Thoughts on the blog comments policy


Readers may recall that at one time I was becoming frustrated with the tone of the comments in this blog, with few people endlessly and acrimoniously sniping at each other over trivial things, treating them with disdain, being needlessly sarcastic, acting superior, and generally creating an unpleasant atmosphere for everyone.

So I introduced some harsh measures such as a limit on the number of comments that could be made to a single post and what I would not tolerate. You can see that policy here. As a consequence, a very few people were either banned or received private messages from me that they were skirting the line.

I must say that the blog comments have become so much better. People are actually talking to one another, responding positively and collegially to others even they disagree, and contributing very useful information that I find enlightening. Sometimes people ask questions and others respond thoughtfully with answers instead of being dismissive. The comments on this post are a good example of what I am talking about because in them I learned a lot about naval logistics.

It is just what I hoped the comments section should be like and a rarity in the world of the internet. I find the comments section to be very pleasurable to read now and hope others do to.

So thanks everyone!

Comments

  1. birgerjohansson says

    I ocassionally lose count and post a fourth comment, but that is what happens when you only get two hours of sleep.
    Congrats for cleaning up the blog (or conga rats as we say at Pharyngula).
    PS the odious serial liar O’Keefe is in trouble again. Good times!

  2. beholder says

    I find the comments section to be very pleasurable to read now and hope others do to.

    That’s great! You managed to curate a rare decent corner of the internet.

    I have a few minor nitpicks about the comments policy — mostly a disagreement about one person that I think should not have been banned, and about a coterie that obsessively follows me around, hate-reading everything I write on FTB and sniping at me even here, but I suppose they snipe within the lines.

    On the whole, it seems to have worked out, though. You’ve spared your own mental health by laying down firm rules, and 99% of the problem went away immediately.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *