Comments

  1. Bobryuu says

    Japanese and French would definately be good ideas, as well as Spanish and, if possible/plausable, Chinese

  2. says

    Can I suggest Arabic? Or Urdu? I’m making this suggestion on the basis that material which is just instructive and entertaining for us is actively subversive in parts of the Muslim world.

  3. Deepsix says

    Alexander, I’ve been studying Russian for a few months now. I love it. However, I have no one to converse with. I don’t think there are any Russian speakers in Tennessee (well, there might be one guy). Should be interesting when I take the trans-siberian and attempt to speak Russian to native speakers. That’ll be fun.

  4. says

    Spanish and French are practical suggestions. Chinese would be more difficult but awesome.

    Anything else would be beyond the scope of my language ability.

  5. Ксения Николаевна Кириленко says

    The next move is scienceblogs.ua, obviously!

    Seriously, the most exciting options would seem to be along the lines of:

    Chinese
    Spanish
    Russian
    Japanese
    Arabic
    Farsi
    Urdu

    Oh yeah – and Texan.

  6. Ксения Николаевна Кириленко says

    The next move is scienceblogs.ua, obviously!

    Seriously, the most exciting options would seem to be along the lines of:

    Chinese
    Spanish
    Russian
    Japanese
    Arabic
    Farsi
    Urdu

    Oh yeah – and Texan.

  7. Zero says

    Was I the only one that read “Sbers” phonetically at first and spent a good 10 seconds trying to figure out what language it could be in?

  8. Umilik says

    If I may humbly suggest my own native tongue, Swabian. And, if you want to be inclusive, Inuktitut would seem an appropriate addition.

  9. Don Quijote says

    From my own experience I would say French is certainly a good idea. I observed that in political science in French speaking countries there is an incredible amount of resistance against English as academic lingua franca (an ironic expression in that context, I admit). Perhaps it is different for other subjects.

    You might want to add Spanish to the list (which I don’t speak, but I guess that is not a criteria here).

    P.S.: Not much going on at ScienceBlogs.de so far. I felt pretty lonely commenting there today. Did I spend time on the wrong threads/blogs?

  10. Kseniya says

    Whoops – forgot to answer the first question.

    Languages known: English (native), French (some), Russian (some).

    Deepsix, do not despair. Tennessee is by no means devoid of polyglots. I have some friends in Trenton, and one is doing language study abroad in Japan. (I don’t think he knows any Russian, though.) :-)

    Sigh. I agree that Russian is fun but, compared to Romance lanuages, it is quite a challenge for a native English speaker. (One word: Declension! I love the consistency of the spelling and pronunciation, though. English is such a mess!) I’m a second-generation Ukrainka-Amerikanka, and my only surviving grandparent grew up in New Jersey, so my family is no help in my learning Russian or Ukrainian. Sigh.

  11. Katie says

    Hungarian!

    Admittedly, that’s just to earn extra girlfriend points from my native-speaking boyfriend…

  12. Epikt says

    I agree, though you really meant Befunge.

    Actually, if I must choose, I’ll take Brainfuck.

    Heh. This disagreement is almost, but not quite, trivial enough to start a religious war over.

  13. Gingerbaker says

    Just replace all nouns with ” the thing”.

    Then even bass players will understand it.

  14. Kseniya says

    Just replace all nouns with ” the thing”. Then even bass players will understand it.

    Q: Whaddaya call a drummer who just broke up with his girlfriend?

    .
    .
    .

    A: Homeless!

    * * buddabump * *

  15. David Marjanović, OM says

    Arabic, Urdu and Farsi are great ideas.

    Much more likely to happen is French, which isn’t a bad idea either. In France, everyone learns English at school now, but they start too late; in Québec, they apparently never learn it — my thesis supervisor, who is from there, speaks and writes perfect English now, but he only started learning when he was 20.

    Apart from German (native) and English (wellll… occasionally I have to stop and think whether to use the past tense or the present perfect tense…), I speak enough French that I could read a ScienceBlog in it, not enough Russian, and count me as illiterate in Chinese (Standard Mandarin, that is)… I’ve found out I can read scientific articles in Spanish and Italian, just from French, English, and the 6 years of Latin I had at school.

    And yes, Klingon is cool.

    I love the consistency of the spelling and pronunciation, though. English is such a mess!

    A mess? If it were merely a mess like German (where, for example, sometimes long vowels are specially marked, sometimes short vowels are specially marked, and sometimes neither is marked), there wouldn’t be much reason to complain. Alas, it isn’t.

  16. David Marjanović, OM says

    Arabic, Urdu and Farsi are great ideas.

    Much more likely to happen is French, which isn’t a bad idea either. In France, everyone learns English at school now, but they start too late; in Québec, they apparently never learn it — my thesis supervisor, who is from there, speaks and writes perfect English now, but he only started learning when he was 20.

    Apart from German (native) and English (wellll… occasionally I have to stop and think whether to use the past tense or the present perfect tense…), I speak enough French that I could read a ScienceBlog in it, not enough Russian, and count me as illiterate in Chinese (Standard Mandarin, that is)… I’ve found out I can read scientific articles in Spanish and Italian, just from French, English, and the 6 years of Latin I had at school.

    And yes, Klingon is cool.

    I love the consistency of the spelling and pronunciation, though. English is such a mess!

    A mess? If it were merely a mess like German (where, for example, sometimes long vowels are specially marked, sometimes short vowels are specially marked, and sometimes neither is marked), there wouldn’t be much reason to complain. Alas, it isn’t.

  17. Shane says

    English. May add some much needed colour. The American around here can get so tedious sometimes.

    ;-)

  18. windy says

    Why not all of them? There could be some Russian or Urdu-speaking scientists who might be suckered into writing now, instead of waiting for a whole new site to appear. If the experiment works well for the first one or two languages, make it an international edition where you can filter by language.

  19. says

    English. May add some much needed colour. The American around here can get so tedious sometimes.

    Well, let’s compromise and use Canadian then, eh? ‘Course, we’ll need a Royal Commission to look into the matter, first.

    In the meantime, toques and cases of Molson for everybody! Hey, who left this poutine on the chesterfield?

  20. says

    I’d say based on the audience and amount of available literature, go with Russian, Arabic, French, Spanish, and Chinese, possibly Japanese and Hindi-Urdu (probably romanized for neutrality’s sake).

  21. David Marjanović, OM says

    As a recovering Catholic, I’d have to say No–too churchy.

    <lift index finger> Gallia est omnis divisa in partes tres, quam unam incolunt Belgae… sive casu sive [forgotten] deum immortalium…>

    (probably romanized for neutrality’s sake)

    Neutrality, yes! Both will hate you precisely equally. :-) Besides, the ejumacated words of book-larnin’ are the ones that are taken from Arabic/Persian respectively Sanskrit.

  22. David Marjanović, OM says

    As a recovering Catholic, I’d have to say No–too churchy.

    <lift index finger> Gallia est omnis divisa in partes tres, quam unam incolunt Belgae… sive casu sive [forgotten] deum immortalium…>

    (probably romanized for neutrality’s sake)

    Neutrality, yes! Both will hate you precisely equally. :-) Besides, the ejumacated words of book-larnin’ are the ones that are taken from Arabic/Persian respectively Sanskrit.

  23. David Marjanović, OM says

    The market for Thai is a little small, I fear…

    (In my comment, please disregard the third >.)

  24. David Marjanović, OM says

    The market for Thai is a little small, I fear…

    (In my comment, please disregard the third >.)

  25. zayzayem says

    Just mention:
    It’s not translation of current SB into another language; its a whole new portal with new bloggers blogging that language.

    I posted on the main thread I really think SB should consider a non-European, Asian language.

    Hindi, Mandarin or Japanese. I’d prefer Japanese (i know it, and I’d get to learn cool sciencey words). Mandarin presents problems with the Chinese government. Both Hindi and Mandarin would allow SB to touch a very large international audience that possibly might not read German or English well enough to enjoy the other portals.

  26. David Marjanović, OM says

    Mandarin presents problems with the Chinese government.

    With one of them anyway.

  27. David Marjanović, OM says

    Mandarin presents problems with the Chinese government.

    With one of them anyway.

  28. DLC says

    Hmm… Klingonese ? Orcish ? Elven ?
    Binary Coded Decimal ?
    Nah.
    I’d say French, Japanese and Arabic.

  29. Santiago says

    Spanish would be awesome, but I fear it would be a tremendous flop. Even though spanish is spoken in almost every country in America, the spanish wikipedia still pales in comparison to the French, the German one, and even the Italian version. It’s depressing how backwards latin-americans are in this respect, *sigh*