Why I am an atheist – Jennifer


When I really look back and think about where I started becoming an Atheist, it’s a bit funny. I never was raised explicitly Christian- I did go to a Methodist preschool, but I didn’t retain a thing save for the fact that there was apparently a God and Jesus, which I never questioned- it was just a thing that was true and mentioned very rarely, as we never went to Church after I finished preschool. Nevertheless, I certainly was Christian, if only because I didn’t know there was a choice.

What really stirred me up as far as religion was a passing comment that I heard- “Dogs don’t have souls and don’t go to Heaven.” It may sound silly, but it really resonated with me, especially since I was only about eight at the time and absolutely adored my animals. I was instantly infuriated that this Church was trying to tell me that my animals weren’t as much worthy of heaven as I was, and I actually remember planning to sit outside a Church with a dog just to protest them. That never happened of course, but the outrage towards the Church stuck with me. I still didn’t even know there was anything but Christianity to believe- even Atheism- but I sure as hell knew I was mad and didn’t want to accept such an idea.

Where I actually learned that there were other religions, I don’t actually know. The one time I asked my mother, her response was basically that there were two sides of religion- the good people who follow Jesus, and the bad people who don’t even think he existed. As much as I was angry at the first side, the second side made no sense, because to my knowledge Jesus was as real a historical figure as any. Saying that Jesus didn’t exist was complete nonsense to me. I really don’t know where I finally got the message that there were other belief systems, save for the fact that it was probably the Internet’s doing. What I do know is that it happened when I was around ten or eleven years old, because around that time I began getting into Paganism.

At the time, my idea of Paganism was everything I thought I wanted in a religion. Animals were treated in high regard, and at the age of eleven that was the main selling point. But as I grew older, the way I practiced and believed in Paganism changed. What I called “Paganism” soon became a strange hodge-podge of the ideas that I agreed with from quite a few different religion, except of course for Christianity, which I still viewed as evil. However, my perception as to why Christianity was evil was changing with my religious ideas. Growing up in Texas, I was subject to some very fundamental Christianity. Their denial of evolution angered the animal-lover-turned-science-lover inside of me, and the fact that this religion prompted my friends to inform me that I was going to burn in hell painted it as very, very wrong. On top of that, I was struggling with my sexuality at the time, and while it took me quite a while to come to terms with being bisexual, I was able to hold myself over by telling myself that I would be a gay rights activist even if I wasn’t gay- after all, we had a common enemy in fundamental Christianity.

This ended up being the allure of my pick-and-choose brand of religion. I could reassure myself that there was something else in the universe, some sort of higher power, and yet I could accept evolution and homosexuality without condemning myself or anybody else. However, my brand of religion continued to evolve past this. I didn’t really like being what I called Pagan; there was a lot of very silly superstition, but it was an important placeholder to me because I couldn’t accept that there wasn’t some form of deity and afterlife. In response to this, I altered my “religion” further. I would tell myself that I could never know if any of it was true, or that it didn’t even matter if it was true. The small idea that maybe it was true after all, but I didn’t have to worry about it, placated my need to have some sort of religion.

The rest of my transition to Atheist isn’t much of a story. Over time, that religion faded from a outright rejection of Christianity, to a nice possibility that may be true, to nothing but a memory of what I used to believe, all over the course of about four years. Now I’m sixteen, glad to be free of religion, and focusing my goals on working with human-like artificial intelligence, which I’m sure I wouldn’t be able to do if I thought that human intelligence was some impossible to understand thing granted by a soul and a god.

On one last amusing note, I recall someone telling me once that my pagan-esque religion was just a rebellious teenage phase. At the time I was indignant, but now I find it amusing how right they were that it was a phase. There’s one important distinction though- where they thought it was “just a phase” before I went back to being a proper Christian girl, it ended up being a transitional phase away from Religion entirely. Funny how that worked out.

Jennifer
United States

Comments

  1. eclectabotanics says

    Without the internet, a lot of Texas kids might never know that there’s an alternative to Jesus. Knowledge kills superstition.

  2. John Morales says

    Jennifer, wow, what a good read. And you’re only 16?!

    (I am very impressed by this essay, in particular its clarity and cogency)

  3. raven says

    This ended up being the allure of my pick-and-choose brand of religion.

    All xians are cafeteria xians.

    All Pagans are cafeteria Pagans.

    At least the Pagans consider that a feature, not a bug.

    What really stirred me up as far as religion was a passing comment that I heard- “Dogs don’t have souls and don’t go to Heaven.”

    Cats do though. These days most xians will claim that pets have souls and end up in heaven. Although how they could know either way is mysterious. AFAIK, the bible doesn’t say anything one way or another.

  4. allencdexter says

    You are very fortunate to have come to this place so early in life. It took me decades.

    Certitudes such as animals not going to heaven are so ridiculous it’s amazing that people fall for them. We have three pet dogs, and they are so human-like that I couldn’t imagine them not joining me in heaven if that were a reality. If you want to demonstrate your superiority and specialness, just relegate whatever you feel superior to to an inferior class. It’s applied to women, other races, etc.

    Thanks for sharing.

  5. otrame says

    Reminds me of Robert B. Parker’s definition of Heaven: when you arrive there, all the dogs you’ve ever loved run to greet you.

    I agree with John Morales. That is a very well-written essay.

  6. santiago says

    What a wonderful story! I’m actually 16 as well, and for my entire life have been subjugated to religious teachings. Even now I attend a Jewish Day School.

    Similar to you, my rejection of religious belief initially stemmed from my understanding of evolution and animal behavior. It seemed absolutely repugnant to me how vehement my local religious teachers were in differentiating between the cognitive and “spiritual” capability of humans and non human animals, even when they would make statements that were blatantly fallacious (e.g. animals are automatons gallivanting through life on instinct alone).

    It was a pleasure reading a story from someone who I can relate to!

  7. cag says

    Another Jennifer, very articulate and a future leader of rationality.

    Jennifer is still too young to vote, while Eric Hovind, Ken Ham etc. are eligible to vote. What’s wrong with this picture?

  8. DonDueed says

    I was instantly infuriated that this Church was trying to tell me that my animals weren’t as much worthy of heaven as I was, and I actually remember planning to sit outside a Church with a dog just to protest them.

    This would have been awesome! I wish you had done it, and that I had been there with a camera.

  9. Pierce R. Butler says

    raven @ # 3: AFAIK, the bible doesn’t say anything one way or another.

    It has nothing to say about cats (the word doesn’t appear in the entire KJV, singular or plural), but John the Revelator makes it very clear (Rev. 22:15) that dogs don’t get in.

    Jennifer’s right: such an afterlife would be intolerable. Same goes for the people who want it that way.

  10. says

    “Without the internet, a lot of Texas kids might never know that there’s an alternative to Jesus. Knowledge kills superstition.”

    Ahh, yes. The Internet: Where Religions Come to Die.