Peak Republican


I’m sure you’ve all heard about Vivek Ramaswamy’s attack ad, but to briefly summarize: Ramaswamy is running for Ohio governor against Amy Acton. Acton had a horrible childhood, being sexually assaulted by her creepy stepfather as a pre-teen, and said creep fled the state to avoid prosecution, and Acton’s mother fled with him, abandoning her children. None of that is in dispute, and is a matter of record. Acton persevered, got a medical degree, and is now running for governor, admirable, even heroic, accomplishments.

Ramaswamy, in contrast, was a spoiled rich kid and pharmaceutical drug lord, who peddled a failed Alzheimer’s drug, and who always presents as a cocky arrogant loser. His image is…not good. So he chose to run an attack ad starring Acton’s deadbeat mother, supportive wife of a rapist, accusing Acton of lying. He chose to replace his face, the face of slick, rich, profiteering pharmaceutical grifter, with the image of a bad mother who abandoned his opponent as a child to live with a rapist.

This sounds like a very bad idea, but I don’t know — it does make him look like a peak Republican, an alpha with no morality, which has been a winning recipe for the party of authoritarians. There are people who actually consider obedience to one’s parents, no matter how awful they are, to be a virtue. They’re the ones who like to quote the ten commandments and argue that if you don’t honor your mother and father, you’ll burn in hell. It might lock down a few votes for him. From, you know, the kind of people who favor the parenting methods of Michael and Debi Pearl.

My mother was a sweetie pie, who I know would not stand by if her husband was abusive (my father was not, not by a long shot), so my personal experience biases me to favor mothers. I have heard enough stories of terrible parenting to know that excreting a baby doesn’t necessarily make you a good person, and have seen enough examples in the news of parents torturing or killing their children to know that evil isn’t a contraceptive.

I’ll be watching the Ohio election. If Ramaswamy gets elected, I’ll know that Americans are beyond hope.

Comments

  1. cartomancer says

    Presumably the horrible people who have such views were going to vote for the Republican anyway?

    Or is it that, being of Asian heritage, he feels he needs to shore up his monster cred more than a flabby white guy would with this constituency?

  2. Leo Buzalsky says

    cartomancer @1, I suspect it’s a recognition that the “independent” vote is essentially lost. So, at this point, their best bet is to anger the base to drive better turnout from them. To your first question, then, I suspect their concern is that a significant number of those people with horrible views might not show up due to them being demotivated thanks to Trump. So I think it’s more hoping the math works such that he gains more votes than he loses, hoping that the people upset by the ad were already voting against him anyway — and thus not losing any votes — and that it brings out disgruntled MAGA voters.

  3. cheerfulcharlie says

    This stunt seems to be blowing up in his face. Acton leads but not by much, but outside the error margin. There are only 8 days until voting day so this will be fresh in voters’ minds as they head to the voting booth. I hope this loses him the election and serves as a warning for future MAGA punks running for office.

  4. raven says

    The mother was and is a generic monster who lost custody of both of her children, Amy Acton and her brother.
    The brother has already supported Dr. Acton’s account of her childhood.

    The mother was also convicted of killing two kittens, by leaving them in a locked hot car. ‘
    I was wondering why her two cats and the kittens were in her car anyway.
    It turns out she was homeless and living in her car at the time.

    Amy Acton’s estranged mother, Donna Arthur, was convicted of animal neglect after leaving newborn kittens in a sweltering car.

    The Incident and Court Case

    • The Date & Location: On April 6, 2021, Donna Arthur left several cats and five-day-old kittens inside her locked car while parked outside her workplace in Pennsylvania.
    • The Conditions: The outdoor temperature was around 76 degrees, but the interior temperature of the vehicle reached 120 degrees with the windows rolled up.
    • The Outcome: Four kittens were recovered from the car; one had already died, and a second died later from suspected heat exhaustion.
    • The Conviction: Arthur was found guilty of animal neglect and sentenced to a fine and probation. In 2023, a Pennsylvania appeals court vacated the conviction due to a procedural error regarding her lack of a court-appointed attorney, though the appellate court rejected her claim that prosecutors lacked sufficient evidence.

  5. Akira MacKenzie says

    Gasp! How DARE you not take the word of this salt of the Earth, Christian mee-maw over that of her evil, vaccinating, woke, blue-haired, Soros-puppet daughter. HONOR THY MOTHER AND THY FATHER!

    ;)

  6. strangerinastrangeland says

    “They’re the ones who like to quote the ten commandments and argue that if you don’t honor your mother and father, you’ll burn in hell.”

    Always funny that those people who quote one specific part of the bible, which fits their narrative, then totally ignore all the other stuff they are supposed to do, like not killing anyone (see the death penalty or the insane U.S. gun laws).

  7. says

    I wonder what the actual motivation for the ancient biblical author was when they wrote “honor thy mother and thy father.” On one hand, it could have been the naive expectation that parents are worthy of it by default. On the other hand, and my cynical side leans this direction: Religious instruction to stay with your abusive parents.

