Canada is not sending their best

Tom MacDonald is very angry at black people, trans people, gay people, woke people, non-Christian people, vaccinated people, and all those immigrants dodging IC, but don’t you worry, he’s got a gun and a Bible. Bang bang bang, kill them all.

He’s from Canada — well, Alberta — and emigrated to the US in 2016 because he was such a great patriot. I think we need to deport him for promoting criminal violence and making bad music.

[Verse 1]
I look at my phone and watch the news
Another white lady been stabbed
Shooting at an elementary school and the gunman was trans
It’s my square the church was – No crosses, no Christ
And rainbows on fabric replaced stars and stripes
And the murder they show on the news is always blacks on whites
And the people burning flags are always left and ain’t the right
And they tell me I’m the problem while I watch the world die
Say I’m radical and I don’t have the nerve to say they don’t know why

[Pre-Chorus]
And I got a gun, and I got a Bible
But I don’t know which one to use
And I’ll pray for y’all but I’m pretty sure one day I’ll have to shoot

[Chorus]
Like bang, bang, bang, kill them all
Bang, bang, bang, watch them fall
I’ve got a gun and a Bible, I’ve got some prayers or a rifle
Either way one of us is going to talk to God

[Verse 2]
I look at my phone and watch the news
Another flag on a coffin
Gas prices through the roof, another war for profit
And everything’s still woke and masculinity still toxic
And the pedophiles from that private island still walking free, no problem
And the criminals we see online are always dodging ICE
And the vaccines they gave to us are still be taking lives
And all we get some crooked politicians and AI
Calls radical and then have the balls to say they don’t know why

[Pre-Chorus]
And I got a gun, and I got a Bible
But I don’t know which one to use
And I’ll pray for y’all but I’m pretty sure one day I’ll have to shoot

[Chorus]
Like bang, bang, bang, kill them all
Bang, bang, bang, watch them fall
I’ve got a gun and a Bible, I’ve got some prayers or a rifle
Either way one of us is going to talk to God

[Bridge]
‘Cause I’ve been watching this place, it’s getting worse every day
Christian, Muslim, straight and gay can’t get along
There’s only two ways that our country can be saved
It’s either bullets or Bibles, don’t know which one

[Pre-Chorus]
And I got a gun, and I got a Bible
But I don’t know which one to use
And I’ll pray for y’all but I’m pretty sure one day I’ll have to shoot

[Chorus]
Like bang, bang, bang, kill them all
Bang, bang, bang, watch them fall
I’ve got a gun and a Bible, I’ve got some prayers or a rifle
Either way one of us is going to talk to God

My first job!

I have been doing chores today, renewing the tabs on our car, walking to the grocery store, reviewing some homework, and most importantly, getting ready to apply for social security benefits. I’ve got plenty of time for that, nothing is due until early 2027, but I wanted to get all the essential paperwork lined up, and one of the things I have to present is my social security card. It was in my wallet. It’s always been in my wallet. Here it is:

I’m impressed. This is the original card I was issued in 1970, and it’s still holding up. My wallet is falling apart, I’m falling apart, but this scrap of paper is still intact, if a bit faded. What do they make these things out of?

I got that card in preparation for my first job. I guess I’ll tell you about that.

I was 13 years old, and in the summer of 1970, I landed a job in the Kent, Washington Parks and Rec department. I had an inside angle — my father at that time was working as a water meter reader* for the city, he knew a few people, pulled a few strings, and I was employed for the summer as a manual laborer, working on city parks. I was enthusiastic. It paid the minimum wage, $1.60/hour, but that was almost $13/day, and as someone who only got a few dollars a week mowing lawns, that was unimaginable wealth.

The work started early in the morning, when the team, about a half dozen young men, would climb into the bed of a dump truck and we’d go roaring up the hill, clinging to the sides. No seat belts. No seats. An accident would have terminated the flower of Kent’s youth, but regulations were a bit loose back then, I guess.

When we got to the work site, we’d all unload and grab our steel rakes and shovels, and rake all the rocks and small boulders out of the glacial soil of Dynamite Shack park and into neat piles. Then we’d fill up a shovel with 10-15 pounds of rock, lift it high, and hoist it over the side of the truck. We’d do that all day. I’d come home with every muscle and bone aching — I was the youngest and smallest and wimpiest of the group, but I tried to keep up, at the expense of muscle strain and nights spent motionless in bed, waiting for the pains to subside.

