Well, it’s been a year since my post in response to the attack last October. The months since have contained even more horror than I expected, and it doesn’t seem even close to ending. I’ve been trying to write a post about it for months now, and I keep finding myself unequal to the task. It’s all so big, so monstrous, and it seems like there’s nothing I can do. Israel wants wholesale genocide, and the US government seems to be willing to provide them with the means to carry it out. Israel wants regional war, and probably to expand their genocide to the whole area they consider to be “Greater Israel”, and from everything the Biden administration has done, they seem to want all that too. They tell long-debunked lies to justify the endless slaughter, they pay half-hearted lip-service to the idea of peace, while eagerly stoking the engines of war. They smear and demonize any who protest for peace, or speak out for justice, including members of their own party, all while the world is being shown the mangled corpses of innocent children and adults, and the perpetrators are so open about their hatred that they will protest for the right to rape prisoners to death.
Nothing I could possibly write would come close to covering everything that has happened, or the scale of hatred and sadism on display, so I’m not going to try. What I will do, is talk about one aspect of all this that I haven’t seen mentioned much in the possibly naive effort to persuade those still not convinced that what we have been witnessing is, in fact, a genocide.
There’s been talk over the last year of the tactics being used – Bombing civilians, starvation, disease, and so on. I’ve seen a couple other people mention it, but when it comes to the tactics of genocide, I would argue that what has been happening in Gaza has been a death march.
In brief, a death march is when you take a group of whatever minority is being subjected to genocide, and force them to walk for days, weeks, or months on end, with little to no food, water, medical attention, or shelter. This serves two purposes for the perpetrators- the most obvious, with marches like the Trail of Tears, is that it physically removes the victims from land that the perpetrators want. The main purpose of it is to kill as many of those people as possible, while maintaining the “plausible” deniability of merely transporting them, or of protecting them from some greater harm (usually threatened by the perpetrators themselves). The death marches of the Holocaust make this a little clearer, as they were generally moving Jewish victims between concentration camps, and many of them happened nearer the end of World War 2, as part of the “final solution”.
What has been happening in Gaza is just as nakedly genocidal in nature and intent as what the Nazis were doing. Since last October, we’ve seen the cycle repeat again and again: Israel tells civilians to evacuate to a “humanitarian zone” where they will be safe from bombing. That humanitarian zone is then bombed anyway, before the civilians are told to evacuate again to a different part of Gaza, which is also not safe. They’ve gone back and forth across the Gaza strip for months now, through an increasingly devastated landscape. Rather than forcing Palestinians to move from one place to another, they’re forcing them to walk around and around the rubble of their own homes, which used to provide shelter, being bombed, sniped, and otherwise attacked all the while.
Somewhere around January, or last December, the “official” death toll stopped climbing. This was largely because Israel had destroyed most of the infrastructure and killed most of the people who would be able to provide those numbers. I feel comfortable saying the actual number is in the hundreds of thousands, because Gaza has been in a state of famine for months now, while also dealing with the total destruction of their sanitation system, and the absence of clean water. Those not killed by bombs, bullets, or the elements, are being killed by starvation, thirst, and disease. All of these conditions are ones that are known to cause death. People who are tired, hungry, and thirsty are also more vulnerable to all forms of infection. So are people who’ve had their limbs blown off, or gotten other injuries. They can’t heal if they can’t rest, and they can’t rest if they’re constantly under attack, and being forced to move around.
It is not plausible that the perpetrators of this do not know what they are doing, and how many will die as a result.
Israel likes to pretend that it’s doing the civilian population of Gaza a favor by telling them in advance to move away from where they’re going to bomb, but even that “kindness” is designed for mass murder. It’s been one endless death march, with the people of Gaza being given a choice between being killed directly and labeled as “terrorists”, a title which is now conferred upon anyone who commits the crime of coming in contact with an Israeli bomb or bullet, or dying of starvation and disease while trying to avoid that fate. It is also clear that Israel will not stop until they are forced to stop.
