they’ve been found to contain common organic molecules, specifically, the building blocks of DNA. That’s cool, not particularly surprising, and it’s good stuff to know…but then we get all these pop science articles speculating that life came from space. No, no, no — it tells us that these organic molecules are universal, that they can be assembled by all kinds of physical/chemical processes, and that nucleotides (for instance) do not require synthesis by living organisms. Chemistry is everywhere, but biology isn’t. Unfortunately, these kinds of observations always provoke people to babble about life, or at least the ingredients for life, falling from space. I don’t buy it.

Scientists have discovered all five nucleobases—the fundamental components of DNA and RNA—in pristine samples from the asteroid Ryugu, according to a study published on Monday in Nature Astronomy. The finding strengthens the case that the ingredients for life are abundant in the solar system and may have found their way to Earth from space, according to a study published on Monday in Nature Astronomy.

OK, yes, it’s quite likely that some organic molecules fell to Earth from outer space. But please, think a little bit quantitatively. There are clouds of organic molecules in space, but they are incredibly diffuse and poorly concentrated. There are asteroids that are made of condensed lumps of carbon with richer concentrations of these molecules, but they are drifting in the vast empty volumes of space, and only occasionally falling to Earth, adding droplets of nucleotides to the Earth’s oceans.

Meanwhile, the Earth itself is a gigantic crucible containing 1,386,000,000 cubic kilometers of water, with a complex pattern of heating and cooling, and immeasurable interactions with minerals and other organic molecules. It is a far weightier contributor to biochemistry than a thin, almost undetectable, vapor of scattered molecules in space. But these stories always get excited about the thin vapor rather than the fact that Earth itself is a rich churning cauldron of geochemistry that is going to be far more responsible for the wealth of biologically relevant chemistry we find ourselves swimming in.

This is not to discount how interesting these asteroid analyses are. They’re telling us that natural, unguided mechanisms can produce the biomolecules that make up life. The asteroids, though, are not likely to be where they originated here, on planet Earth, which is already a great place for building them.

The article says something else that irritated me.

Now, following the discovery of all five nucleobases in the Bennu pebbles, Koga and his colleagues have found the complete set in Ryugu. The findings lend weight to the so-called “RNA world” model of abiogenesis. In this hypothesis, early life on Earth depended solely on RNA as a self-replicating molecule, laying the biological groundwork for later, more complicated systems that involved DNA and protein-based organisms. The extraterrestrial samples from Ryugu and Bennu provide evidence that at least some of the nucleobases that made up these early lifeforms came from outer space.

No, this observation says nothing relevant to the RNA World hypothesis. It neither confirms nor refutes it. Nucleobases exist, we’ve known that for a long, long time, but I don’t believe that the earliest life on Earth depended solely on RNA, and finding nucleobases in a lifeless rock is not evidence that life was solely spawned from those few components. Were there no other molecules in them? No sugars, no amino acids, no polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, no carboxylic acids? There are a great many complex organic molecules found bubbling in the soup of our oceans, aren’t they a more likely source of life than a dead lump that’s been floating in space for billions of years?

Sorry. It’s a good bit of science, but I get cranky when I read these ill-informed unwarranted speculations that ignore more substantial science.

Why do creationists shy away from gene duplication?

A new review article on Evolutionary causes and consequences of gene duplication has dropped. It’s nothing novel to well-informed biologists, but it’s another nail in the coffin of creationism. Not that they will care; we’ve been explaining that common genetic mechanisms can routinely increase the information content of the genome, and that we can witness how new genes with new functions arise, and it never sinks in.

Gene duplication is the primary mechanism by which new genes emerge. Models and empirical studies have shown that paralogous genes are maintained because of dosage benefits, the partitioning of ancestral functions or the acquisition of new functions. However, the underlying molecular mechanisms and the relative importance of the factors driving evolution towards one fate or another have remained difficult to quantify. Recent advances in experimental and computational methods, such as gene editing, deep mutational scanning and ancestral sequence reconstruction, have enabled molecular analyses of duplicated gene evolution across timescales. Combined, these approaches are revealing how adaptive and non-adaptive evolutionary forces shape the modern fates of gene duplicates.

I imagine some might leap on the phrase “remained difficult to quantify,” but that’s the point of the paper: new techniques have been developed that allow us to quantify those details. The review specifically brings up multiple examples.

Divergence in interaction specificity following duplication has profound consequences on cell biology. For instance, the neofunctionalization of steroid receptors, a family of hormone-activated transcription factors with roles in development and stress responses, evolved following multiple rounds of WGD[whole genome duplication] in vertebrates. Although one paralogue maintained its ancestral interactions, the other acquired mutations, conferring on it the capacity to bind different hormones and DNA motifs. Studies of transcription factors in plants, yeast and other organisms have identified many paralogues that diverged in their specificity for transcription factor binding sites and distal regulatory elements. Such divergence in interaction specificity has enabled multiple species to acquire novel regulatory modules over time.

The conclusion discusses some of those mechanisms.

Evolutionary biologists have long been interested in the fate of duplicated genes. Long-standing questions include which factors promote the fixation or long-term retention of duplicates, and their divergence in terms of sequence, expression, interactions and function. Multiple emerging technologies have enabled directly testing how adaptive and non-adaptive forces drive the evolution of paralogues. For example, fitness functions derived by tuning expression level with synthetic biology tools have enabled testing whether increases in protein abundance due to duplications are beneficial or not. Deep mutational scanning and comparisons between extant and reconstructed pre-duplication ancestral sequences facilitate the identification of mutations that alter a particular function. In particular, comparisons between different paralogues have shown that the fixation of function-altering mutations is often contingent on the presence of other mutations that originally had no effect on fitness. Similarly, other paralogues can become dependent on each other if their heteromers become the only functional unit. Therefore, multiple sources of evidence highlight the role of non-adaptive processes in the evolution of duplicated genes.

Continuing to combine and develop new methodologies will help to address open questions about the fates of paralogues. Although the likelihood of functional divergence between paralogues increases with the age of the duplication, the time required to reach functional divergence might vary depending on the pair of paralogues. In fact, multiple underlying factors may contribute to variation in the rate of functional divergence, such as the type of function performed by the paralogues. In turn, progressive changes in functions such as catalysis and binding specificity are likely to modify the fitness functions of the paralogues, allowing natural selection to distinguish between them. Ultimately, assaying such subtle and progressive mutational effects on gene function will help to better trace the evolutionary history of paralogues and the forces that shaped them.

It’s a nice summary of the problems and potentials for studying evolutionary gene duplications. I’m adding it to my list of papers to study in greater depth.

Creationists will pretend it doesn’t exist.

Angel F. Cisneros, Soham Dibyachintan, Frédéric Bédard, Simon Aubé, Pascale Lemieux & Christian R. Landry (2026) Evolutionary causes and consequences of gene duplication. Nature Reviews Genetics https://doi.org/10.1038/s41576-026-00935-5.

Phenotypic plasticity is part of evolution, too

This is a cool short video that will annoy phrenologists and “race realists”. Analysis of a 12,000+ year old skeleton of a young native American woman, now named Naia, who fell into a cenote and died were initially interpreted to imply evidence of multiple migrations into the Americas — the morphologically distinct shape of her skull was used to suggest that she was not ancestral to modern American Indians, but belonged to a separate branch of the family tree.

I’ve heard similar arguments about Kennewick Man, the 8,000+ year old skeleton found in Washington state. His remains looked “caucusoid,” therefore could not be Native American, and therefore laws that protected native remains did not apply. DNA showed otherwise. It turns out that “looks like” is a poor criterion for assigning genetic relatedness.

Same with Naia. DNA testing showed that she really was related to modern South American natives.

Why was her skull so different from the people she was genetically related to? Scientists once thought that distinctive skull shapes were rigid markers of separate ancestries, implying that robust ancient populations in America, and even Australia and Europe, must be genetically distinct from the populations that came later. But Naia proved that the two population theory was wrong. The dramatic differences in skull shape were not due to different blood lines, but to rapid evolutionary adaptation. Scientists now realize that skull shape is highly plastic and changes based on what we do.

I hope that there is a growing appreciation of the concept of phenotypic plasticity — we are products of both our genes and our environment.