Now I realize that was brutal child labor, but I was blinded at the time by thoughts of filling my pockets with vast riches. Also, the crew boss was nice to me. After a few days of hard labor, he let me spend a morning shift picking up trash at Kent Memorial Park, walking around with a mesh bag over my shoulder and a pointy stick, picking up candy wrappers and bottles and unmentionable things under the bleachers…but we don’t talk about what we’d find under the bleachers. Then I was back on the rock shoveling crew.

One memorable morning I was standing by the truck, holding a shovelful of rocks over my head, poised to twist and throw my burden into the truck bed, when I felt a snap and an awful pain. I looked down and my leg was bent at an angle I didn’t think was possible, and my knee cap was jutting out weirdly to one side. It didn’t hurt, much, but I realized my rock-shoveling days were over. The crew boss helped me hop into the cab of the truck, and drove me to our family physician’s office.

The pain didn’t begin until Dr Dona hoisted me out of the truck and carried me into his office, with my leg flopping around wildly. I may have screamed for a while. But then he gave me a shot of ketamine, and I got distracted watching the ceiling of his office melting and flowing down the walls. While I was hallucinating, he straightened up my leg and wrapped it up thickly in a plaster cast from hip to ankle, and I spent the whole summer in that thing. I did not have a good time, especially since my family like to go to the beach. Sand and plaster casts are not the most comfortable of pairings.

In the end, I didn’t get rich. I did get a check for about $125, compensation for my workplace injury, but I didn’t get to spend it, since my parents used it to buy clothes for the coming school year.

And that’s why I support child labor laws.

*My dad was a water meter reader for a couple of years, which involved visiting every single house in town, introducing himself to everyone, getting to know their pets (especially the dogs), and learning where they worked, what kind of car they drove, where and when they were going to vacation this year. He acquired a preternatural knowledge of everyone, and just going to the grocery store with him was an adventure in which he knew everyone present. When I introduced my girlfriend a few years later, he already knew everything about her parents. It was weird to have a father who was a psychic wizard, and know that I would never be able to get away with anything.

Not this tired old story again

There exists a very popular story about a man who is extremely rich despite lacking all creativity, curiosity, empathy, and joy, who thrives in a deeply divided society, buffered by the presence of prisons and workhouses for the poor, who is visited one night by a group of ghosts who terrify him into a greater appreciation of his status. The outcome of his spiritual instruction is that he learns to smile more and gets invited to more Christmas parties, although nothing is done about the prisons and workhouses, and the poor see no significant improvement in their material life. It makes for a strange movie. It gets remade shockingly often, and the script never changes — you could probably recite the lines yourself, we’ve all heard them so many times.

Why it’s popular is easily explained: audiences love the affirmation of the palliative of religious beliefs, and go in for a booster shot of Christian indoctrination and Tiny Tim being cute and helpless, as poor children should be. The wealthy keep funding remakes because it is a story that centers them and tells them they can be happy while propping up a criminally divided social order. It’s a redemption story that is astonishingly superficial and rewards the repulsively rich man at it’s core while demanding that he give up nothing more than the cost of a Christmas goose.

The latest version of this classist fairy tale is titled Ebenezer, and it stars Johnny Depp. Depp is good in the first part of the movie, where he plays a bitter, entitled asshole (it requires no acting), but the end of the movie requires him to be joyful, and he looks like smiling hurts his face. He’s no Alastair Sim or George C. Scott…he’s not even a Bill Murray.

There are no Muppets in this version. You can skip it.

Surprise egg sac!

I’ve been despairing — I never get good egg production over the winter months. Today, though, one of the black widows surprised me with a big ol’ egg sac. I’ve been trying to make them think they’re vacationing in Florida in July, and I guess I fooled one, despite it being November in Minnesota.

You know what this means? I’ll have a swarm of baby spiders in December! And you know what that means? All my friends and family are getting black widow spiderlings for Christmas!*

*Not really. I don’t know that they’d properly appreciate a pet spider.