I’m not going to go into every detail of how to “solve” the situation in this post, but step one seems pretty obvious – the international community (especially the US) needs to cease all support for the nation of Israel, and place them under sanctions until the killing stops, and they agree to actual peace negotiations. Actual pressure needs to be put on Israel, because they have demonstrated that they have no better nature to appeal to – they are in this for total genocide.
billseymour says
I spotted that the first time that Israel “warned” the Palestinians to move to southern Gaza because they’d be bombing the north, and then promptly bombed the north-sourth route that folks were using. I hadn’t connected that to death marches in general, or the Trail of Tears in particular, though, until your post. Thanks.
Abe Drayton says
It took me a long time to see it too, and I’ve only seen a couple other people talking about it. I don’t have a lot of reach, and I’m probably not the best messenger for the idea, but I felt a compulsion to at least put it out there.
SailorStar says
Welp, Israel is now opening fire on the international Peacekeeper forces, with at least 30 Irish citizens. They can’t even pretend they didn’t know those folks were noncombatants. And they’re lecturing the Irish Prime Minister that it’s the fault of the Peacekeepers.
Why not? They lie about everything, and like every abuser everywhere, appease them and they only escalate.
StevoR says
Gaza, Lebanon , West Bank.. so far.
Iran possibly (probly?) coming soon and
draggingseeing the USA become either enthusiastically or grudgingly but willingly involved in a horrendous new South West Asian war. Whoever becomes POTUS or before E-day regardless.Possibly helping Trump beat Harris if the latter.. (Obscenities. A lot of obscenities.)Let’s hope it doesn’t end in the Samson Option..
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samson_Option
SailorStar says
Don’t forget, in addition to their neighbors, Israel has been bombing aid workers who coordinate their actions with them (World Central Kitchen was not the only one) and journalists. And then they hide behind their perpetual victimhood by screaming “antisemitism” for calling it out. It was pathetic to see the Irish Prime Minister do a tapdance around how OF COURSE Israel has the right to defend itself (against a bunch of peacekeepers just observing) and OF COURSE Israel should be able to commit whatever atrocities it chooses.
Pierce R. Butler says
StevoR @ # 4: Gaza, Lebanon , West Bank.. so far. ¶ Iran possibly (probly?) coming soon …
I keep having flashbacks to Michael Moorcock’s 1970s manic-surrealist Jerry Cornelius tetralogy, in which background news blurbs report Israel steadily “expanding its defense perimeter” or somesuch — to Turkey, to Czechoslovakia … they’d reached Norway by the conclusion, iirc.
Not the sf universe I would choose to live in!
PS: pls note my reply to you in Pharyngula arthropleura thread.
StevoR says
Hadn’t thought about the whole death march aspect o the repeated forced displacxements or seen anyone else do so before here myself and, yes, that’s a very good analogy and point there, Abe Drayton
StevoR says
@ Pierce R. Butler : Yes, thanks :
https://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2024/10/10/bring-me-the-head-of-arthropleura/comment-page-1/#comment-2239159
Ichthyic says
“Let’s hope it doesn’t end in the Samson Option..”
nah. Israel has been fed US top end weapons for decades. they can easily curb-stomp all arab nations combined without resorting to nukes if they want to (hell, they did it already in the last century), just like Germany did in Europe in WWii. I remind, because it does seem to be the case that the modern Jew has entirely forgotten what that was like, to be on the receiving end of such “justice”. Or is it inevitable that those exposed to such horror are doomed to repeat it themselves? sure seems to be the case if history is any judge. One might conclude that the US WANTS to perpetuate this trend. I can only think of entirely stupid reasons for them doing so however. OTOH, seeing the current election results… why eliminate something stupid? America DID have quite a few proponents in favor of siding with the Germans in WWii after all. I doubt there is anybody left in politics in the US smart enough, or with enough power, to cause the US NOT to slide into pure fascism any more. I swear I almost feel like I need to quote Obi Wan’s ridiculous “You were supposed to DESTROY the Sith, not JOIN them!” but this ain’t no dumb sci fi fantasy, is it?