House of cards


Last week, the US grounded thousands of flights, throwing air transportation into chaos. We still don’t have a good explanation for what triggered this event, other than a vague “telecommunications error,” but I have hypotheses.

Hypothesis #1. It was a consequence of the fragility of a growing complex system.

That seems plausible to me. The various explanations available all point the blame at various things, like upgrading copper wires to fiber optic, or adding new AI capabilities to the air control system. I can believe that rummaging around in core dependencies could lead to a sudden collapse. In particular, inserting a chunk of vibe-coded AI junk is a formula for disaster.

Hypothesis #2. Just general incompetence all around.

That’s Sean Duffy, the head of the Department of Transportation. His only qualification is that he was a low-level reality TV “star”. He’s used his position to film a reality-TV-style series about his family driving across the country.

Next to him stands Markwayne Mullin. He’s a plumber. He was elected by the Red State of Oklahoma to represent them in the US Senate, and he has performed that role admirably, although it does mean he’s a know-nothing dufus. Trump put him in charge of the department of homeland security.

Watching their performance after the grounding will fill you with despair. They had no explanation, but they did praise Trump and ask for $50 billion to somehow fix things.

Hypothesis #3. Malicious interference.

I know, Duffy and Mullin denied that it was outside interference, but they are such idiots it’s hard to believe them. On the other hand, the US director for counterterrorism is Sebastian Gorka, a pompous far-right clown with no qualifications at all. Look at this summary of his background.

A number of academics and policymakers questioned Gorka’s knowledge of foreign policy issues, his academic credentials, and his professional behavior. Writing in 2017, Andrew Reynolds, then a professor of political science at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, questioned the validity of Gorka’s doctoral degree, noting discrepancies between how doctorates are normally awarded and how Gorka’s was awarded. Reynolds said that the evaluation of each referee on Gorka’s PhD committee was “a page of generalized comments – completely at odds with the detailed substantive and methodological evaluations that I’ve seen at every Ph.D defence I’ve been on over the last twenty years.” According to Reynolds, at least two of the three referees had only Bachelor of Arts degrees, and one of the referees had published with Gorka previously, in violation of the academic expectation that reviewers have no personal or other form of interest in the success of a candidate’s thesis. Georgetown University associate professor Daniel Nexon reviewed Gorka’s Ph.D. thesis, describing it as “inept” and saying “It does not deploy evidence that would satisfy the most basic methodological requirements for a PhD in the US”. Nexon ran Gorka’s thesis text through plagiarism software, finding that portions of it were “repurposed”, and concluded that he “might as well have mail-ordered his Ph.D.”.

The journal Terrorism and Political Violence had never used Gorka as a reviewer because, according to the associate editor, he “is not considered a terrorism expert by the academic or policy community.” In August 2017, Gorka falsely asserted that the Obama administration “invented” the term “lone-wolf terrorism”, when the term actually had been widely used in the academic literature, media, and by governments long before that. Responding to his academic critics, Gorka said that there was an ongoing “proxy war” and that others were attacking him as a way to attack Trump.

So no, I cannot discount the possibility of nefarious intent and direct action, not as long as that rat is in charge of guarding the door.

Hypothesis #4. All of the above.

We are vulnerable just as a natural consequence of the complexity of the technology, but it’s all made worse by a corrupt administration that has been actively destroying our ability to respond by appointing the most goddamned incompetent nest of weasels to run the country.

Comments

  1. mordred says

    #4.

    Interestingly Microsoft also had a little problem recently. I’m expecting to see more like this in the future.

Leave a Reply