The Lincoln pool debacle continues


I have to admit that ever since I discovered the existence of the livecam that points directly at the Lincoln Reflecting pool, I have been checking it regularly to see what progress is being made in fixing what has clearly become yet another symbol, if a minor one, of Trump’s utter incompetence at doing anything. While nowhere close to the cost in lives and money of his blundering in Iran and the economy, shredding formerly good relations with allies such as Canada and others, and so many other missteps, this failure is highly visible, even if he tries to hide the debacle by surrounding the pool with high metal fencing and then covering that with black tarpaulin. I am surprised that he has not ordered the livecam to be removed, since it directly contradicts in real time his repeated claims that the pool is almost fixed.

I asked my browser search engine whether the pool can be fixed and its AI replied with a confident ‘yes’ and then linked to a New York Times article from a week ago, presumably in support of its answer. But reading the article, one gets the sense, reinforced by the accompanying photos, that while work is being done on the pool, the problems may well be insurmountable. In reports to the administration, the contractor Atlantic Industrial Coatings conceded that it was their own fault, and not that of vandals as claimed by Trump, that created this fiasco.

[T]he documents, which have not previously been reported, make clear that the contractor, Atlantic Industrial Coatings, found problems in both the design and the execution of the renovation. The documents include Atlantic’s reports to the government as well as daily progress updates from the National Park Service over the past two months.
…

Because of “human oversight,” workers in some areas did not spray enough of the primer that made the layers of the liner stick together, Atlantic said in the documents. But the bigger problem, the company said, was that the repair plan laid out in the contract called for the layers of liner to include two chemicals that turned out to be incompatible.

The chemical on top reached a temperature hotter than what the compound underneath could withstand, and the heat caused the bottom layer to blister and come loose, the documents show. The contractor said it had not expected that outcome because it was very uncommon to mix the two products in that way.
…

The pool is still drained, and repairs appear to be ongoing: On Thursday, the pool was full of workers. Some were seen tearing up large strips of the blue lining, while another sprayed a new layer of coating as a man in a shirt reading “Atlantic Coating Inspection” watched.
…

The documents show that, to redo the repairs, Atlantic said it would use a smaller team of workers that would be closely supervised, and that it would consult an adviser from the manufacturer of the compounds used in the liner.

The photos accompanying the article are telling, showing workers still in the process of peeling away huge strips of the old blue liner, sweeping up the debris, and spray washing the floor.

The big mistake that Trump may have made is in thinking that the way one builds a normal swimming pool can be scaled up to something the size of the Lincoln pool, which is roughly the size of 25 Olympic-sized swimming pools. It turns out that they are encountering problems that they did not anticipate, such as that even sweat from the workers was causing the material to blister and peel.

Mr. Trump said then that the pool would reopen “shortly.” But it remains drained a month later. The documents reviewed by The Times help explain why. They show that repairing the pool has been a challenging and involved task.

On Aug. 13, the contractor began power-washing the pool to remove loose chunks of blue liner, according to the documents. By the end of the next day, workers had filled one large trash bag, but many more bits of liner remained stuck to the pool’s concrete slabs and would need to be removed later with razor blades, hammers and crowbars. [This makes the claim of vandals using knives look pathetic-MS]
…

After removing the loose pieces, the documents show, Atlantic sought to reapply the blue coating, only to encounter the same problems as before: Blisters would appear under the surface, between layers of the lining. Early this month, the company concluded that the problem was the interaction between the two compounds and stopped layering the hotter one on top, the documents show.

That reduced the blisters, the documents show. But it did not stop them completely.

Also early this month, the contractor identified a new potential culprit: sweat. It said that a worker, wearing a protective suit under the hot Washington sun, was leaving droplets of sweat on the coating, which were then trapped when new layers were sprayed on top.

To try to solve that problem, the documents show, the man then opened the top part of his protective suit and wrapped cloth around his head and wrists to contain the sweat. The documents reviewed by The Times do not say if that stopped the blisters.

While technology can solve many problems, I am sticking to my prediction that the Lincoln pool cannot be fixed (even if they use AI to come up with a solution) and that it will remain out of sight until Trump leaves office and a new sane administration abandons the whole thing and takes it back to its original concrete base.

Comments

  1. timothyeisele says

    And of course, the livecam also shows the big patch of bare dirt between the reflecting pool and the Washington Monument, where the “summer festivities” killed all the grass. It doesn’t look like they are doing much to address that, either.

  2. Jenora Feuer says

    One bit of this that I saw reported a while back (though not until well after the whole thing had become an obvious mess) is that the company that had previously done repairs on the Lincoln Reflecting Pool was actually approached first about this months ago.

    Their response was pretty much ‘It absolutely cannot be done by July 4th if you want it done right’, and to give a more reasonable timeline and a much higher cost than the Trump administration expected.

    Trump threw a tantrum because he wanted this to be all ready for the 250 celebrations which he was already taking over in other ways, hired his own pool guy who didn’t know enough to realize how big and complex the job would be (and who didn’t even really have the right licences to work on national monuments), and the rest is history.

  3. says

    This is the kind of symbolism that, if it happened in a novel and not in real life, I’d say it was too unsubtle and on-the-nose to be believable.

  4. Pierce R. Butler says

    I’ve got it! Since Trump has decided that (unlike the properties he personally owns) the Kennedy Center must be demolished because of one leak, he can then fill the Reflecting Pool with the debris! Win-win! (by Trump standards)

  5. Dunc says

    Depends what you mean by “fixed”… It may not be possible to apply the blue coating Trump wants, but it absolutely would be possible to return the pool to its prior condition, which everybody else had always regarded as perfectly good enough.

  6. Deepak Shetty says

    even if they use AI to come up with a solution

    If they use Grok , then you will have enough blog posts for the rest of this presidency.

  7. Mano Singham says

    What complicates things is that the base of the pool is not flat. Along its length, the pool is 18 inches deep at the sides and 30 inches deep at the center, so you have a V-shaped surface which makes it harder to create a smooth coating.

  8. Lassi Hippeläinen says

    I’ve mentioned this before, but I’ll repeat it: the easiest way is to cast the top layer with coloured concrete. Search key “blue pigment for concrete”.

  9. Mano Singham says

    Lassi @#8,

    I looked it up and it does seem like a possible option. I suspect, though, that it would have taken longer than Trump wanted since he needed it done by July 4th.

  10. Heidi Nemeth says

    If the bottom layer blisters when it gets too hot, and they want to remove the lining, wouldn’t it be easier to just heat the lining and get the blistering? Instead of using razor blades, hammers, and crow bars? It’s late in the season to do that now…maybe next year?

  11. seachange says

    I was thinking what Heidi Nemeth was thinking. If I’ve got a home improvement project and ‘the thing’ is taking to long, this means I have time to think about how to save myself the misery in order to get to the happy end result. If it blisters easily and you can pick it right up when it does, then why scrape scrape scrape?

  12. Lassi Hippeläinen says

    @mano
    Since I’m willing to believe anything bad about Trump, I suspect that coloured concrete was rejected, because it didn’t have enough potential for grift.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *