An atheist response…and an invitation to a livestream


I was bored and trawled through a Christian site to address some silly questions.

Hey! Next week I’m planning to do a livestream to talk about Lucy Cooke’s Bitch, an excellent book about biology’s long history of bad science whenever the subject of women comes up, and going through many examples of the complexity of sex in zoology, and also talking about the short shrift women get in science. If you have any interests along those lines, or have read the book, or are, like, a woman who’d like to make sure the man talking about this subject stays in line, send me an email and let me know what times work for you, and maybe we’ll talk.

Comments

  1. Reginald Selkirk says

    You found these questions on stream.org, but the original appears to be on Brown’s own site askdrbrown.org, where you can drop answers in the comments.
    I notice (22:55) that Michael Brown is one of your Patreon supporters. I’m going to guess that is a different Michael Brown.

  2. rwt6115 says

    About 60 years ago I became an atheist. On a Sunday after a particularly long church service my father who was the son of a minister asked a question. Do you believe everything that was in the service? Now this was a church and a minister that my father had selected for us to attend. My immediate impression as a teenager was NO. There were too many things in the sermon particularly that did not jive with the science that I knew. I have been an atheist ever since. I can’t prove there is no god but here is no evidence of one. Now you should know that my grandfather (the minister) became an economics professor (with a PhD), My father got a PhD in Physics and I have a PhD in Geology. I have never forgotten that experience. This video just reaffirmed my reaction to religious bigots.

  3. Alt-X says

    Why aren’t you a Christian? “Because I’ve met Christians”.

    Why don’t you believe in the Christian god? “Because I’ve read the bible”.

  4. maggie says

    Giving my head a shake while reading those questions would have given me a huge migraine.

  5. Akira MacKenzie says

    @ 8

    The RationalWiki article doesn’t go into it, but I recall that Brown sent a letter to the Israeli government, asking that they apologize on behalf of Jews for the crucifixion of Jesus.

  6. dstatton says

    My answer is that I never gave it much thought, and when I did, it seemed highly implausible.

  7. says

    Thanks for the link to Dr. Brown’s questions. Here’s a response I just posted there:

    Dear Dr. Brown: Now that you’ve asked your “honest questions for atheists” and got at least a few honest and substantive answers, I’d like to ask YOU a question: when and where do you plan to publicly address, process and respond to the answers you’ve got?

    I ask this because for several decades I’ve heard many many Christians publicly asking questions of atheists, and never showing any sign that they’ve ever seen or heard any answers from anyone. The attention-grabbing headlines are either “Umpteen Honest and Sincere Questions for Atheists” or “Umpteen Important Questions Atheists Can Never Ever Answer (#5 Will Rock Your World!)”. I know for a fact that many atheists have indeed been answering those questions, for about as long as Christians have been asking them; and yet none of those oh-so-sincere questioners have ever shown any sign of hearing any of the answers.

    In fact, you’re the only questioner I’ve yet seen who even provides a space for us to post our answers; which is why I’m coming here to ask you: What is your response to our answers now that you’ve actually got them? I eagerly await your response. Thank you.

    His comment “system” thingie removed all my paragraph breaks, and I had to re-insert them. That’s just one of my many complaints about the organization and layout of his blog.

  8. Reginald Selkirk says

    @14: “Mitch McConnell has too much power and is destroying democracy.”

  9. Ed Peters says

    #13 Raging Bee. Excellent. I agree with you. Theists of all stripes do a lot of JAQing off, but precious little processing of the answers they get. You might even be forgiven for suspecting that they are hoping no one will answer, so they can offer that as proof of their belief’s irrefutability.

  10. unclefrogy says

    it is their conceit that they think no one can answer their questions which are so overwhelming that the only answer possible is god which ever one they believe.

  11. Derek Vandivere says

    #3 / rwt6115:

    Same – I was 7, we left (Methodist) church, Mom asked if I wanted to keep going to church, and I said not really. 45 years later, still an atheist.

    dersk

  12. Owlmirror says

    @Raging Bee:

    I have a sneaking suspicion that Michael L Brown will collect the comments to his questioning post, and will at some point either pick the weakest responses or the most easily misconstrued responses, and construct one or more sermons or additional blog posts based on how sad [his misconstrual of] those responses are.

    Go ahead, tell me I’m too cynical.

  13. says

    I’ve seen his other headlines, and no, you’re not being “cynical” at all. My own guess is that he’ll either totally ignore and forget the whole “sincere questions” thing, or just make up “answers” that fit his script. I’ve seen no response, or promise of a response, so far. The best we can hope for from that kind of Christian is that he’ll quote each answer verbatim, followed by “But the Bible sez that’s wrong!”

Leave a Reply