Proof That God Exists?

That’s the title of the site, anyway, Proof That God Exists. It ain’t.

It’s a dreary exercise in the fallacy of the excluded middle. You are lead through a series of binary choices, in which you are asked to choose one alternative or the other, with the goal of shunting you to the desired conclusion, which is, of course, that God exists. Building on a fallacy is bad enough, but even worse, it can’t even do that competently — it cheats. All of the options are designed to bounce you to only one line of reasoning, and if you don’t play the designer’s game, it gets all pissy at you and announces that you aren’t serious and you should go away. Some proof, eh?

The one argument it channels you into is this one: there must be an absolute source of absolute morality, therefore, God. Francis Collins would be quite happy with it, I’m sure. When I took it, I agreed that there is an absolute truth (because I believe reality exists), I believe in logic and mathematics, but then when it asked if there is an absolute morality, I had to say no. Morality is a derived property generated by the interactions of individuals; it is not imposed on us from above. And that’s where the site gets nasty.

It gives you two choices: “Molesting children for fun is absolutely morally wrong” and “Molesting children for fun could be right”. If you answer the former, it bounces you back to the question about whether absolute moral laws exist…therefore God. You don’t get to choose something like “Molesting children is damaging to our species and harmful to individuals, and I agree with the cultural proscription against it”. If you answer the latter, you get their surrender message.

You have denied that absolute moral laws exist but you appeal to them all the time. You say that rape IS wrong because you know that it IS wrong and not just against your personal preference. Unless you reconsider your stand on this matter, your road to this site’s proof that God exists ends here. It is my prayer that you come to understand how inconsistent and irrational this line of thinking is and return to seek the truth.

I don’t think they understand the concept of a proof, or logic for that matter.

It is rather interesting that this is the most common “proof” people are throwing at us lately, this idea that the existence of a common morality in human cultures is evidence for a supreme being. It’s a sign of how weak and pathetic their arguments have become.

A Republican push-poll

The Republicans are asking the party faithful to fill out a biased poll. The purpose is not to get a snapshot of public opinion, but to mislead people by presenting leading questions. Or, as Mike Haubrich explains it:

The point of push-polling in politics is not to gather opinion, it is to “push” towards a certain viewpoint by exposing the opposite viewpoint as being untenable.

If you’ve got a few minutes and want to cause some bafflement among conservative pollsters, have fun with it.

Ken Ham commissions a scientific study

So right away, you know not to trust it. No details are given, we are simply told that “a major study he commissioned by a respected researcher unveils for the first time in a scientific fashion the startling reasons behind statistics that show two-thirds of young people in evangelical churches will leave when they move into their 20s”. That’s actually a nice result from my perspective…so it’s too bad that I can’t believe what he claims.

Also, since it is Ken Ham, he knows exactly what the problem is and what we need to do to keep more kids in the faith.

The book explores a number of reasons for the findings, but Ham sees one overarching problem that is related to how churches and parents have taught youth to understand the Genesis account of creation.

Ham — who believes in a literal six-day creation that happened 6,000 to 10,000 years ago — says the church opened a door for the exodus of youth, beginning in the 19th century, when it began teaching that “the age of the Earth is not an issue as long as you trust in Jesus and believe in the resurrection and the Gospel accounts.”

I get it. His “study” is actually propaganda for his “museum”.

Science wants to reward good online science education resources

If you’ve been building a site for science education, you’ll want to looking into this: The Science Prize for Online Resources in Education (SPORE).

The Science Prize for Online Resources in Education (SPORE) has been established to encourage innovation and excellence in education, as well as to encourage the use of high-quality on-line resources by students, teachers, and the public. In 2009, the prize will recognize outstanding projects from all regions of the world that bring freely available online resources to bear on science education.

Winning projects should reinforce one or more of the four strands of science learning recommended by the National Academies (Taking Science to School: Learning and Teaching Science in Grades K-8 [2007], National Academies Press; see also Bruce Alberts, “Redefining Science Education,” Science 23 January 2009: 323, 437) and be consistent with the science education standards published by the National Academies (National Science Education Standards [1996], National Academies Press) and the AAAS (Benchmarks for Science Literacy).

