There exists a very popular story about a man who is extremely rich despite lacking all creativity, curiosity, empathy, and joy, who thrives in a deeply divided society, buffered by the presence of prisons and workhouses for the poor, who is visited one night by a group of ghosts who terrify him into a greater appreciation of his status. The outcome of his spiritual instruction is that he learns to smile more and gets invited to more Christmas parties, although nothing is done about the prisons and workhouses, and the poor see no significant improvement in their material life. It makes for a strange movie. It gets remade shockingly often, and the script never changes — you could probably recite the lines yourself, we’ve all heard them so many times.
Why it’s popular is easily explained: audiences love the affirmation of the palliative of religious beliefs, and go in for a booster shot of Christian indoctrination and Tiny Tim being cute and helpless, as poor children should be. The wealthy keep funding remakes because it is a story that centers them and tells them they can be happy while propping up a criminally divided social order. It’s a redemption story that is astonishingly superficial and rewards the repulsively rich man at it’s core while demanding that he give up nothing more than the cost of a Christmas goose.
The latest version of this classist fairy tale is titled Ebenezer, and it stars Johnny Depp. Depp is good in the first part of the movie, where he plays a bitter, entitled asshole (it requires no acting), but the end of the movie requires him to be joyful, and he looks like smiling hurts his face. He’s no Alastair Sim or George C. Scott…he’s not even a Bill Murray.
There are no Muppets in this version. You can skip it.



Well here’s one alternate ending…
Thread over…I’ll get the lights. :^)
I just had the random thought — what would Alan Rickman have done with this role? I guess because of that Robin Hood line about “And cancel Christmas!” He could do both bitter and joyful really well.
^ ^ ^ ^ ^
Oh, yes. I really miss Alan Rickman.
But… Ayn Rand said greed is good!
I remember some right wing pundit citing the book as evidence that “wokery” isn’t new, so merely spending money on a goose and raising a single employee’s wages is apparently too much for a rich person to do. Nowadays, I wouldn’t be surprised if modern rich people would prefer Scrooge to do unspeakable things to Tiny Tim and end up in the Epstein files.
The Muppets version is the best.
Per the inter-tubes, there are over 100 movies and television adaptations of this hack going back to 1901’s “Scrooge, or Marelys Ghost.”
cendare @ 3 — I suppose that would be Alan Rickman as Snape or the sommelier Steven Spurrier until his conversion, then Colonel Brandon. As Spurrier, I thought Richman did an amusing job as a grumpy older male.
@6: Which is fucked up: the usual conservative narrative is that private charity is good (provided the recipients are properly deserving, and makes the donor look good), but government “charity” (i.e. a social welfare system) is bad, and changing the system so it’s not necessary in the first place is evil communism. I read a bunch of Dickens a few years ago; there’s a common pattern where the protagonist endures harsh conditions and comes out all right in the end, but while the author implicitly criticizes the socio-economic circumstances of Victorian England, he stops short of calling for the radical reforms that would end them (at least, AFAIR).
@9: Yeah, I imagine a lot of authors have drawn that line to avoid scrutiny. These days, with media literacy in the gutter, I’d love to see some who do propose big changes in their stories, or even better, have them implemented and working by the end.
….though, according to WP, Dickens’s writings did influence public opinion in the right direction, so perhaps he deserves more credit than I just gave him.
stevewaton @ #11 — Per my wife, who is kind of Dickens fan, he was a bit of jerk toward his estranged wife and grew demanding of his sons as they got older.
Wikipedia – Scrooge effect
This question is actually at the core of ethics. Take your president, for instance. It is to be believed that he won’t “turn good” ever. He’s sent millions to their certain deaths by gutting aid programmes, he’s a rape convict and the lies that he tells are innumerable.
I think that the solution that most humanists prefer is to at least remove such people from doing extreme amounts of harm. I vaguely remember the term “dangerous leader syndrome” for people of that ilk. Therefore, your president should at last be put to justice as soon as possible.
A more difficult question to answer would be whether or not such characteristics are in fact heritable in a reasonable sense (though I share the objections regarding the inadequacy of many methods used in evolutionary psychology, which calls itself a branch of science). At present, we unfortunately do not understand the mechanisms of character formation. Yet contrary to the blogger’s stated opinion, I do not believe that we can completely rule out heritability (be it via the genome or education), though I admittedly have not seen compelling evidence in favour.
Sometimes we just have to admit that some processes are as yet too complicated for science to understand.
More generally, I might be given to the conjecture that cures for the anti-social character disorders (which hitherto appear to be elusive, in particular for sadism) would in principle be of some interest, though care must be taken that the human rights of the subjects are not violated. The reason that people don’t open that box is presumably that they (very likely quite rightly) conjecture that people of anti-social character would immediately declare anyone that they do not have appreciation for eligible for such a cure, and have much greater chances of seeing it applied due to their manipulative skills.
… audiences love the affirmation of the palliative of religious beliefs…
A credible encounter with time-traveling incorporeal spirits might have that effect on quite a few of us.
drdrdrdrdralhazeneuler @14: “Take your president, for instance.”
Please!
Thomas Paine – Common Sense (1776)
PBS Nova article – How a worm gave the South a bad name
Yeah let’s not be so quick to forget this:
Why does anyone continue to employ this asshole?
@16
Well that and thymol. Which is my disinfectant of choice when cleaning the litterbox.
https://resource.rockarch.org/story/public-health-how-the-fight-against-hookworm-helped-build-a-system/
Have you looked at the US vaccination rates lately? The US lost its measles eliminated status today, and there is a raging measles outbreak in Pennsylvania at the moment.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/measles-elimination-status-united-states/
From the Rockefeller link above:
Sound familiar?
Mind you, nothing is really going to improve as long as Bobby Brainworm is secretary for HHS.
I don’t think the worm in his brain is riding shotgun.
One point – Ebeneezer Scrooge wasn’t “extremely rich” by Victorian standards. He was your classic petty bourgeois small business owner – with a single employee – who had made a fair amount of money from trade (he seems to have owned one warehouse in Cornhill). Middle class, certainly, but not your rich industrialist or banker who lived in a mansion with dozens of servants. He was much closer to Dickens’s own social class.
cartomancer @18: “not your rich industrialist or banker who lived in a mansion with dozens of servants.”
Now entertaining a headcanon that he turned undead…
Monica Van Fleet – Class and capital in Dracula
I think Alastaiir Sim was the best of all but I’m also rather partial to Patrick Stewart’s made-for-TV version.
@19. CompulsoryAccount7746, Sky Captain : “One point – Ebeneezer Scrooge wasn’t “extremely rich” by Victorian standards. He was your classic petty bourgeois small business owner..”
Huh. Didn’t know hat and always thought he was extremely rich and miserly. Sorta become a byword for someone who is that -both those things. Thanks.
FWIW Scooge’s wikipage here : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ebenezer_Scrooge
@17. silvrhalide : Yup – plus more. See :
Source : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnny_Depp#Legal_issues_and_allegations
@1. imback : Cheers! Love that alternative ending altho’ certainly not too cheery a one.
[StevoR, wrong. It was cartomancer who pointed that out, though he used the English loan term. Originally ‘petite bourgeoisie’]
@ ^ John Morales : Ah yes, you’re right. I stand corrected and my apologies to cartomancer #18 for that.
@19: Fascinating note on Dracula, there. And I’m all for scaring wealthy Victorian era lords.
Talking of awful Christmas stores, I always thought Rudolph the Red Nose Reindeer was kinda fucked. Pick on the different kid until they prove useful. Yikes. College Humor skewered this beautifully a long time back now
https://youtu.be/oiL9I5A1qBQ?t=2
@25: Deviation from the norm is punished unless it can be exploited.
This version sounds like blatant pro-billionaire propaganda.
The hookworm story reminds me of an anecdote (which may be apocryphal) about a group of Christian missionaries who discovered a village full of people in Africa, all infected with hookworm through walking barefoot through human faeces, and decided to help out ….. by organising a delivery of (mostly used) shoes, that turned out to be next to impossible to repair with locally-available materials and tools.
bluerizlagirl @28: Plausible I guess. Shoes are a typical intervention, including among missionaries. The ones you mention might’ve seen the dependency on them for more shoes as a bonus.
I fell down another rabbit hole. Longer than I’d prefer, but interesting.
Roads and nematodes: Kenya’s colonial economy as metabolic struggle (2026)
Your anecdote could have taken place in near-present-day Alabama. *sigh*
The return of hookworm and the limits of public health philanthropy (2017)
* Among the historical resentments: “another conspiracy theory held that the Sanitary Commission was just a ruse to convince southerners of the dangers of walking barefoot by Rockefeller, who was poised to capture the leather market and make a killing on shoe sales” hence the Commission propping up local public works rather than imposing as an outside private entity.