The politics of crowds and poll numbers


There has been a lot of reporting about the size of crowds at campaign rallies. I have never been too impressed by crowd sizes as an indicator of popularity because however large they may be, they represent just a tiny fraction of the votes one needs to win. They measure more the depth of intensity of the most ardent supporters of a candidate, not the breadth of support. For example, in the case of creepy Donald Trump, there seem to be many of the same people who go to rally after rally, sometimes traveling great distances. It is like a cult following. Such people can swell multiple rally crowd numbers but still have only one vote.

But rally crowds do help campaigns in several important ways. The people who are enthusiastic enough to spend a big chunk of a day going to a campaign event and lining up to get in are those who are very likely to vote and, more importantly, more willing to work on the campaign in some way. You can be sure that there are campaign staffers at these events who are signing up people as donors and volunteers. While getting money helps since so much is needed for expensive TV advertising, American elections are awash with so much dark money that by the time elections come around, the airwaves are saturated with so many ads that they are unlikely to sway voters. Their purpose is largely to remind those who are already committed as to why they should stick with the candidate. The main benefit of getting new people to contribute even a small amount is not the money but because once you have given money to some cause, you are more invested in that candidate and want that person to win, like betting on a horse or a sports team.

It is signing up volunteers that is more important. They play a crucial role back in their neighborhoods, especially close to election day, doing door-to-door canvassing, putting up yard signs, distributing banners, encouraging people to vote early, and getting out the vote on election day. Rallies are usually the best way to find and recruit such people.

Creepy Donald Trump desperately wants to feel that he is loved and admired. That is why he is always boasting about himself and is such a sucker for sycophants, praising anyone who sucks up to him, however obviously phony that adoration may seem to the rest of us. After all, weird JD Vance was just a few years ago one of his harshest critics and yet creepy Trump picked him as his running mate because weird Vance, seeing no future in the current GOP by being anti-Trump, shameless did a 180-degree turn and started fulsomely praising him.

The two measures that creepy Trump really obsesses about, because he thinks they show how much people love him, are crowd sizes and poll numbers. He constantly talks about how large his rallies are, usually inflating the numbers, and gets really upset when it is suggested that other people are getting larger crowds. It is utterly childish but that is who he is.

He has even made the bonkers claim that the images of the large crowd that attended a Harris-Walz rally on an airport tarmac were AI generated and that in reality there was no one there.

“Has anyone noticed that Kamala CHEATED at the airport? There was nobody at the plane, and she ‘A.I.’d’ it, and showed a massive ‘crowd’ of so-called followers, BUT THEY DIDN’T EXIST!” Trump writes. “She was turned in by a maintenance worker at the airport when he noticed the fake crowd picture, but there was nobody there, later confirmed by the reflection of the mirror like finish on the Vice Presidential Plane. She’s a CHEATER. She had NOBODY waiting, and the ‘crowd’ looked like 10,000 people! Same thing is happening with her fake ‘crowds’ at her speeches. 

But even some conservatives are conceding that the images of large crowds at Harris-Walz rallies are real.

Former Republican speaker Kevin McCarthy, who famously traveled all the way to Mar-a-Lago to grovel before creepy Trump after criticizing him for instigating the January 6th attacks, is also asking him to stop questioning the size of the Harris crowds, probably realizing how ridiculous it makes creepy Trump look to anyone outside the MAGAsphere.

Then we have opinion polls, creepy Trump’s other obsession. Since his numbers have been dropping recently, creepy Trump has started saying that those polls are fake too and that ‘real’ polls (whatever the hell they are) show him leading.

Predictably, just as news outlets were beginning to publish their “AI crowd” fact checks, Trump allowed a new wave of denial to take over.

“I’m doing really well in the Presidential Race, leading in almost all of the REAL polls,” Trump posted Sunday night, assuring supporters and possibly himself that his 2024 run “is thus far my best Campaign,” with the “most enthusiasm and spirit, etc.”

Trump, eight years older and just weeks removed from an actual near-death experience, is no longer capable of vigorously campaigning like he did in 2016; even his boasting appears mailed in. The former president appears content to live in an alternate reality where he’s winning, by a lot, and can let Sen. JD Vance, R-Ohio, his historically unpopular running mate, do the hard work of leaving the house.

Republican pollster Frank Luntz is worried.

“Quite frankly, people like [Harris] more than they like him,” GOP pollster Frank Luntz conceded Sunday on CNN. Trump, sitting at home instead of campaigning, is seeing that and losing his mind, Luntz said: “His head is exploding and that’s part of the problem.”

