There’s a lot to be said about the harm that climate change is doing and will do in the future, both to ecosystems and to humanity, but the current system would be horrible, dangerous, and inhumane even without the destabilization of our climate. Case in point:
A rupture in Petroperu’s 40-year-old pipeline spilled 1,000 barrels of oil in Mayuriaga on 3 February, nine days after a leak in the same duct poured 2,000 barrels near eight other indigenous communities in the same Amazonian region.
This is a bit out of date, but I just came across it, so it’s news to me. It is yet another example of how the notion of “responsible fossil fuel use” is absurd. There has never been responsible fossil fuel use. From spills, to mistreatment of workers, to mine runoff, to atmospheric pollution, there is no reason to think that any corporation is capable of handling fossil fuels without causing massive environmental and human damage in the process. It may be hypothetically possible, but it has never been done, and there’s no reason to think it ever will be done in the future.
And the governments of the world have been no better. They have consistently failed in their duty to act in the interest of their citizens, and to protect those living within their borders. It’s not surprising that people have taken action to protect themselves:
The Wampis community of Mayuriaga seized a grounded military helicopter late on Sunday, holding crew members and several officials to press for inclusion in the emergency response plan, said Germán Velásquez, the president of state-owned energy company Petroperu.
It looks like nobody was harmed, other than those whose home has been poisoned, and that’s good. Violence is not going to get us the real change that we need. This does underscore a point that I feel a lot of conservatives in the U.S. miss, though. If someone tries to kill you, you have the right to use violence to defend yourself. In most of this country, you currently have that right even if you just think they’re going to try to harm you. Strangely, though, for all the talk of corporate personhood, if a corporation is in the process of poisoning your food, water and air, you don’t have the right to attack them to try to make them stop. It doesn’t matter if they made the decision not to repair or maintain their pipelines or holding tanks, even knowing that spills would result. It doesn’t matter that we’re talking about a scale of negligence that borders on intent to cause harm. The only legal recourse for a private citizen is a very, very slow and discouraging process of lawsuits and settlements.
And government agencies, of course – the same government agencies conservatives want to dismantle. I wonder – do they think we should take up arms against the local factory or oil company if it poisons us? I somehow doubt they would see themselves as being on the side of the Wampis community that seized the helicopter and crew…
The dangers of our current industrial and energy systems go beyond climate change (though that’s the most dangerous part), and the injustices of our current political and justice systems – across the world – go far beyond the social and political. Whether it’s an oil spill on tribal lands in Peru, or an bitumen spill in an American suburb, or harassment and murder of black and brown people by police, or the poisoning of water in Michigan, or West Virginia – we need change. We need change at every level, and we need to approach it as members of a global community with shared problems.