Old fools antagonize a young skeptic

A young woman made a short video criticizing Ken Ham’s Ark Park bullshit, and did it so well that Answers in Genesis felt compelled to rebut it. They did it in the laziest way possible, though, simply stealing her entire video and plastering text on it and making the ironic accusation that she was indoctrinating children. Oh boy, that just opened the door to her tearing their arguments apart more.

My favorite part was their response to her rejection of their pseudoscience with the simple claim that Jesus believed it. Yeah, citation needed. Modern creationism is a hyper-specific derivative ideology that is mostly unbiblical and is built on contemporary culture war issues.

Myths and money have poisoned our educational system

The analysis of last week’s colossal political upheaval continues. One explanation: education was a major driver of the public’s discontent with Republicans.

Voters were upset about a number of issues, including a voucher program, signed into law by Greg Abbott, the governor, that sent $1bn of public money to private schools. They were concerned about new social studies standards that critics say promote Islamophobia and minimize the impact of slavery. They had seen students detained by immigration authorities, and Abbott threaten to strip district funding if students protested against ICE. And they were angry about a curriculum incorporating Bible verses that felt “forced down the throats” of schools, Palmer said.

Well, yes. I, and just about everyone on the left, has been howling about those kinds of issues for decades. It’s nice to see it’s finally sinking into voters’ minds that the conservatives have been dismantling public education, and that that is a bad thing.

Maybe soon they will recognize that there are certain organizations, often religious, that are loci of spreading corruption, and will work to cut them out.

People still think Julian Jayne’s “bicameral mind” hypothesis is useful?

It’s been about 40 years since I read Julian Jayne’s book about his bicameral mind hypothesis, so my memory is more than a little fuzzy. Don’t ask me about the details! So I appreciated this summary by someone who supports the theory.

Imagine a theoretical framework that solves a long list of mysteries: the origin of religion and its concomitant features—supernatural visitations, ancestor worship, monumental mortuary architecture, divination, oracles, spirit possession, and the vestiges of archaic spirituality still visible in churches, temples, and mosques. This approach also explains otherwise inexplicable phenomena, such as hallucinations, hypnosis, glossolalia, and children’s imaginary companions. Moreover, this theoretical approach has clinical value: its argument about the originally nonpathological, adaptive nature of hallucinations helped establish an intellectual climate conducive to the Hearing Voices Network, which regards voice-hearing as a meaningful experience. Moreover, this framework comes with hypotheses waiting to be tested.

Such a framework can be found in The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind (1976) by Julian Jaynes (1920–1997). He theorized that until about three thousand years ago (with some geographic variation) humans possessed a “bicameral” (“two-chambered”) mentality in which the right hemisphere communicated with the left hemisphere using command hallucinations. These were interpreted as the voices of gods, ancestors, or godlike rulers. But population expansion and social complexity put pressure on this dual psychological system of supernatural superior and mortal subordinate. During the late second millennium BCE, this two-tier neurocultural arrangement collapsed. In response, languages—by developing metaphoric “mind words”—upgraded psychological processes. Jaynes identified the new mentality as “consciousness” (or in a wordier rendering, subjective introspectable self-awareness). Jaynesian consciousness is neither an innate, biologically fixed trait, nor something identified with sensation, thinking, or being awake. It is a learned cultural innovation.

That first paragraph claims the theory has explanatory power, but I fail to see how a hypothesis about the ancient duality of the mind explains a diverse and complex phenomenon like religion. I also don’t see the clinical value of a vague claim about hallucinations. I agree that hallucinations are real, and shouldn’t necessarily be pathologized, but where is the virtue in clinical practice to treating them as something more than a consequence of the problem of consciousness? I don’t think that splitting consciousness in two helps, because now you’ve created two equally big problems from a single problem.

You know, Wilhelm Fliess came up with an explanation of neurosis that involved a mysterious connection between the nose and the genitals, and even came up with surgical interventions to treat depression and psychosis. Did it work? No. I’m as convinced that the bicameral framework is effective in doing anything as I am about a hack chopping up turbinate bones.

The second paragraph is a silly claim about history — that there was a revolution in how the brain works 4,000 years ago, based on a hypothetical separation of mind functions before that transition, which Jaynes cannot demonstrate existed, except by his interpretation of old myths. Sure, people weren’t writing introspective psychological novels in the bronze age, but they were creating great works of art and building systems of laws and expressing themselves in poetry and music. They don’t seem fundamentally different from modern humans in that sense.