It is a puzzle why creepy Trump isn’t holding more rallies. His schedule is very light. After holding one rally in Montana last Friday, his next one is in Pennsylvania this coming Saturday. An entire week between rallies seems like a surprisingly long gap at this stage of the campaign. The only event he seems to have scheduled in the interim is the interview with Elon Musk.

Maybe he just does not have the energy to do more. After all, he is 78 years old. Now that the older Joe Biden is out of the race, he is being compared with the much younger and much more vigorous Harris and he does not come off well.

Comments

  1. file thirteen says

    The two measures that creepy Trump really obsesses about, because he thinks they show how much people love him, are crowd sizes and poll numbers. He constantly talks about how large his rallies are, usually inflating the numbers, and gets really upset when it is suggested that other people are getting larger crowds. It is utterly childish but that is who he is.

    Alternatively, it could actually be an insightful understanding of his followers’ mentalities, realising that most can only think in pictures and not in maths, and knowing the mental picture of a large crowd is more convincing to such people than any explanation as to why it shouldn’t matter.

    It is a puzzle why creepy Trump isn’t holding more rallies.

    Possibly he’s run out of material and fears people will get bored with the same old same old. He may be just waiting and hoping for Harris or Walz to give him something to work with. He does keep trying to fling mud after all, just nothing seems to stick.

  2. Snowberry says

    I figured it’s a combination of Trump not having the stamina to do rallies quite like he used to plus having to deal with all the court-related issues. You can’t as easily go gallivanting around the country when you have to spend a lot of time in New York and Florida.

  3. birgerjohansson says

    Once people have made an emotional investment, it is hard to change their minds.

    During Reagan many Americans voted for the first time. His recipe of nationalism and populism made many vote for him -- against their own interests- and they became Republicans.
    Until at least the second Dubya term.

  4. Katydid says

    Every accusation is a confession with that crowd, and likely his team is playing around with AI to make the crowds seem bigger.

  5. kenny256 says

    As a former TV actor, Trump is obsessed with ratings.

    Every day is another episode for Trump as the star in his own mind of the Trump Show.

    He wakes up and goes to makeup and wardrobe, and gets his schedule and appearances for the day, then reviews the list of “central casting” that he will select to be included in this episode.

    Everyone else is just bit players with minor roles in his show. The show is all about him and the purpose is RATINGS.

    High ratings is all that matters--that is where the money is and the power flows.

    Of course it doesn’t hurt to advertise and sell some overpriced crappy trinkets, bibles, sneakers, fake gold coins stamped with his image (they are stamped from iron slugs), etc.

  6. JM says

    I saw one analyst who said that getting back at Biden was part of Trump’s reason for running again and Biden dropping has yanked that out. This is why Trump is still talking about Biden so much.
    I think Trump would have run anyways but Biden exiting the race has messed up Trump’s motivations and plan. He can’t cast this as proving he really won in 2020 once Biden left.

  7. garnetstar says

    “It is a puzzle why creepy Trump isn’t holding more rallies”

    Well, lately he was very, very close to being murdered at a rally. That would frighten me, and he’s never been known for his courage.

    And, oh no, not the “skewed polls” fantasy again! What Trump is saying is just a crude repeat of that Romney-Obama mass delusion.

  8. KG says

    Possibly he’s run out of material and fears people will get bored with the same old same old. He may be just waiting and hoping for Harris or Walz to give him something to work with. -- filethirteen@1

    I think the first sentence there misunderstands Trump’s psychology: everythnig he does is perfect as far as he’s concerned, so no-one could possibly be bored by what he says. The second sentence I think over-rates his level of strategic thinking. Much more likely he’s simply too low in energy, and is spending what energy he has in ruminating on how unfair it is that he’d “won” (in his own mind) and then Biden was replaced by Harris.

  9. Tethys says

    I think part of the reason why he isn’t holding more rallies is the fact that they are expensive and he is a deadbeat who has outstanding bills in multiple large cities from his previous rallies.

    Trump is set to take the stage at Asheville’s Thomas Wolfe Auditorium on Wednesday after paying $82,247.60 to the city for a “last-minute” rally, according to Blue Ridge Public Radio (BPR).
    [capacity -- 2,431]

    While the campaign paid in advance due to Asheville’s policy for short-notice bookings, Trump has a long history of failing to pay cities for billed rally fees, leaving office in January 2021 with at least $850,000 in unpaid rally debt. Most of the bills are still unpaid, including more than $500,000 owed to the city of El Paso, Texas.

    https://www.newsweek.com/trump-campaign-forced-pay-north-carolina-city-82k-advance-rally-1938769

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *