Quantcast

«

»

Sep 02 2011

He taught me critical thinking

Another escapee is Libby Anne. She gives a ten-part account of being a good child of Patriarchy and then of being turned around.

The childhood is by no means all horrible, even seen from the outside. Much of it is quite appealing.

I also enjoyed gardening. We always had large gardens, and we children did a great deal of the tending and weeding, sometimes waking at dawn in the summer months to weed before the summer heat. In addition to learning to garden, I found books at a homeschool convention about edible plants and medicinal herbs and set out to teach myself these important skills. I learned that dandelions could be eaten in salads, that plantain was good for mosquito bites, and that raspberry leaves made an excellent tea for pregnant women (such as my mother). I even tried to make flour out of clover. I loved walking through marshy areas or abandoned lots looking for plants that matched the pictures in my books, becoming excited at each new find. I knew that a proper wife should be able to forage for food and prepare herbal remedies, especially if the government collapsed and the country descended into anarchy as we always feared it would.

The proper wife bit and the descent into anarchy bit are a downer, but then that’s apparently what it was like: a mix of patriarchal doctrine and pleasantly industrious rural life.

But the patriarchal doctrine had some thorns even then.

My mother was constantly reading books like Me? Obey Him? as she strove to be a better, more submissive wife. This was difficult for my mother, for she was a very strong woman. I watched her war with herself as she tried to reconcile her strong spirit with the submission she believed in so steadfastly. I watched her cry over it, watched it eat away at her. My father, usually a reasonable man, became quite upset with my mother if he felt she was infringing on his authority. His most common response was to give her the silent treatment, and that was enough. In response, my mother generally first felt indignation and then blamed herself for not submitting enough and resolved again and again to do better. While my parents loved each other dearly, this tension added strain to their relationship, and I could see it.

The sad thing is that it’s an artificial strain, a worked up strain. A reasonable man has no need to think he has an authority that his wife shouldn’t infringe on. If both had thought of each other as partners and equals, they would still have disagreed about things, but without doctrinal anger or resentment or guilt. Nonsense about authority and submission is an extra element. It’s truly sad that people mess themselves up this way. It’s a disaster that they teach their children to do the same.

In addition to teaching me about theology, politics, and current events, my father taught me to think. He taught me critical thinking, and told me never to believe something just because someone says it, but to always question everything and follow truth wherever it leads. He taught me to never trust authority for authority’s sake and to never be afraid of truth. He taught me logic and how to recognize logical fallacies. Of course, the context of all this was learning to rebut worldly ideas and bogus concepts like global warming and evolution.

Not patriarchy or submission or god.

But then Libby Anne went to college…and as so often happens, the doors opened.

I began to have theological and political conversations with a number of non-Christians. I worked hard to show them the perfection of the Bible, the evidence of young earth creationism, the evils of abortion, and the love of God.

Strangely, I found a surprising number of my arguments rebutted by arguments I had never heard before. I was told that there were serious problems with creationism, ethical issues with the Bible, and more affective ways to decrease abortion than banning it. I turned to my resources, my books and websites on creationism, theology, and conservative politics, and I tried again. And again. And again. But some things just didn’t add up. I paused my arguments to do some serious research, and I was astounded by what I found.

An open door.

 

4 comments

1 ping

Skip to comment form

  1. 1
    James Sweet

    Heh, I have to sort of chuckle at the “especially if the government collapsed and the country descended into anarchy as we always feared it would” stuff, because there’s a tiny element of that in my own thinking. I like learning how to do stuff as much “from scratch” as possible*, mostly cuz I just like that kind of thing, but sometimes I mentioned only half-jokingly, “I’ll be the one that knows how to X when the apocalypse comes…” It’s not necessarily a bad thing to, now and then, contemplate what you would do with yourself and your family if civilization as we know it collapsed… as long as it doesn’t consume your life or drive some crazy ideology, of course.

    * I say “from scratch” with a certain amount of reservation, because as Carl Sagan pointed out, “If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe.” QFT. I occasionally am asked “Did you make this from scratch?” and will answer with something along the lines of, “Well, I didn’t mill the flour, I just bought that at a store…”

  2. 2
    docslacker

    It is an amazing account and a very important glimpse into the mindset of the extreme evangelical movement. They want homeschooling to keep their children ignorant and therefore accepting of their dogma.

  3. 3
    Johnny Jefferson

    Fantastically revealing thank you, It is my opinion your current readers might possibly want a lot more posts of this nature keep up the great work.

  4. 4
    Tim Cole

    Particularly good thank you, I do believe your trusty visitors may want a whole lot more reviews such as this keep up the excellent work.

  1. 5
    Daylight Atheism > Escaping Christian Patriarchy

    [...] of Butterflies and Wheels has been writing some excellent posts lately about the abuse and oppression of women in Christian communities. One of them led me [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite="" class=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>