There are more details at the link. This is a non-trivial exercise, so don’t think you can put it together in a flash…but if you’ve got something you’ve been building for a while, look into getting some recognition for it.

Finally, a homeopathic medicine that actually works!

It’s called Zicam Cold Remedy Nasal gel. Unfortunately, it doesn’t do a thing for colds…all it can do is destroy your sense of smell. It wasn’t caught before it was put on the market, because, get this:

The FDA said Zicam Cold Remedy was never formally approved because it is part of a small group of remedies that are not required to undergo federal review before launching. Known as homeopathic products, the formulations often contain herbs, minerals and flowers.

Minerals. Like lots of zinc, which can cause nerve damage.

We’re sorry, China

It’s nothing personal, but we’re getting a little worried about the economic competition you’ve been delivering lately, so we need to even the playing field a little. A couple of Christian evangelical real estate billionaires have created a Noah’s Ark tourist attraction in Hong Kong. Pretty soon you’ll be as stupid as we are.

Oh, wait! “Tourist attraction”? It’s supposed to poison the minds of the locals, not traveling Westerners! Dang. Maybe we can ship a few container ships full of Bibles and Chick tracts over there instead.

Frank Drake speaks

You’ve all heard of the Drake Equation, a little exercise in rough estimation which attempts to approximate the number of intelligent, technological species in our galaxy. Here it is, if you haven’t:

N=R* x fp x ne x fl x fi x fc x L

R* is the average rate of star formation per year in our galaxy
fp is the fraction of those stars that have planets
ne is the average number of planets that can potentially support life per star that has planets
fl is the fraction of the above that actually go on to develop life at some point
fi is the fraction of the above that actually go on to develop intelligent life
fc is the fraction of civilizations that develop a technology that releases detectable signs of their existence into space
L is the length of time such civilizations release detectable signals into space.

I think it’s an interesting exercise; even though most of the terms are rough guesses, nothing more, when you stack them all together you soon discover that even the most charitable estimates suggest that we could at best be dealing with only a handful of potential equals in the whole galaxy, and the galaxy is a very, very large place. (I’m not one of the charitable estimators: I’d guess very low on those last 3 parameters, and get an N of less than one.)

Drake is interviewed in Spiegel, and he leans toward the optimistic side, in more ways than one. He seems to think that any aliens out there would have matured out of primitive hostility (or survived selection for cooperation), which I don’t buy. I suspect that if the human race could leave our solar system, we’d be a rather rapacious horde in our little corner of the galaxy, so I think that human temperament and history argues against that hopeful wish.

Anyway, another tidbit that I think argues against benign aliens: intelligent species would also carry a load of delusions, just like us.

Drake: Actually, one of my worst nightmares is that we find a signal and it will be an advertisement for a religious cult.

SPIEGEL ONLINE: Why would that be a nightmare?

Drake: I want to learn more about a civilization than just its belief in the supernatural. Religion is an important part of the culture but may not help to improve the quality of life in a civilization. Maybe their religion is a really good one, but I doubt it.

SPIEGEL ONLINE: That makes it sound like you’re not religious.

Drake: I am not a religious person.

Everyone chant: One of us!

Now that that’s out of the way, the possibility he advances is a horrifying prospect. If religion is a natural and intrinsic part of a sapient’s way of thinking (which I don’t believe, by the way, but I’m often told by the pro-religion camp that it is), it’s another reason to hope we never meet an extraterrestrial, space-faring species. I’m pretty sure they wouldn’t believe in Jesus, Mohammed, Vishnu, or Xenu. And all I need is space missionaries knocking on my door on Saturday mornings.

Pepper an Australian poll

A majority (60%) of Australians think same-sex marriage is just fine. The story has an associated poll, though, and the results are tipped just a little bit the other way. What’s wrong here? Fix it!

Are you in favour of same-sex marriage in Australia?

Yes
44%
No
55%

We might have some opposition on this one. A Christian, anti-science, anti-choice, anti-gay organization called Salt Shakers is pushing this poll, too. We must defeat them. Steamroller the salt shakers!