I dismissed it all as baseless fluff when I read it all those years ago, and that was before I started a research career looking at the development of cross-connections in the brains of fish and insects. The brain is full of commissures and decussations! Even your eyes split their output, with each eye sending information to both hemispheres, and the earliest neuronal pathways tend to innervate the contralateral side of the nervous system. Jaynes has to postulate that we had this massive cross-connection, but that people didn’t notice and incorporate into their ways of thinking until there was a “learned cultural innovation.”

I can well believe that there have been major cultural revolutions in our history. I just don’t see any evidence that somehow our minds were split into two chambers once upon a time.


These bozos have some really strange beliefs.

In Homer’s Iliad, we rarely encounter the Greek word for ‘I’ or much that refers to internal thought or decision-making. bit.ly/4C1lZgk

Cultural theorist Brian J. McVeigh agrees with Princeton psychologist Julian Jaynes’ claim that the Homeric Greeks had no internal life or self-awareness.

I guess the ancient Greeks were all NPCs, then.

I can relate

Only 3% of transgender adults regret transitioning.

I don’t have any personal experience with that. The part I relate to is all the people who regret knee surgery — I had knee surgery, I don’t think I was harmed by it, but it didn’t help at all. I could have spared myself weeks of time in bed and all that therapy if I’d just stayed home.

With those odds, though, I’d transition, if only I weren’t mostly satisfied with the body I’ve got.

The very least surprising thing about the last election

Mike Lindell says it was stolen.

MyPillow founder Mike Lindell called for a recount of the 2026 midterms, claiming that he has discovered “new evidence” of election interference — and directing supporters to give money to a nonprofit legal fund that paid one of his own companies more than $4 million between 2023 and 2024.

Nice twist at the end — he’s telling his fans to donate money to a corporation he owns, which means he’s just funneling it all back into his own pocket.

Who the hell is Chad Robichaux?

I heard some ridiculous things about this guy, so I started digging into his background, and hit a brick wall because Google has become completely useless. He has an unusual name, so you’d think it would be easy to find diverse sources about him. You can’t. Google search results are saturated with autobiographical claims by Robichaux himself, about and by the foundation he established, his podcast, his youtube channel, and puff pieces by organizations that support him, like Focus on the Family (you ought to be suspicious of anything Focus on the Family supports.) All I learned was that he’s really good at optimizing his presence on the internet.

AI doesn’t help, either. Here’s the AI summary of the man.

Chad Robichaux is a former Force Recon Marine, bestselling author, and founder of the Mighty Oaks Foundation, which helps veterans and first responders recover from PTSD and trauma. He has dedicated his life to helping others find healing and purpose after serving in combat.

I finally found one source that demonstrated any critical thinking, and it was Reddit. Sorry. That’s never a reliable source, but at least some people are asking questions.

I’m sorry, but can I get some clarification on Chad Robichaux? It seems like he tells stories like he was deployed as a Marine Recon member to Afghanistan eight times doing all this insane high speed stuff with JSOC.

However, I’ve heard other claims that he never deployed as a member of the military and was instead overseas as a contractor. That seems like a MASSIVE difference and very dishonest if it’s being presented that he was a member of the military getting into all these insane black ops missions.

Right. He spends a lot of time on his podcast and interviews, bragging about all his black ops missions, while simultaneously claiming to be this great righteous humanitarian. I’m already suspicious, and what is more plausible is that he’s a profiteering contractor who exploited the war, and afterwards turned into a grifter exploiting veterans. I was primed to doubt and mistrust this bozo by an interview he did with Tucker Carlson, where it was clear that he’s an obsessive liar and conspiracy theorist.

Let’s start with a standard stupid claim about archaeology. Did you know that ancient Egyptians and Native Americans couldn’t possibly have built megalithic stone structures?

CHAD ROBICHAUX (GUEST): I’ve stood in front of the megalith structures of Machu Picchu. When you stand there and you’re looking at a 300-ton rock that’s carved at such precision, it’s like, the Inca didn’t build this. Maybe they built stuff on top of it, but the Inca didn’t build this. Like, some primitive little mountain tribal person didn’t build this. There has to be a preexisting — they had help from someone, and they probably did it with preexisting technology. I don’t believe, by the way, we’ve — and you said this — I don’t believe we’ve evolved. I think we’ve devolved.

TUCKER CARLSON (HOST): Well, so a lot of those structures, Machu Picchu is a great example, but the megaliths in Jordan, the mounds in Illinois, like —but some of the stonework, we don’t, there are no masons today who could build it.

ROBICHAUX: No.

CARLSON: So like, what does that tell you? In 2026. No, with modern tools you couldn’t build that. So, no one’s explained any of this stuff. I’m just amazed by how incurious official institutions are in this. Like, how can National Geographic or the Smithsonian — like, if I’m the editor of National Geographic, I’m, I don’t know. I’m assigning piece after piece, like, how were the pyramids built? How did they get the stones 300 feet in the air? Like, how did that happen? No one even asks. And it’s considered wrong to ask.

That’s all too familiar racism and ignorance, and Carlson is pandering to it. We know how these structures were built. Scientists and engineers have been asking the questions for centuries, and working to understand the clever engineering and social structures that could use brute force and material understanding to get stones 300 feet in the air. Everyone asks. The answers are easy to find, at least if you can escape the vortex of suck that is Google.

It’s clear, though, that Tucker Carlson is an unreliable kook who is trying to imitate the Joe Rogan strategy of bringing in even kookier kooks to make him appear reasonable. Don’t be fooled!

At least he’s useful for exposing the even wackier beliefs of gomers like Chad Robichaux. Robichaux babbles about Nephilim.

TUCKER CARLSON (HOST): So, if your theory that Genesis 3 and the Book of Enoch are not just folklore, but are describing physical reality, If that’s true, if you’re right, then there would be actual physical giants. I mean, that’s what those accounts describe, giants.

CHAD ROBICHAUX (GUEST): Right.

…

ROBICHAUX: From my research, and this is something I’ve been very interested in, and those who I’ve spoken to who have spent their life researching this, every time there is evidence of giants, it goes to the Smithsonian and never to be seen again, which is quite strange.

CARLSON: No, they’ve denied it. Not that that means much, but do you think that’s true? That the Smithsonian has suppressed archaeological evidence for whatever reason?

ROBICHAUX: I’ve spoke to several people. Even beyond the physical evidence that we have today, if we believe the Bible and believe every part of the Bible, the Bible talks about giants and talks about Goliath. And talks about other giants in the Bible. So you can’t believe part of the Bible and not believe all of it. So I believe it cover-to-cover. So I believe giants did exist. I believe the, you know, modern day stories are true as well. I believe the giant of Kandahar is a true story. In fact, Tim Alberino interviewed the pilot in private that flew him out, so it’s a firsthand testimony there. So I believe —

What if we don’t believe the Bible and believe every part of the Bible? Where’s your credibility then?

He’d rather believe that the Smithsonian is suppressing evidence than that maybe the Bible is an untrustworthy collection of old myths.

TUCKER CARLSON: For those of us who are not familiar with the giant of Kandahar. Kandahar, Afghanistan.

ROBICHAUX: So I have some time in Afghanistan. However, I didn’t see any giants there. But the story of the — is some Marines getting this gunfight with this giant, and —

CARLSON: This is in the 2000s during GWAT?

ROBICHAUX: During GWAT, and a team goes back, and they actually — a team goes back because these Marines didn’t come back out. Team goes back and actually kill this giant, and it’s brought into a facility, and the US aircraft flies the body back.

He wasn’t there, but he obligingly parrots a story about a giant being killed by American forces. There are very tall people that some would call “giants,” but that’s not what these clowns are talking about.

ROBICHAUX: But I do believe this exists, and if you look at the Nephilim, which is the offspring of human women and the fallen angels, a lot of people would bring that to the modern day Sasquatch and Bigfoot. Once you start talking about this, it sounds crazy. However, no one’s found Bigfoot yet, including us, and we did two episodes of Shadow Figures on it. And I believe the reason no one’s found Bigfoot is because it’s not some primitive ape, it’s actually intelligent. Ancient and intelligent being, and not one, but a species of them that whether they’re elusive for whatever motivation they’re elusive for, but that’s why we’ve not been able to spot them or see them. You know, we get fuzzy videos, and with game cameras all over, right, you’re a hunter, there’s game cameras all over the world, why don’t we have a picture of Bigfoot? And I believe because it’s not some just primitive ape, some wild animal.

CARLSON: I was just thinking that exact same thing.

Two gullible idiots chatting about total nonsense. This is what the internet has brought us.

Such an astonishing amount of bullshit.

The murder was planned

Planned by his own dad.

When God made the trees, He knew that a tree would one day be used for the evilest event of history: Jesus’ crucifixion.

These people have such a weird worldview — everything is planned and predestined, right down to the seed that grew into the tree that would be used as a torture device. God is scheming in advance to do evil.

Speaking of evil…the death of Jesus was the evilest event in history? When you are not fanatically obsessed with your cult founder, one can think of many much more evil events.

Which god, and what’s your evidence? Be specific

Would you believe that “Scientists who believe in God are challenging the expert atheist establishment”? It’s a peculiar headline. Who are the “expert atheist establishment”? What are they “expert” in, because I know it’s not God — no one, not atheists and not theists — have any expertise in God, since there is nothing in that hypothetical entity that can be tested or measured. So what are they challenging?

I was temporarily discombobulated by that weird claim, but I guess I better go on and read the article.

For much of modern history, religion and science have been cast as natural enemies. But today there is a growing (albeit minority) view among scientists that God may well be behind their new discoveries.

Pardon me, but that is a serious mangling of history. Most of the time I hear apologists declaring that all of the scientists before Darwin were religious, so clearly most scientists did not see a conflict between science and religion. The conflict, if any, is that there is a gigantic explanatory gap, where we lack any evidence for a deity, so we don’t invoke a god in our explanations. Sure, you can go to church, synagogue, or mosque if your heart so desires, but we still expect a material explanation for the phenomena we observe.

I’d like to know who these “scientists” are who claim God is behind their discoveries, and what their evidence is for such intervention.

As they continue to untangle the complexities of the universe and molecular biology, they see a system that only a higher power could construct. Simple mechanical explanations simply fail to meet the explanatory test.

OK, but what about complicated mechanical explanations? I look at the scientific literature and see many sophisticated, detailed explanations; I don’t see papers that say, “I give up, serine-threonine protein kinases can’t possibly explain cell growth, therefore God.” Nobody looked at the irregularities in Uranus’s orbit and suggested that God must be wiggling it, they looked deeper and found Neptune, not God.

I am not impressed by arguments that rely on the inadequacy of a current observation to immediately postulate a fantastical super-powered invisible being. The scientists I know who are theists don’t accept that kind of argument, either.

So who is the author of this silly article talking to?

“The new discoveries in science push us in this direction,” notes Dr Stephen C. Meyer, who recently wowed the broadcaster Piers Morgan (and millions of his viewers) on his eponymous Youtube show.

Oh god. That’s all I can say. Meyer is a phony who doesn’t understand science. You’re going to have to do better.

So, after a stock recitation of historical figures who held religious beliefs, he gives us a list of the “scientists” who are challenging the non-existent atheist establishment.

Even the world’s most important innovator, Elon Musk, has recently become more public in his positivity towards Christianity, which he has described as “a religion of curiosity” and “greater enlightenment”.

Others like Pat Gelsinger, the former head of Intel, Gary Tan, the chief executive of Y Incubator, and Peter Thiel have openly embraced Christianity.

The religious re-discovery among scientists reflects a wider shift among leading intellectuals such as Douglas Murray, historian Tom Holland, and psychologist Jordan Peterson.

None of them are scientists! These aren’t people trying to untangle the complexities of molecular biology at all! When your list of people failing to understand molecular biology and inventing gods to fill their ignorance starts with Elon Musk and ends with Jordan Peterson, and your justifications are all based on the claims of Stephen Meyer, I think I’m warranted in dismissing you as a lying idiot.

Pro-choice is not pro-abortion

May he never enjoy the pleasure of a woman’s company ever again

Here’s an excellent story to illustrate the difference between pro-choice and pro-abortion, even if it is a horrific injustice to the woman involved. I have to wonder what kind of moral monster this guy is.

She wanted to have the baby. Suh didn’t. Instead, he told the judge, he impersonated the woman to open an online pharmacy account, ordered abortion medications, got Xanax from a friend to use as a sedative, and duped his girlfriend into drinking what she thought was just a prenatal protein shake. After waiting until she fell asleep, he administered the abortion pills orally and vaginally.

According to the woman’s lawsuit, Suh left her alone and incapacitated and ignored her attempts to contact him after she woke and realized she was bleeding. She called 911 and was hospitalized.

Jesus. This isn’t a moral dilemma at all — consent is essential, and Suh was ignoring the woman’s consent and putting her at risk medically, all so he could ignore the consequences of his actions. But he’s a man, so he blithely went on to university — two prestigious universities, no less — as if he hadn’t deeply harmed a woman he’d had sex with.

A onetime West Point cadet drugged his then-girlfriend in her barracks room, administered abortion pills to her against her will and caused a miscarriage. Then he went on to study at two Ivy League universities, starting at one of them after he pleaded guilty to assault, according to court records and a new lawsuit.

The man, Caleb Suh, graduated from Cornell University this year…

Oh, Cornell. Can Cornell’s reputation sink even lower? Have they no standards?

At least Suh pled guilty, although he hasn’t yet been sentenced. He’s also been hit with a lawsuit. Throw the book at him, please.