A very carefully calculated piece of political propaganda


Also a good blog post on the Mail on Sunday’s amusing prank, at Where’s the Benefit?

Beyond the horror that they did this to a charity, we need to be very aware of exactly what was done here, and it is a far murkier story than many will realise. The Trussell Trust has been flagging up the massive growth in people seeking their help for the last year or more, and this is not a narrative that the government is happy with, in particular it seems to be driving Iain Duncan Smith towards apoplexy, and this week saw the launch of a coordinated attack on the Trussell Trust in the pages of, surprise, surprise, The Daily Mail with the claim that “Food bank charity ‘is misleading the public’: Claim that 1m need food parcels ‘just self promotion’” and ‘DWP sources’ (presumably code for IDS’s Special Advisors) alleging the charity was engaged in “misleading and emotionally manipulative publicity-seeking“. There is something deeply ironic that IDS, who brandishes his Catholicism at every opportunity, should choose Easter Week to launch a coordinated attack on a charity dedicated to feeding those in need.

It is and then again it isn’t. The Catholicism I’m most familiar with, that of Ireland, is all about being viciously cruel to poor people. Maybe IDS’s Catholicism is of that variety; the “call them scum, it will encourage them to stop being poor” variety.

This MoS story is actually a very carefully calculated piece of political propaganda designed to allow IDS and the Tory party to deny the reality of the foodbank crisis. Tory DWP minister and IDS-mouthpiece Lord Freud has repeatedly tried to claim that people go to foodbanks not because they are in need, but because it is free food; that strategy hasn’t been working because no one believes him. The MoS story clearly sets out with the intent of proving that Freud’s position is true, by inventing a story that makes it true. It then further twists the narrative by alleging that many of the people receiving food parcels were asylum-seekers, linking the foodbank issue to the xenophobic fears of the Mail’s Little Englander readership, and seeks to undermine the Trussell Trust figures by implying that there is massive fraud across the entire foodbank system.

Well, Cameron said “we’re” a Christian country. There’s your Christianity.

 

Comments

  1. says

    Tory DWP minister and IDS-mouthpiece Lord Freud has repeatedly tried to claim that people go to foodbanks not because they are in need, but because it is free food

    Tells you a lot about Tory ministers, little about poor people.
    It’s them who take, take, take (oh, and fortunately they are in the wonderful position to decide exactly how much they can take). Poor people often think 20 times before they approach a charity and ask for help, because it’s damn stigmatizing and shameful for them.

  2. Blanche Quizno says

    “the “call them scum, it will encourage them to stop being poor” variety.”

    Yes, ho ho, satire, that’s rich, right?

    Fox Business commentator Todd Wilemon said just that:

    Not all of them cannot afford health care; they’ve made the choice to go bare. … I’ll be honest – if you’re poor, stop being poor. … That’s a good idea.”

    http://www.truthdig.com/avbooth/item/if_youre_poor_stop_being_poor_says_fox_commentator_to_daily_show_20140308

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *