So much snow. So much grading. I need to dig myself out from under both today, so I’m not going to be posting much, even though there’s a few things I’m itching to write about. So, instead, I leave you with some dance moves.
No, sir. Don’t like it. Gangnam Style was ok, but not digging this one. At all.
drownersays
By using only the most charitable definition could this be called music. That is not an indictment of electronic music at all, either. But think about how rudimentary the process is to produce these sounds, especially given current available technology and the fact that there is not an original thought or note contained within.
There are much better wastes of time on the internet, IMO.
davidnanglesays
The visuals are far more entertaining than the audio portion. Perhaps it could be favorably synched with ragtime. Or death metal.
throwaway, butcher of tongues, mauler of metaphorsays
drowner @4:
I wonder if vocal purists were ever saying the same thing about instruments. Maybe it went something like this:
By using only the most charitable definition could this be called music. That is not an indictment of instrumental music at all, either. But think about how rudimentary the process is to produce these sounds, especially given current available woodworking and metallurgy practices, and the fact that there is not an original thought or note contained within.
There are much better wastes of time in the salon, IMO.
SqueakyVoicesays
So, imitating a school child and making sexually suggestive ‘dance moves’ at school girls and teachers is okay, again?
Did I miss a memo or something?
drownersays
@6
Come on, really? Is there no way of objectively evaluating music? Are all vocalists equally sonorous? Can’t it be shown how utterly derivative the notes and beats in PSY’s video are? Yes, all music is derivative in some way, but the percentage in this example is hovering near 100%.
drownersays
I was not criticizing electronic music; I was criticizing only this one example.
Vivecsays
I would argue that plenty of extremely derivative music excellent, and plenty of comparatively original music is complete garbage. Subjectively, of course, because that’s what taste is.
Steven Brown: Man of Mediocritysays
@Vivec #10
As my saxophone tutor used to tell me in reference to improvisation: “Anyone can be original and crap. I’d rather you played something clichéd and sounded good.”
drownersays
@10 & 11
I agree, and it was inelegant of me to focus only on the lack of originality of this song. Heck, I listen to Ornette pretty frequently (listened to the album, Free Jazz, just yesterday). Your sax tutor was right. When the hooks, instrumentation, timbre, tone, rhythm, etc. has been done so many times already, I guess it requires some face-transplantation software, and an “edgy” choreographer for your video, to make a song successful.
I can hardly wait till “Revelation Unraveled” posts its detailed analysis of the apocalyptic significance of Psy’s new video, just like it did with “The Antichrist Arrives Gangnam Style!”
lotharloosays
@14:
Holy shit, that “Revelation Unraveled” is totally delicious! I want to watch all of the videos! :))))))))
raelsays
Even if the song isn’t your thing, he’s wonderfully talented and infectiously fun. I’m not someone who has any appreciation for dancing but even his basic silly dance moves look really well executed and deliberately humorous at the same time.
What shocked me was that I assumed he’d have the same level of fandom in South Korea as Weird Al in America, but not so, his concerts are jaw-droppingly massive in attendance and in scope. They look like the opening to the Olympics with the amount of pyrotechnics and people involved.
davidnangle says
Three generations of lady killing at the same time, plus a Korean Disco Stu tying it all together… Colossal win.
lakitha tolbert says
OMG! This stupid video just totally won my morning!
YOB - Ye Olde Blacksmith says
No, sir. Don’t like it. Gangnam Style was ok, but not digging this one. At all.
drowner says
By using only the most charitable definition could this be called music. That is not an indictment of electronic music at all, either. But think about how rudimentary the process is to produce these sounds, especially given current available technology and the fact that there is not an original thought or note contained within.
There are much better wastes of time on the internet, IMO.
davidnangle says
The visuals are far more entertaining than the audio portion. Perhaps it could be favorably synched with ragtime. Or death metal.
throwaway, butcher of tongues, mauler of metaphor says
drowner @4:
I wonder if vocal purists were ever saying the same thing about instruments. Maybe it went something like this:
SqueakyVoice says
So, imitating a school child and making sexually suggestive ‘dance moves’ at school girls and teachers is okay, again?
Did I miss a memo or something?
drowner says
@6
Come on, really? Is there no way of objectively evaluating music? Are all vocalists equally sonorous? Can’t it be shown how utterly derivative the notes and beats in PSY’s video are? Yes, all music is derivative in some way, but the percentage in this example is hovering near 100%.
drowner says
I was not criticizing electronic music; I was criticizing only this one example.
Vivec says
I would argue that plenty of extremely derivative music excellent, and plenty of comparatively original music is complete garbage. Subjectively, of course, because that’s what taste is.
Steven Brown: Man of Mediocrity says
@Vivec #10
As my saxophone tutor used to tell me in reference to improvisation: “Anyone can be original and crap. I’d rather you played something clichéd and sounded good.”
drowner says
@10 & 11
I agree, and it was inelegant of me to focus only on the lack of originality of this song. Heck, I listen to Ornette pretty frequently (listened to the album, Free Jazz, just yesterday). Your sax tutor was right. When the hooks, instrumentation, timbre, tone, rhythm, etc. has been done so many times already, I guess it requires some face-transplantation software, and an “edgy” choreographer for your video, to make a song successful.
Anders Kehlet says
@7: Yeah, it creeped me out too.
Zeno says
I can hardly wait till “Revelation Unraveled” posts its detailed analysis of the apocalyptic significance of Psy’s new video, just like it did with “The Antichrist Arrives Gangnam Style!”
lotharloo says
@14:
Holy shit, that “Revelation Unraveled” is totally delicious! I want to watch all of the videos! :))))))))
rael says
Even if the song isn’t your thing, he’s wonderfully talented and infectiously fun. I’m not someone who has any appreciation for dancing but even his basic silly dance moves look really well executed and deliberately humorous at the same time.
What shocked me was that I assumed he’d have the same level of fandom in South Korea as Weird Al in America, but not so, his concerts are jaw-droppingly massive in attendance and in scope. They look like the opening to the Olympics with the amount of pyrotechnics and people involved.