Evangelicals and Donald Trump

Evangelical Christians are a major part of the Republican voting base and I was curious about how they felt about Donald Trump, since he does not seem to be particularly religious. At least, he does not talk about god at every opportunity. Sarah Posner writes that Trump has split the evangelicals along unusual lines, with so-called ‘born again’ Christians being less favorable to him, and those evangelicals who do like him being those who care more about projections of American machismo than they do about religion.

But Reuters/Ipsos polling gives us a tiny and interesting window in its ongoing survey of respondents’ views on the presidential candidates. In that polling, there’s some evidence that “born-again” (that’s Reuters/Ipsos’s classification) Republicans who attend church frequently don’t like Trump as much as other Republicans do.

For example, as of last weekend, Trump was polling among Republicans at 24.9. percent, with Ben Carson in second place at 10.3 percent. But when you look at only born-again Republicans, Trump’s support drops to 19 percent and Carson’s rises to 15 percent, with Mike Huckabee coming in third with 12 percent. If you further winnow that to born-again Republican respondents who attend church nearly weekly or more, Trump’s support dips again, down to 13 percent (tied with Huckabee), behind Ben Carson’s 22 percent by nine points.

Trump is the first Republican presidential candidate in the post-Reagan era to pin his campaign on a macho, chest-beating, self-aggrandizing view of what America is without invoking either his own salvation testimony or a paean to America as a Christian nation. For Trump, America is Trumpnation, not a Christian nation. What’s appealing to Christian nation diehards is often not the notion of America as a pious nation, but rather the affirmation that America is strong, brave, or just generally the best. For Trump, America risks not being the best anymore not because of the decline of religion (typically the heart of Christian nation ideology), but because of the rise of immigration.

Trump is opening up many fault lines in what had been a fairly solid Republican party base and it is clear that it is causing some consternation.


  1. raven says

    Trump has already claimed to be a religious nut, a Presbyterian. It wasn’t too convincing, like his claims to have any idea what he is talking about on anything. He’s on his third wife and made a lot of his money out of gambling.

    It won’t make any difference to the christofascists.

    Their last nominee wasn’t even a xian!!! Romney was a Mormon, generally regarded among fundies as nonxians. They voted for him anyway.

    As long as someone hates the right groups, that is all they care about. For the fundie xians, hate is more important than anything else.

  2. machintelligence says

    I really wonder about the solidity of the Republican base. The religious right consists of conservative Catholics, Evangelical Protestants and Mormons, each one of whom believe that the other two are bound for hell.

  3. Lassi Hippeläinen says

    Trump seems to take his ideas from European right wing populists, who count on xenophobia (they call it “nationalism”) in stead of religion. People like Nigel Farage (UK), Marine Le Pen (France), and Victor Orbán (Hungary), to name a few. All of them have landed into difficulties when some of their followers have taken their xenophobia too seriously, and have begun to look like nazis. Marine Le Pen even had to kick out the founder and honorary chairman of her party -- who also happens to be her father.

  4. anteprepro says

    I read either on 538 or a news site that, looking at the statistics of supporters, Trump is more about attitude than policy. He has support across bizarre combinations of demographics, and it largely all comes from people who like his audacity and enjoy the fact that, with Trump, it isn’t “politics as usual”. The fact that this means that they are supporting an asshole with asinine policies is entirely incidental, I’m sure.

    (He was also found to have more support among Low Information Voters. Go figure, right?)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *