I’m pretty sure we have no flat earthers here


But if we do, let’s smoke them out.

For those unfamiliar with the region, Mt Rainier (correct spelling) is about 80 miles (130 km) north-north-east of Mt St Helens. That photo is a good visual aid for refuting flerfs.

Argue away! Or can I expect dead silence because no one is stupid enough to fall for that flat earth nonsense here?

Comments

  1. says

    I’ve got a morbid curiosity about how they rationalize a conspiracy dating back to ancient mathematicians who calculated the circumference of the earth in olden days. If everyone’s been lying about the earth being round, why?

    Of course, I imagine most flerfs haven’t thought that far. Most probably just want their gut impressions to be more authoritative than the combined hard work and diligent calculations of humanity. They want their pride and laziness to be virtues.

  2. robro says

    Mt. Rainier just seems smaller than Mt. St. Helens because it’s further away.

    How’s that for flerf logic?

    I learned a new word today which seems appropriate: slang-wrangler, “someone who uses abusive slang or is a ranting partisan.”

    I learned the word from this Washington Irving quote:

    “In this country every man adopts some slang-wanger as the standard of his judgement, and reads everything he writes, if he reads nothing else: which is doubtless the reason why people of this logocracy are so marvelously enlightened.”

    “Logocracy” was Irving’s label for the US.

  3. Dan Phelps says

    Obviously that explosion in 1980 was a controlled demolition by the government to conceal the TRUTH!

  4. ealloc says

    It does seem perspective plays a big role. And I think the post has the wrong distance:

    Mt Rainier to Mt St Helens – 82 km
    Portland to Rainier – 165 km
    Portland to Helens – 83 km
    Helens height – 2.54 km
    Rainier height – 4.4 km

    On a flat earth from Portland, Mt Rainier should look lower:
    Mt.St Helens should be atan(2.54/83) = 11.0 degrees above horizon:
    Mt Rainer should be atan(4.4/165) = 9.6 degrees above horizon (lower).

    On a curved earth radius 6371 km, by pythagoras Mt. Rainier will appear 2.1 km shorter and Helens 0.54 km shorter, working out to angles 5.0 degrees for Rainier and 8.67 for Helens above horizontal. That is indeed a larger difference (3.65 degrees) than on a flat earth (1.4 degrees).

    I wonder if the ancient greeks could have figured out the radius of the earth from looking mountains like these somehow, instead of Eratosthenes method.

    (This math provided “as is” with no warranty of correctness).

  5. dschultz says

    I see three categories of flat earthers (moon landing deniers, etc.)

    1) It is goof to see if they can get a rise out of people.
    2) it is a con. Trying to get some of that sweet YouTube monetization.
    3) They really are that stupid.

    I suspect that the third category is the smallest.

  6. astringer says

    about to post a link, then noticed Erlend Meyer is a ref to the same video. I use as “go to” in a continuing attempt to fathom this and other madness. Warning: contains QAnon rabbit hole…

  7. stevewatson says

    There’s a Netflix documentary Behind the Curve about flerfers. They (or at least the American ones it concentrates on) seem to be a mix of extreme Christian fundies and New Age loons, who make pretty odd bedfellows. For some reason, Facebook shows me a lot of flerf posts, many of which are at the “not even wrong” level, nonetheless the authors are quite derisive towards round-earthers. I think a lot of them really are that stupid. (This is one reason I limit my FB activity to no more than once per week).

  8. springa73 says

    If the earth is actually totally flat, shouldn’t you be able to see Mount Fuji in Japan from the California coast, all the way across the Pacific Ocean? Perhaps not with the naked eye, since the distance is so great, but surely with a telescope?

  9. WhiteHatLurker says

    My first thought about the photo is the same as previous posters – it doesn’t show earth’s curvature in any visible way, and it can be argued as perspective.

    Why not a photo from an airplane or even a hot air balloon? It is easy to show incontrovertible proof.

    And it’s (almost) impossible to convince those with deep seated beliefs in absolute nonsense of the truth of the matter.

  10. WhiteHatLurker says

    The video looks cool. The lake bit anyway. The second part on criminal conspiracy cults less so. That would be depressing I suspect.

  11. beholder says

    You want a Flat Earther diagnosis? I’ll put on that hat and give it a shot:

    The framing is deceptive. The taller mountain is farther away and already looks smaller on the True Earth. On a globie ball the mountains would be tilted away from you. Does that look like a mountain that is tilted away from you? No. If you zoom in real close you can see that the picture was constructed by a computer and we all know the people in charge of tech are trying to fool us into thinking the Earth is a globie fucking impossibility to make us stray away from the teachings of the Bible.

  12. Pierce R. Butler says

    Oops @ my # 19 – a premature posting. The remainder:

    Everybody knows that Portland, Oregon, was utterly destroyed by Communist Democrat rioting years ago, and nothing remains of it but a smoking crater!