    Heard one interpretation of Beauty and the Beast was about alleviating fear of arranged marriages, teaching little girls that they could “fix him” if they got a bad husband.

  8. says

    If Ramaswamy gets elected, I’ll know that Americans are beyond hope.

    I’m disgusted that the race was ever even close. Ramaslimy was obviously nothing more than a blatant fraud and a hateful little pipsqueak LONG before this ad of his came out. At least as disgraceful and shameful as Ramaslimy himself, is the fact that the Retrumplitarian Party, at the national/institutional level, took that little shit seriously for more than ten seconds. Is he really the best Ohio Republicans could find?

  9. Ridana says

    And no surprise, Preznident Pedophile full on supports this, saying his sainted mother would never say anything like that about him, and agreed that Acton was a liar and a terrible person, and he didn’t know anything about a stepfather, this has nothing to do with a stepfather. All while telling the reporter to shut up after he asked her why she wouldn’t believe the mother’s side. It’s a remarkable display of all the things wrong with his brain.

    Just don’t read the comments – most of them support him and the mothers are saints angle and think the reporter should’ve been more “respectful.”

  10. birgerjohansson says

    Ridana @ 11

    This is so obviously horrible the (D) senate candidates should (and hopefully will) rub it in:
    The (R) candidates who do not clearly condemn this crap de facto approve of the narrative Trump spreads about a rapist stepfather and the enabling mother not being the bad guys.
    .
    Just play the clip over and over agson in ads, and say the republican candidate refuse to condemn the gaslighting.

    I am not good at English, I am sure you can phrase it in a more devastating way. Make the voters see the Epstein class and their bought politicians for what they are.
    I have to sign off now, I have molten lava pouring out my ears…

  11. says

    @birgerjohansson:
    Unfortunately, the Trump era has taught me that gaslighting is an all-American pastime. I’ve seen so many people just accept the state of affairs, I feel like I’ve crossed into a parallel world where manchildren are the norm, and I’m told to be ashamed for paying attention to sex education lessons about consent. Of course, the world has been that way for a long time, and I just got un-sheltered. Then Trump got elected, and everyone lost interest in maintaining even the facade that truth or morality matter.

    It’s a hell of a revelation that so many people never meant anything they ever said.

  12. birgerjohansson says

    Recursive Rabbit @ 14
    .
    The 30% will always be a horrible regressive bloc of fascist adjacent voters, but they are not 50%.
    The independents, even those who are fiscal conservatives are not in the cult.

    Bombard them with evidence of how Trump and Rawaswami ignore child SA and how the other Republicans are yellow cowards who do not call out the cult leader.
    Keep reminding them that 95% of those with an (R) are fine with not releasing the remaining Epstein information.
    .
    This shit hits a nerve other MAGA shenagians do not. Keep hitting it the remaining week, especially in “tossup” electoral districts.
    .
    I can’t beleive I am less cynical, maybe the lack of sleep is getting to me…

  13. John Morales says

    gaslighting

    Misused term in this context. It does not mean misinformation in general.
    It does not mean plain lying. It does not mean disputing a claim via a third party.

    (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaslighting)

    It specifically refers to psychological manipulation involving two parties, where a “gaslighter” persistently puts forth a false narrative to make the “gaslighted” individual doubt their own reality, memory, or sanity.

    Is this making voters doubt their own reality, memory, or sanity? No. So it does not apply.

    I am not good at English, I am sure you can phrase it in a more devastating way.

    It has to be at least a tiny weeny bit ‘devastating’ it order to be even more so, so, no.

  14. CompulsoryAccount7746, Sky Captain says

    Recursive Rabbit @7:

    my cynical side leans this direction: Religious instruction to stay with your abusive parents.

    Wikipedia – Honour thy father and thy mother

    [In Judaism]: Because honouring parents is part of honouring God, the mitzvah does not depend on the worthiness of the parent: “Even if his father is wicked and a sinner, he must fear and revere him … A convert to Judaism must not curse or despise his non-Jewish father.” (Kitzur Shulchan Aruch 143:13,25)
    […]
    Honouring one’s parents is also described in the Torah as an analogue to honouring God. […] According to the prophet Malachi, God calls for similar honour.
    […]
    [In Protestant Christianity, John Calvin wrote]: the name of Father is a sacred one, and is transferred to men by the peculiar goodness of God, the dishonouring of parents redounds to the dishonour of God Himself, nor can anyone despise his father without being guilty of an offence against God, (sacrilegious.) If any should object that there are many ungodly and wicked fathers whom their children cannot regard with honour without destroying the distinction between good and evil, the reply is easy, that the perpetual law of nature is not subverted by the sins of men; and therefore, however unworthy of honour a father may be, that he still retains, inasmuch as he is a father, his right over his children

    “peculiar goodness of God”, heh.

  15. Pierce R. Butler says

    John Morales @ # 16 expounds Is this making voters doubt their own reality, memory, or sanity? No. So it does not apply. with such confidence some might even think he knew what he was talking about.

