My politics tend towards anti-punitive. That is, I tend to favor smaller and shorter punishments for criminals. No particular reasons for it, no commitment to any philosophy or political movement. It’s moral intuition. When I imagine the appropriate punishment for a criminal, and I compare to what’s actually done, I find actual punishments sound too harsh to me.
This has long put me at odds with certain kinds of advocacy against sexual violence. I am in favor of holding perpetrators accountable, acknowledging and caring for victims, and pushing back against the culture that teaches men to become perpetrators. I am not and have never been in favor of harsher punishments for perpetrators.
Let me clarify. Many perpetrators face virtually no punishment. Victims are subject to ostracization and retaliation, and thus deterred from making any accusations. When accusations are made, the friends and community of the perpetrator close ranks and defend them. Police do virtually nothing. For the perpetrators who face no punishment, or are even socially rewarded, yes I favor a punishment that is harsher than zero. But for those perpetrators who are successfully held accountable, I do not advocate harsher and harsher punishments.
