The gnu-flavored atheist movement was founded in part by people who favored military adventurism against muslim-majority countries, chiefly Christopher Hitchens. That movement quickly morphed into a broad liberalism which appealed to less bloodthirsty people like you and I. That was revealed to be paper thin cover for a reactionary mindset during Elevatorgate, which is why FtB is so much smaller than SciBlogs had been before the schism.
Elevatorgate’s queen was Abby ERV, who basically abandoned pro-vax activism in favor of a 24-7 misogyny campaign. Together with Gamergate and the MRA and incel movements, these were the foundational kernel of the neo-nazism that has taken over the USA. If you meet a rethuglican bro under fifty, he probably spent some time in one or more of these online communities, or their descendants.
If we take that piece of shit ERV as being an icon of atheo-skepticism who contributed to fascism, what of her opposite number in the anti-vax movement, Jenny McCarthy? Anti-vaxxing (and medical woo in general) used to be strongly associated with liberals, with left of center people. When conservatives embraced anti-vaxxing, those people swung hard. I’ve had the misfortune of talking to some of them. Maybe they have a left belief or two among the gallery of monsters in their skulls, but they are ardent supporters of shitler, and many are Qanon as well. Both pro- and anti-vaxxing contributed to fascism.
So here’s my moment of bothsiderism. Who contributed more to our present political ruination, gnu atheists or antivaxxers? Abby ERV or Jenny McCarthy? Even tho the actor was much more famous, I honestly do not know the answer to this question. Both movements had some amount of access to the halls of power via lobbyists or cultural prestige.
In composing this post, I found myself reflecting on the strange political moments and movements that added up to Nazi USA. That broad tent is wild as hell. It’s so much easier to take the world apart than to make it better. The locust swarms flow into and out of each other, devouring hope and love.
I do not fault anyone for feeling doomed and destroyed, but I still have hope for all of you, that you keep it together, that you enjoy the things you can, and you don’t feel too overwhelmed by the overwhelming circumstances. We’ve got each other and we’re still alive, baby.
–