You don’t need to learn about Wes Huff

If you never heard of Wes Huff, relax — he just flamed out and crashed. Huff was a rising star in Christian apologetics, mainly thanks to his appearance on the Joe Rogan show (you could have stopped there, being Rogan famous is synonymous with being brain dead), and I was seeing him pop up everywhere, because as a good atheist I do try to track the latest excuses from theists. I was never impressed with Huff, because he’s just another Bible thumper who pretends the Bible is evidence for the Bible.

But man, he was just brutally exposed as a shameless plagiarist by Dan McClellan. Here’s his thorough exposé, included for completeness, but you don’t actually need to watch the whole thing — it’s seriously thorough overkill.

Since that came out, Huff has admitted his failure.

Let me be totally upfront in this scenario. If you want to cancel Wes Huff from 2016 or maybe even 2017 and 2018, I do too. I was not a good writer. I was not a good academic. I was just trying to find my legs as to where I fit in in the whole world of scholarship.

Let me be totally upfront and take responsibility for that, for what I think is bad. This paper, in fact, all of the papers I put on Academia.edu almost a decade ago are bad. Their use of citation and attribution is problematic. They’re not well written. They’re all pretty bad.

More accusations followed. He has now deleted his entire website. It’s the most dramatic destruction of a person’s reputation I think I’ve ever seen.

He should have been ashamed at the very beginning of his career as an apologist, because all apologetics is bad academic writing and is not honest scholarship. It’s just now caught up with him. May all apologists suffer his fate.

How not to become a scientist

Georgia Purdom, the creationist “scientist” working for Answers in Genesis, has written an article titled “How Can I Become a Creation Scientist?” It’s bad. I’m tempted to reply to it with one simple recommendation, “Don’t.” But this article is full of bad advice I have to try to counter.

Purdom breaks the process down into the stages of education, so I’ll follow that too.

High School

Her advice is stuffed full of self-serving religious nonsense. She suggests, first of all, read your Bible and Christian apologetics, and then adds reading AiG’s list of creation scientists, and visiting the Creation “Museum” and the Ark Park. You will not get any foundation in science from any of that; it’s not necessarily bad for you to follow a religion, unless you get fooled by the anti-science sentiment in those sources, but it’s entirely irrelevant to pursuing a science career. You can be religious and be a good scientist, but being steeped in religion isn’t going to help.

She gives some good, but generic, advice: do well in school. OK, that’s fair. But then she also has some bad ideas, beyond just stuffing your brain with creationist apologetics. For example, she expresses an attitude that I really dislike: I struggle with math, so chemistry or physics would not have been a good field for me. Don’t dismiss math, and don’t imply that biology is for people who don’t like math. All sciences are quantitative, and you must cultivate some understanding of math. You don’t like it? Then you’ll have to work harder to grasp the necessary quantitative skills. More importantly, learn the joy of mathematics by understanding what it is good for. That would be far more useful than reading Christian apologetics.

What’s missing from Purdom’s advice is anything to foster a love of science, replacing it with soaking in the Bible. The Bible isn’t going to help you in science! I would tell a high school student to indulge in fun, relevant hobbies, in addition to doing well in classes. Take up model rocketry or chemistry experiments, hike in the woods, go fishing, collect butterflies, collect rocks, raise pet insects, birdwatching…that’s all stuff I did in high school, but there’s much more. Geocaching, computer programming (even computer games), space camps, math olympics, etc., you can think of lots of entertaining activities that simultaneously build skills that will be useful in science.

Another thought I’ve had is that learning to cook is a fabulous support skill for science. It’s quantitative, it requires careful measurement, you learn to appreciate a variety of chemicals, even if people don’t like to call them that.

Purdom also recommends that you prepare to attend a college that stands with AiG on the truth of God’s Word beginning in Genesis. Don’t do that. Avoid those places.

College

Purdom’s recommendation for college students is to read even more apologetics, join the creation research society, attend creation science conferences, and find a good church. None of that will inspire a deeper appreciation of science.

As someone who advises college students, I would say that finding a church, if that’s your thing, is a fine thing to help a student who is looking for social support. What I’m usually telling students is that they need to take more math to meet the prerequisites of their more advanced classes. I’m serious: the number one problem for students entering a science major is insufficient preparation in math, which is why I hate those people who downplay the significance of math and lead young people to neglect a core piece of their education.

But beyond that, the other thing I tell students is to get involved with a campus organization: we have a physics club, a chemistry club, a math club, a biology club. One of the jarring things about Purdom’s advice is that nowhere does she suggest doing science recreationally, because it’s fun. I also tell students to get involved in research, that you actually can just walk up to a professor and ask if there’s anything you can do in their lab, and often they’ll say yes and welcome volunteers. My last (sadly, my very last) research student got involved in studying spiders, joined the American Arachnology Society, presented her work at an arachnology conference, and is currently off in grad school, studying entomology. She’s on her way to a career in science in a way that joining a church cannot directly promote.

Purdom has another strange recommendation: hide your ideas.

Be careful what you share on social media and with others about your biblical creation beliefs. Much of higher education is antagonistic toward Christian students in general but especially those who are biblical creationists in science fields. Today, it’s easy to find out a lot about a person using a Google search and even AI.

How sad. The persecution complex is pervasive, to the point the creationists are telling their young students that they can’t be forthright in public. Have they considered the possibility that creationism is stupid and wrong, and simply telling young people you’ll look like an idiot if you espouse it? She says, It’s best to keep your mouth shut and get the education and training you need, and when the time is right, you can open it! There it is: she openly advocates lying for Jesus until you’ve got your diploma.

Graduate School

You’ll never guess what advice she has for grad students. Read more apologetics and find a good church. Aww, did you guess it?

She also recommends picking an advisor who is a creation scientist. Good luck with that! There aren’t many around, except maybe in the AiG approved crap colleges she wants you to attend. Then, another revealing comment:

If you’re constantly being bombarded by ideas that are counter to God’s Word, it will be hard not to compromise. For example, I would not recommend getting a degree in evolutionary biology. There’s a very real chance that you would be an author on a paper that espouses evolutionary ideas as truth.

She wants to raise up more dedicated pseudoscientists to challenge evolutionary biology, but it’s important that they don’t get exposed to evolutionary ideas that refute the nonsense that creationists peddle, and above all, do not actually get a degree in evolutionary biology. That explains a lot, actually: creationists don’t understand the science they criticize.

Professional Career

I’m sorry, but if you follow Georgia Purdom’s advice, you won’t have a professional career. All she can suggest is that you get a job with a Christian church or Christian organization.

My secular path doesn’t guarantee you a job, it’s a hard path to follow. But there are far more options available to you: we have students working in industry, agriculture, and research, as well as in education. And you know what allows our students to succeed in a variety of occupations? Their quantitative skills. Knowing math and statistics is a powerful skill that can help you find a place in all kinds of jobs.

Knowing bizarre Christian apologetics and how to lie for Jesus gets you diddly-squat in the world outside the churchy hotbox.

Old fools antagonize a young skeptic

A young woman made a short video criticizing Ken Ham’s Ark Park bullshit, and did it so well that Answers in Genesis felt compelled to rebut it. They did it in the laziest way possible, though, simply stealing her entire video and plastering text on it and making the ironic accusation that she was indoctrinating children. Oh boy, that just opened the door to her tearing their arguments apart more.

My favorite part was their response to her rejection of their pseudoscience with the simple claim that Jesus believed it. Yeah, citation needed. Modern creationism is a hyper-specific derivative ideology that is mostly unbiblical and is built on contemporary culture war issues.

Myths and money have poisoned our educational system

The analysis of last week’s colossal political upheaval continues. One explanation: education was a major driver of the public’s discontent with Republicans.

Voters were upset about a number of issues, including a voucher program, signed into law by Greg Abbott, the governor, that sent $1bn of public money to private schools. They were concerned about new social studies standards that critics say promote Islamophobia and minimize the impact of slavery. They had seen students detained by immigration authorities, and Abbott threaten to strip district funding if students protested against ICE. And they were angry about a curriculum incorporating Bible verses that felt “forced down the throats” of schools, Palmer said.

Well, yes. I, and just about everyone on the left, has been howling about those kinds of issues for decades. It’s nice to see it’s finally sinking into voters’ minds that the conservatives have been dismantling public education, and that that is a bad thing.

Maybe soon they will recognize that there are certain organizations, often religious, that are loci of spreading corruption, and will work to cut them out.

People still think Julian Jayne’s “bicameral mind” hypothesis is useful?

