The world of cricket once held to supposedly high standards of sportsmanship, even giving rise to the phrase ‘that’s not cricket’ when someone behaved unethically. However, like in so many professional sports, the desire to win has led players and even teams to indulge in shady practices and even outright cheat in order to gain an edge. Many of these skirted close to the edge of breaking the rules without actually crossing the line or, when they did, tended to be the actions of individuals. Australia is well known to be among the most aggressive of teams in using gamesmanship and pushing the limits of what is allowable in order to win. But the last week has seen scandalous revelations in which it is alleged that the entire Australian Test cricket team colluded in what was a blatantly illegal activity.
To understand the issue, you need to know the special role played by the ball in cricket. Each innings starts with the fielding side being given a new ball. Unlike most sports in which the balls can and are switched frequently, in cricket that one ball has to be used for at least 80 overs (480 deliveries). So if a player hits the ball outside the field and a spectator catches it, the ball has to be returned to the players on the field. This is because the condition of the ball is an important factor in how it moves and only the wear and tear of actual play is allowed to influence its state. After 480 deliveries, the captain of the fielding side can at any time choose to replace it with a new ball, although they are not obliged to do so.
Why the condition of the ball is so important is because of the way the ball is constructed and used. It consists of a hard spherical core that is covered by two hard hemispherical leather segments that are sewn together. The stitching creates a ‘seam’, a slightly raised band that runs around the equator. When the ball spins so that this equator rotates in a circle while the ball is moving forward, the hydrodynamic forces on either side of the seam create differential pressure that can make the ball move laterally in the air, something known as ‘swing’. The greater the difference in the conditions on the two halves of the ball, the greater the lateral movement, and the more such movement, the harder it is for the batter to pick up its trajectory and hit the ball.
So it is in the interests of the bowler (and the fielding side) to make the difference in the condition of the two sides as different as possible, so that one side is shiny and the other side is rough. But there are only a limited number of legal ways that a fielding side can do this. One is to rub just one side of the ball on one’s trousers to preserve as much of the original shine as possible. Players are only allowed to use their clothing, sweat, or saliva to shine one side of the ball. They are not allowed to change the condition of their saliva by eating sticky sweets or using other glutinous materials like vaseline or to rough up the other side. That is called ball tampering and can result in serious penalties for the player caught doing so.
And this brings us to what happened in 2018 when Australia was playing in South Africa. In the third Test match, one Australian player Cameron Bancroft was caught on TV surreptitiously using a piece of sandpaper in his pocket to rough up one side of the ball. In the subsequent uproar, it appeared that the team captain Steve Smith and vice captain Mark Warner conspired with Bancroft to secretly plan and carry out this scheme. All three were punished by Cricket Australia, the country’s governing body for cricket, for “engaging in conduct that was contrary to the spirit of the game, unbecoming of a representative, harmful to the interests of the game, and/or which brings the game into disrepute.”
That seemed to end the matter. But earlier this month, one of the players in that match Usman Khawaja, who had just retired, published a memoir which revealed on November 7 that every member of the team, including the coach Darren Lehman, had been aware of the scheme.
This caused a huge uproar and the current team captain Pat Cummings (who had been a member of the 2018 team) held a long press conference on November 12 in which he emphatically denied all Khawaja’s charges, saying that he was “100% wrong” and that it was “complete and utter nonsense”.
But just yesterday, less than a week after Cummings’ denials, Bancroft himself undercut Cummings and issued a lengthy statement that indeed everyone had known about the scheme and that it was decided that just he, Smith, and Warner would take the fall.
It seems highly plausible that it is Khawaja and Bancroft who are telling the truth. Veteran cricket writer Jonathan Agnew, a former bowler himself, says that it was never credible that just the three of them knew about the scheme. This is because all three are batters while it is the bowlers who are in charge of the ball.
The very notion that Cameron Bancroft – the most inexperienced batsman in the Australia team at the time – would use sandpaper on the ball against South Africa without the bowlers knowing has never made sense.
…[T]o get one thing straight, whether a ball is being tampered with or not, it belongs to the bowlers. It is the bowling attack’s weapon. As much as a bowler would not fiddle with a batsman’s bat – sanding an edge or changing the grip – a batsman would not work on the ball without the knowledge of a bowler.
Cummins has stuck to his denials. Cricket Australia is supposedly investigating this matter. They have not covered themselves with glory in the past when investigating wrongdoing. But I cannot see how they can avoid questioning every player who took part in the relevant matches and if Bancroft’s and Khawaja’s claims are sustained, at the very least Cummings should be sacked for the original incident and brazenly lying about it now. Other heads should also roll if Australian Test cricket is to regain any standing in the world of cricket.

Leave a Reply