It’s an election day, but still CNN managed to post a lengthy article titled “Scientists say they’ve found the strongest evidence yet of red blood cells in a dinosaur bone”, which is nice. I like to see more science presented to the public. Most commendably, though, I read the entire article and nowhere does it question the age of the Earth, nor does it go scurrying to some dumbass creationist to get a quote. That’s very good and a journalistic step up!
I’m still trying to figure out why we should care — what soft tissue they find is grossly degraded and very little information can be extracted from it. It’s also contentious because of that great degradation. The blobs they identify as red blood cells are seriously deformed, and make me wonder how they identified them as cells in the first place.

(A) SEM image of 24 h HCl treated bone; and ii to xiii, SEM images showing selected RBC-like structures (Scale bar, 10 μm); (B) Photogrammetric 3D reconstruction of a selected RBC-like structure, generated from 72 SEM images
OK, those could be red blood cells. Maybe. I could be persuaded. But the CNN article also consulted Mary Schweitzer, the one person most associated with finding soft tissue in dinosaur bones, and she has reservations.
It’s also possible that the structures might not be remnants of red blood cells at all.
The findings do not meet established standards for identifying fossilized blood cells, said Mary Schweitzer, professor emeritus in the department of biological sciences at North Carolina State University. She was not involved in the study.
She questioned whether the structures’ shape and size sufficiently match red blood cells in living relatives of dinosaurs as well as the significance of hausmannite, the type of manganese oxide the study authors predominantly found. Schweitzer noted that this substance is not detected in living red blood cells.
So it’s a big maybe, but still, these are issues worth pursuing. The authors of the source paper are similarly cautious in their conclusions.
Mineralized RBCs from dinosaurs have not previously been reported, and their fossil morphology remains unknown; this work provides evidence for their appearance in this preserved form. These findings support the identification of the oldest known mineralized dinosaur RBCs containing molecules derived from heme.
Saying “containing molecules derived from heme” is a rather weak interpretation. It’s not surprising that there were chemicals in the living bone (of course!) and that they deteriorated over many tens of millions of years into modified chemical products — they didn’t evaporate or dematerialize — which is exactly what anyone should expect.
What do we do next with this corrupted information? I don’t know yet.