It’s been about 40 years since I read Julian Jayne’s book about his bicameral mind hypothesis, so my memory is more than a little fuzzy. Don’t ask me about the details! So I appreciated this summary by someone who supports the theory.

Imagine a theoretical framework that solves a long list of mysteries: the origin of religion and its concomitant features—supernatural visitations, ancestor worship, monumental mortuary architecture, divination, oracles, spirit possession, and the vestiges of archaic spirituality still visible in churches, temples, and mosques. This approach also explains otherwise inexplicable phenomena, such as hallucinations, hypnosis, glossolalia, and children’s imaginary companions. Moreover, this theoretical approach has clinical value: its argument about the originally nonpathological, adaptive nature of hallucinations helped establish an intellectual climate conducive to the Hearing Voices Network, which regards voice-hearing as a meaningful experience. Moreover, this framework comes with hypotheses waiting to be tested.

Such a framework can be found in The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind (1976) by Julian Jaynes (1920–1997). He theorized that until about three thousand years ago (with some geographic variation) humans possessed a “bicameral” (“two-chambered”) mentality in which the right hemisphere communicated with the left hemisphere using command hallucinations. These were interpreted as the voices of gods, ancestors, or godlike rulers. But population expansion and social complexity put pressure on this dual psychological system of supernatural superior and mortal subordinate. During the late second millennium BCE, this two-tier neurocultural arrangement collapsed. In response, languages—by developing metaphoric “mind words”—upgraded psychological processes. Jaynes identified the new mentality as “consciousness” (or in a wordier rendering, subjective introspectable self-awareness). Jaynesian consciousness is neither an innate, biologically fixed trait, nor something identified with sensation, thinking, or being awake. It is a learned cultural innovation.

That first paragraph claims the theory has explanatory power, but I fail to see how a hypothesis about the ancient duality of the mind explains a diverse and complex phenomenon like religion. I also don’t see the clinical value of a vague claim about hallucinations. I agree that hallucinations are real, and shouldn’t necessarily be pathologized, but where is the virtue in clinical practice to treating them as something more than a consequence of the problem of consciousness? I don’t think that splitting consciousness in two helps, because now you’ve created two equally big problems from a single problem.

You know, Wilhelm Fliess came up with an explanation of neurosis that involved a mysterious connection between the nose and the genitals, and even came up with surgical interventions to treat depression and psychosis. Did it work? No. I’m as convinced that the bicameral framework is effective in doing anything as I am about a hack chopping up turbinate bones.

The second paragraph is a silly claim about history — that there was a revolution in how the brain works 4,000 years ago, based on a hypothetical separation of mind functions before that transition, which Jaynes cannot demonstrate existed, except by his interpretation of old myths. Sure, people weren’t writing introspective psychological novels in the bronze age, but they were creating great works of art and building systems of laws and expressing themselves in poetry and music. They don’t seem fundamentally different from modern humans in that sense.

I dismissed it all as baseless fluff when I read it all those years ago, and that was before I started a research career looking at the development of cross-connections in the brains of fish and insects. The brain is full of commissures and decussations! Even your eyes split their output, with each eye sending information to both hemispheres, and the earliest neuronal pathways tend to innervate the contralateral side of the nervous system. Jaynes has to postulate that we had this massive cross-connection, but that people didn’t notice and incorporate into their ways of thinking until there was a “learned cultural innovation.”

I can well believe that there have been major cultural revolutions in our history. I just don’t see any evidence that somehow our minds were split into two chambers once upon a time.


These bozos have some really strange beliefs.

In Homer’s Iliad, we rarely encounter the Greek word for ‘I’ or much that refers to internal thought or decision-making. bit.ly/4C1lZgk

Cultural theorist Brian J. McVeigh agrees with Princeton psychologist Julian Jaynes’ claim that the Homeric Greeks had no internal life or self-awareness.

I guess the ancient Greeks were all NPCs, then.

I can relate

Only 3% of transgender adults regret transitioning.

I don’t have any personal experience with that. The part I relate to is all the people who regret knee surgery — I had knee surgery, I don’t think I was harmed by it, but it didn’t help at all. I could have spared myself weeks of time in bed and all that therapy if I’d just stayed home.

With those odds, though, I’d transition, if only I weren’t mostly satisfied with the body I’ve got.