  13. Reginald Selkirk says

    Mt. St. Helens only looks taller because light rays are bent by Bigfoot and UFOs.

  14. bravus says

    An extremely common issue with flerf arguments and claims that I don’t think has been mentioned in the discussion here is a failure to understand scale. They seem to assume the radius of Earth is a few dozen or a few hundred miles, not thousands. This then means that the fact that a large enough sphere (all right, oblate spheroid for the pedants) can be approximated as a plan at the scale of our everyday life experience is not available to them.

  15. flex says

    Oh come on, everyone knows that the foot gets shorter the further north you go. In that 80 miles the foot clearly shrinks about half!

  16. CompulsoryAccount7746, Sky Captain says

    springa73 @15: “shouldn’t you be able to see Mount Fuji in Japan from the California coast, all the way across the Pacific Ocean?”

    They’d be looking due north across the pole, I think. West of California is just the ice wall encircling the disk.

    flatearth.ws – The Polar Azimuthal Equidistant Map is NOT the Flat Earth Map

    Flat-Earthers stole the shape of the azimuthal equidistant map and call it the “flat-Earth map.” […] They claim it to be distortion-free.

  17. beholder says

    @15 springa73

    Sunlight doesn’t reach that far. Even if you had a light source over there, there’s too much elemental darkness in the way for you to see it.

  18. whheydt says

    It’s obvious that the Earth can’t possibly be flat. If it were flat, the cats would have pushed everything off the edges by now.

  19. stevewatson says

    @22: One of the arguments I’ve seen is that, on a round earth, pilots would continually have to adjust their course downwards to maintain the same altitude, and this would be noticeable. I’m not a pilot, but I’m pretty sure they have to continually make both pitch and yaw adjustments to allow for air movement, and these dwarf the slight downward pitch required to follow the curved surface of the earth. As you say: no appreciation of the scale involved.
    If the earth were flat, the entire aviation and maritime transport industries would have to be in on the coverup, as would any business that involves surveying any distance more than about 100m (I pulled that number out of my ass, but you get the idea). I wonder if it’s possible to detect the lateral curve in a long east-west road, necessary to keep it following the same latitude.

  20. direlobo says

    @2 Recursive Rabbit:

    The answer to why they think the conspiracy exists is religion. Simple as that. God (in the bible) says the earth is flat, or say they interpret it, and stars and whatnot visible are in the “firmament” (whatever the hell that is) ergo, the devil is trying to deceive people. I’ve noted a correlation between flat earth belief and the belief that space is “not real”. They literally do not believe space exists, other galaxies exist, other stars, etc., etc. – all dots of light on the “firmament”, nothing else out there, at all. I really do not buy the argument that most of them are grifters or trolls, I believe they are 100% convinced they are right because to believe otherwise, in their tiny brains, would go against their god.

  21. microraptor says

    @30: Guess we can add gravity to the list of things that flearthers don’t believe in, if that’s how they think flying works.

  22. dbarkdog says

    @stvewatson.
    I once lived in a very flat area in Ohio. The country roads ran in a simple grid pattern, and at the east side of the county they all made a jog to compensate for the difference between a two dimensional plane and a curved surface. At least that was my interpretation. It could have simply been the result of poorly coordinated surveying, but that is a much less interesting explanation. In any case, on a sufficiently large rectilinear array the mismatch would become obvious.

  23. zetopan says

    Concerning Flat Earthers, Conspiracy “Theorists”, Qanon, MAGA, and the many thousands of other idiot cults. The internet has allowed these morons to find each other, rapidly propagate their uninformed viewpoints, and spawn newer forms of insanity. And now, the terribly misnamed LLM AI will give them an even greater voice among the perpetually perplexed.

    About 10% of the US adult population hold flat Earth views, and a whopping 40% are creationists. I’m relatively surprised that the overlap isn’t a full 100% since the US creationists’ “infallible” reference is an obvious collection of very primitive flat Earth writings. About 1/3rd of the US population endorses astrology, and about 1/3rd endorses tarot cards. Obviously, there is a lot of overlap between these groups. But the point is, with that high of percentage of ignorance, democracy stands relatively little chance of a permanent survival once the loons and obscurantists get control of the government (like in the current USA).

    “Anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.” — Isaac Asimov

    “As democracy is perfected, the office of the president represents, more and more closely, the inner soul of the people. We move toward a lofty ideal. On some great and glorious day, the plain folks of the land will reach their heart’s desire at last, and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron.” — H.L. Mencken in 1920 (Achievement accomplished.)

    “No amount of evidence will ever persuade an idiot.” — Mark Twain

    https://newrepublic.com/post/172902/georgia-gop-chair-earth-really-round-many-globes-everywhere
    https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/2025/05/17/flat-earth-us-politicians/83492658007/
    https://minnesotareformer.com/2025/04/16/minnesota-republicans-elect-a-flat-earther-to-a-party-leadership-post/
    https://www.chicagotribune.com/2020/09/17/republican-nominee-for-us-senate-in-delaware-has-repeatedly-promoted-qanon-conspiracy-theory-once-called-self-flat-earther/
    https://www.bluestemprairie.com/bluestemprairie/2025/04/minnesota-cd7-republicans-elect-flat-earther-bret-bussman-district-chair.html
    https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2017/11/28/americas-flat-earth-movement-appears-to-be-growing

  24. Ridana says

    Georgia put Marge Greene in the US House. She started out as a QAnon grifter, mixed in with all her racism and other conspiracy theories. Remember “Jewish space lasers”? I guess that means she may not be a flat-earther at least, though contradictions and hypocrisy have never stopped her mouth.

  25. drmarcushill says

    You can’t use trigonometry like that of ealloc @8 without also knowing the altitude of the vantage point, which is clearly greater than the 0 implicit in the calculations.

  26. John Morales says

    drmarcushill, it’s treetop height, which in the scheme of things ain’t much.

    (Me, I am more amused by the ‘feet’ metric)

  27. drmarcushill says

    Hard to tell from the photo if the base of the trees are enough above sea level to make a perceptible difference, but you’re probably right.

    OTOH, feet are very much not metric 😈

  28. EigenSprocketUK says

    That photo is clearly fake.
    Even a child can see that those red arrows alone would each be about a mile in height. There’s no way that levitating such massive brightly coloured structures even for the brief amount of time to take the photo would have gone unnoticed.

  29. EigenSprocketUK says

    Oh, crap. I accidentally posted below the Event Horizon. Serves me right for not reloading.

  30. outis says

    Sorry, but Zetopan @34 has a point: if someone really believes in a flat earth, they may be too far gone do be otherwise convinced by just “reasoning with them”. The distance from reality is just too great – and that worries me, as this is one of the very definitions of “psychosis”.
    Yet there’s hope: if I remember correctly a while ago on Pharyngula one of the commenters recalled a documentary which showed a summer expedition to one of the Poles… and somehow they had a flatearther in the company. This good fellow, after seeing with his own eyes how the sun went round in circles, bravely acknowledged his mistake.
    Impressive, and a cause for being hopeful.

  31. stevewatson says

    @33: Back in the 19th century, a lot of North America was surveyed in grids for partitioning into farm plots. The north-south roads (called “lines” where I live, though a lot of them later received actual names) follow great circles (or if you prefer, lines of longitude) which means they will diverge as you go south. So every few miles they had to reset the grid to maintain a constant distance between them, so the farms would all be about the same area. Thus at an east-west road (called “concessions”) you get a pair of T-junctions where the N-S roads are offset by 100 yards or so. You can often see the results in suburban areas, where a main N-S artery will have a wiggle at or near a cross-street, because as the city expanded the planners decided they’d better join up the two segments of the road to improve traffic flow.
    The E-W roads however are not great circles; they follow constant latitude, which means they actually curve slightly towards the north as you go along them.
    (Of course, the grids in a lot of places aren’t exactly N-S/E-W — where I live, it’s rotated a good 40deg. I think they wanted to orient roughly w.r.t the river shore).

  32. Kagehi says

    @43 Ugh.. Way too many maps used in search and rescue use this coordinate system and years back my dad suggested making a program that tracked all the “marked location” that they sometimes had to find and look up, to coordinate with people. I stupidly volunteered and then got tied up in a) it probably isn’t going to fit on a single floppy, and b) how the F do you automatically have it do the math to convert between them, so people don’t have to enter both sets of coordinates, for every single bloody location? It never ended up being finished, since it was more of a, “Could we do this?”, with no expectation it would necessarily work, and, obviously, a few years later better GPS became available to pretty much everyone. But, yeah, this brings back annoying memories. lol

  33. whheydt says

    Re: stevewatson @ #43…
    Those N-S longitude lines are “meridians”.
    On a mildly different point of all this… Then there are the people who look at a Mercator projection map and think that it represents actual areas correctly. You know the ones… Thinking that Greenland is REALLY big.

  34. Steve Morrison says

    Of course the earth isn’t flat! Everyone knows that it’s hollow and we’re living on the inside.

  35. d3zd3z says

    So aside from “Rainier” being most recently surveyed at 14,410 ft, this is really a terrible photo to try to use as an argument for a curved earth. If the position of the camera were given, someone could calculate what the image should look like. But, the main reason Rainier looks smaller is perspective, and the earth’s curvature only accounts for part of that. There would be a place for a camera that would have a similar view to this photo if the earth were flat. (Aside from things like no mechanism to explain mountains on a flat earth)

    In other words, there are plenty of things that do actually demonstrate the curvature of the earth, we don’t need to tout photos that don’t actually do that.

Leave a Reply