    He describes “gaslighting” as put forth in the 1938 play of the (almost-) same name; he might as well dub the swastika as a benign symbol of south Asian religion.

    Consider these quotations:

    The aim in both cases is consistency. Before they seize power and establish a world according to their doctrines, totalitarian movements conjure up a lying world of consistency which is more adequate to the needs of the human mind than reality itself; in which, through sheer imagination, uprooted masses can feel at home and are spared the never-ending shocks which real life and real experiences deal to human beings and their expectations. The force possessed by totalitarian propaganda—before the movements have the power to drop iron curtains to prevent anyone’s disturbing, by the slightest reality, the gruesome quiet of an entirely imaginary world—lies in its ability to shut the masses off from the real world.
    The Origins of Totalitarianism, Chapter 11 Totalitarian Movements, Part I Totalitarian Propaganda

    In their situation of spiritual and social homelessness, a measured insight into the interdependence of the arbitrary and the planned, the accidental and the necessary, could no longer operate. Totalitarian propaganda can outrageously insult common sense only where common sense has lost its validity. Before the alternative of facing the anarchic growth and total arbitrariness of decay or bowing down before the most rigid, fantastically fictitious consistency of an ideology, the masses probably will always choose the latter and be ready to pay for it with individual sacrifices — and this not because they are stupid or wicked, but because in the general disaster this escape grants them a minimum of self-respect.
    – ibid

    and

    The ideal subject of totalitarian rule is not the convinced Nazi or the convinced Communist, but people for whom the distinction between fact and fiction (i.e., the reality of experience) and the distinction between true and false (i.e., the standards of thought) no longer exist.
    – ibid

    Me, I just wonder why no updated version of Patrick Hamilton’s play has been made into a major movie. We (USAnians in particular) need another Spartacus.

  16. John Morales says

    Pierce R. Butler wanked thus:

    John Morales @ # 16 expounds Is this making voters doubt their own reality, memory, or sanity? No. So it does not apply.

    <snicker> You get what you give.

    That was not expounding, that was asking a question, of the rhetorical variety.
    I am not making any elaborate explanation, or any thesis. Just pointing out the obvious, really.

    Don’t like Wikipedia?
    Here: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/10888683251342291

    Gaslighting is a type of emotional abuse where someone manipulates another person into doubting their own sense of reality.

    Again: The advert is purely a smear; the objective is to destroy an opponent’s public reputation in the eyes of a third party (the voters). It is designed to discredit and defame. Not interpersonal.

    Political smear adverts are not gaslighting.

    Gaslighting is psychological manipulation designed to make someone question their own perception of reality, memory, or sanity, leading to a dependence on the perpetrator. Interpersonal.

    He describes “gaslighting” as put forth in the 1938 play of the (almost-) same name; he might as well dub the swastika as a benign symbol of south Asian religion.

    Well, yes. That is what it fucking means!
    Its origin, its current meaning.

    —

    I am right here, coward. Addressing me in the third person is typical of your lot.
    It makes no diff, only the comment-count, so far. And the other 4 strictures.

    BTW, you evince some ignorance:
    https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20210816-the-ancient-symbol-that-was-hijacked-by-evil

    Hindu cultural organisations and religious groups have tried to explain that the Nazis did not use the swastika, but a hooked cross. The Nazi swastika has the arms turned to 45 degrees giving a slant to the symbol, whereas the swastikas of Hinduism are presented with the base arm lying flat.
     
    When Adolf Hitler was looking for a symbol for his newly launched party, he used the hakenkreuz, rotating the swastika to the right and omitting the four dots – he then adopted this as the party’s emblem in 1920. Joseph Goebbels, Hitler’s minister of propaganda, passed a law in May 1933 that prevented unauthorised commercial use of the hooked cross.

  17. silvrhalide says

    There are people who actually consider obedience to one’s parents, no matter how awful they are, to be a virtue.

    Classic for a reason
    https://issendai.com/psychology/estrangement/missing-missing-reasons/

    Really, if you want to understand the MAGAsphere, try the estranged parents forums. The delusional beliefs are jaw-dropping. But they also go a long way in explaining how they can be so completely delusional about other things. The solipsism and magical thinking are truly mind-boggling. Amy Acton’s mother kicked her and her brother to the curb to be with a pedophile rapist but she somehow can’t figure out why her kids don’t want her in their lives.

  18. says

    I’m pretty sure Amy Acton’s biological spawnpoint knows why she’s hated by her daughter on a certain level, but like all weak-willed and pathetic self-loathing pieces of gutterscum she copes by indulging in extreme narcissism where she’s always the victim who did everything right and it’s some unfair evil universe that’s undeservedly punishing her.
    After all, that’s the same way her lord and master Drowzy Donald Dumb has acted his entire life.

  19. indianajones says

    @Sky Captain and Pierce, might I suggest that instead of talking, perhaps we might sing together? I even fast forwarded to the best bit :D

Leave a Reply