Bad People Do Good Things


What makes a person “bad”?

I want to start by saying that I’m honestly not comfortable designating a person as bad, or as evil, as though it were some inherent quality that could never change. It’s far too easy for us to get caught up in our own perspective, and forget the humanity of our fellow humans. That said, there are some people who just seem to be bad, even if we can’t always agree on who those people are.

I would hope that the most widely accepted answer is rooted in some version of “doing bad things”, but one of the sadder lessons we must learn is that what actions are “good” or “bad” is often going to vary greatly from person to person, or community to community. Most of what I got from my religious upbringing, as a Quaker in New England, still applies to my current atheist/humanist perspective on things, and I would honestly be surprised to learn that anyone within that community believed it impossible for an atheist to be a good person, or for a Quaker to be a bad person. The perspective I suspect the majority of our species believes, is that the “badness” of a person is determined by their actions, and more specifically by the harm they do, the harm they allow when they could prevent it, and the good they could do, but won’t.

Within this overarching “evil is as evil does” perspective, there are a number of qualifiers, depending on who you ask. For some people, harmful acts are only bad when done to out-groups. This is probably the mindset that allows for a lot of the systemic harm in the world. The extreme example would be fascists, who range from “harmful acts are bad but must be done for the greater good”, to “harmful acts are good, when done to those of various out-groups.

Because for some people, you can only be a good person if you are part of their specific in-group, unless proven otherwise. The best you can hope for is to wrongly believe you’re a good person, or to pretend you’re a good person. Some Christians even believe that everyone actually KNOWS they’re evil and deserving of torture, it’s just that most of us are in denial.

I think one thing that unites even more people than the “badness means doing harm”, is the simple fact that bad people do good things.

Bad people do good things all the time.

It’s possible to be an active and committed member of the 21st century Republican Party – a fascist – and also be nice to the people in your circle, and even self-sacrifice for them. German society, for a famous example, has been very into dogs for a long time, and that includes during the years of Nazi rule. Why, even Mother Theresa might have done some good in her lifetime!

Even those who believe nobody outside their religion can be good accept that outsiders do good things.

This is, to me, obvious.

I also think it’s probably worth stating explicitly from time to time, because when confronted with the worst people in the world, there will invariably be some folks insisting they’re not all THAT bad, because they do [insert good thing here]. It’s how billionaires justify their obscene wealth, while still using it to exert influence by funding some things, and not others. We can, however, grant that every cent of that philanthropy is a purely selfless investment in the betterment of society, and still see that the very real good it does is nowhere near enough to make up for the harm involved in accumulating the obscene wealth of, for example, the tech oligarchs.

The materials for our phones, and our computers, and the cancerous growth of data centers, come at a terrible human cost. Slavery remains a crucial part of capitalism, and the lives consumed in the extraction of things like cobalt rival many of the horrors of the past that we pretend to have left behind. Billionaires, as a class, are the main drivers of the endless wars against communism, terrorism, or whatever the bogeyman of the day happens to be. War is a time-tested way to turn raw material, taxes, and people, into rubble, profits, and corpses. It also keeps the price of labor and goods low, by making it hard for the former colonies from building enough power to assert any kind of sovereignty over their natural resources. If Iran, or Venezuela, for example, did something truly evil like nationalizing their oil supply, well, they’re not honoring contracts signed under colonial occupation and at gunpoint. Stop supplying the corporate overlords with the cheap materials they demand, and the gun comes back out.

Things are going to get worse over the next couple years, as the current US fascist regime grows increasingly desperate to hold on to power, and the tech oligarchs try to set themselves up to rule whatever comes after. Unfortunately, its global military presence and economic dominance mean that the whole world must suffer for what the US has become. But as we move forward, we are going to continue wrestling with the question of how seemingly good people can support such atrocities, and it’s important to remember that while there do seem to be some people who are purely malevolent, like Trump or Stephen Miller, most of the terrible people in history had what some might consider “redeeming qualities”, because they were human, and we tend to be pretty complicated.

I don’t think we should have a punitive justice system, but I think that allowing the people most responsible for the current state of affairs to just get away with it is an even worse option. When deciding what to do with them, we have to remember that just because we saw a different side of them, or we find them relatable in some way, does not lessen the harm they did. It also does not diminish the likelihood of them doing more harm in the future, should they be given the opportunity to do so.

 


Because I need to spend so much of my time trying to pay bills, I’ve had to dedicate less time to this blog. Even so, I’ve mostly been able to publish something every week, on my patreon. Because FTB has been down recently, you all are now a bit behind. If you want to stay caught up, if you want to support my work, or if you want me to be able to spend more time on this, you should sign up at patreon.com/oceanoxia and throw a little pocket change my way. There aren’t a lot of perks at the moment, but you get more reliable access to my work, some particles and drafts that don’t make it to the blog here, and a little bit of art. If you give me enough money, I’ll even mail you an art!

Comments

  1. Pierce R. Butler says

    As a native of the US southeast (aka, a “southerner”), I can’t help but point to our famous – and real – “southern hospitality” (in actuality rooted in the sheer isolation and loneliness of upper-crust plantation life) as a prime example of BPDGT.

  2. Snowberry says

    There’s something which I hope to fully research and write up someday, though I’m not sure where I’d publish it because I don’t currently have a blog or anything. It’s basically a what-if scenario, what if we collectively decided to partition the physical world into communities in a similar fashion to how the internet is partitioned into countless online communities. Where people can join up and live among others of similar beliefs and lifestyles.

    Relevant to your post, one of the benefits to that would be that people who believe that large swaths of humanity are evil or subhuman can minimize their contact with outsiders, making their life more comfortable and making people who would otherwise have to deal with them safer. This isn’t intended to be the main purpose of meatspace partitioning, because it doesn’t solve that particular problem, it merely sidesteps a major part of it. If anything, it would probably make things harder, which counts as a major point against doing it unless we’ve either effectively cured bigotry or written it off as unsolvable.

    We’d also need a small number of involuntary communities for people who are too dysfunctional and/or antisocial to fit anywhere and refuse to change or be helped. They’d be open-air prisons, essentially, but far nicer. (“Far nicer” is contingent on the management being able to keep people from constantly fighting with each other and/or wrecking the place. I don’t envy anyone who would take that role.) But even most of those people don’t deserve to be around serial killers and similarly dangerous psychos. But short of maybe forcing them to permanently live in FDVR (Full-Dive Virtual Reality, which is likely a long way from existing) I’m not sure there’s any truly humane way to deal with those people.

    Of course, there are many, many issues with the idea of partitioning the physical world this way, and one of the biggest one is how communities can potentially turn into what I call “nightmare traps” where a significant number of people within them don’t belong and most can’t or won’t leave. For example, gay kids being born in a “gays are evil” community which disallows internet access. This already exists in the real world, of course, but depending on how the system would work out it might actually make this issue worse in some ways, making a mockery of the whole idea of people being able to choose where they belong.

  3. Jenora Feuer says

    The idea that there are somehow ‘good people’ and ‘bad people’ is, really, part of the problem, as it can lead to ‘as long as we make sure only good people get this power …’ thinking. Few people actually consider themselves to be villains, and believing in a ‘higher purpose’ of any sort can lead to problems.

    Stalin was an autocrat building his own cult of personality. Lenin was, from what I’ve seen, a true believer who spent time actively working to convince himself that the omelette they were making absolutely was worth all the ‘eggs’ they were breaking: he despaired that he had to be a monster to bring forth the utopian ideal, and he apparently didn’t want a statue to himself at all, preferring the celebration be for the movement rather than himself. This made Lenin both the more sympathetic and the more dangerous of the two, as he would operate in what he felt were the movement’s best interests rather than his own.

    As C. S. Lewis said, “Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron’s cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.”

    @Snowberry:
    The Terra Ignota series of SF books actually has something like that as part of its world background; ‘nations’ are defined primarily by ideology rather than geography, and most of the more powerful groups are very intent on ensuring that everybody knows what the choices are, if only because they figure that people knowing what the choices are will be good for recruitment. Needless to say, you have to have a world that not only has worldwide communications but is largely post-scarcity in order to actually pull it off.

  4. says

    @Jenora – I’m in almost complete agreement, but I think CS Lewis was a bit off with that quote. The robber barons, as it turns out, do not get satiated, and they pay people to ensure that their cruelty continues while they sleep. More than that, capitalism justifies itself as being for the good of those it oppresses. Hell, it’s framed by its proponents as the best possible system, both morally and practically, for literally everyone. I’m not sure there is such a thing as tyranny that doesn’t claim to be for the common good.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *