There are no atheists in foxholes, by definition


Pete Hegseth has decreed that there are only 31 religions that will be officially recognized by the US military, in an effort to pare down and streamline the efficiency of their administration. Of the 31, 22 are hair-splitting variants of the Christian cult, which to my mind suggests that there are greater efficiencies to be achieved, if only this policy were administered by someone who doesn’t have Crusader tattoos all over his body, and isn’t a member of Doug Wilson’s white nationalist church.

But surprise, surprise, surprise, guess who is left off the list?

This restructuring of faith codes, which help identify service members as well as the military in planning for appropriated religious coverage to include them, has now excluded minority faith/worldview groups including Atheists, Asatru, Deists, Druids, Eckankar, Heathens, Humanists, Magick, New Age churches, Pagan, Rosicrucianism, Shaman, Spiritualists, Troth, Unitarian Universalists and various Wiccans.

I guess some of the founding fathers of this country, the ones who were Unitarians and deists, wouldn’t get any respect from our modern military. The ones who owned slaves would probably fit right in.

Hey, did I lose my audience with an ancient Gomer Pyle reference? I am old.

Comments

  1. Ed Seedhouse says

    “Hey, did I lose my audience with an ancient Gomer Pyle reference? I am old.”

    At least one person in your audience is old enough to think you are still young.

  2. Snarki, child of Loki says

    I never knew that Magick (the gathering) was considered a religion, but guess I should have.

  3. Knabb says

    The actual term “atheist” was removed, but “no religion” is still there, so this is minor from our perspective. Everyone who gets lumped into “Other Religion” and told that this is somehow to help them get “targeted religious support from the Chaplaincy” is in a much stronger position to complain. The ridiculous pile of variants for Christianity also really stands out relative to other religions; if baptist, Pentecostal, and evangelical are somehow distinct categories Sunni and Shia being lumped together has to sting.

  4. larpar says

    Knabb @ 3
    Spiritual but not religious would be considered No Religion too. It completely erases open atheists from the military. It’s not “minor”.

  5. Doc Bill says

    Whoa, this totally breaks my Noodle, blessed be he!

    Pastafarians are NOT on the Do Not Pray list!

    Praise be to his Exalted Holiness, the Flying Spaghetti Monster and the Noodley Host!

    Ramen!

  6. says

    The actual term “atheist” was removed, but “no religion” is still there, so this is minor from our perspective. Everyone who gets lumped into “Other Religion” and told that this is somehow to help them get “targeted religious support from the Chaplaincy” is in a much stronger position to complain.

    Now I’m just imagining a parallel world where Christians, Jews, and Muslims all get lumped under “Abrahamic faiths” while some other ascendant religion gets all its denominations respected.

  7. erik333 says

    Callng atheism a religion is like calling being healthy a disease…. so they at least got one thing right. Sadly, one can’t hope they don’t keep everyone but the “no religion” folks away from the guns.

  8. erik333 says

    Christians shouldn’t need a military anyway. Just find another true believer and pray at the enemy. Hypocrits

  9. Larry says

    It should be easy to figure which religions should still be on the list. If a religions adherents hate and despise the adherents of other religions to the point where they’d slaughter each other for centuries, they obviously could never stand worshipping together. Hence, separate services would be necessary.

  10. fernando says

    So, if i understood this correctly, it is allowed to worship the aztec pantheon, and bring to the frontlines a drum made of human skin, making “music” to inspire the soldiers?
    Somehow, this doesn’t surprise me…

  11. Pierce R. Butler says

    Given Sec. Hegseth’s overt devotion to “lethality”, the Department of War clearly needs to recognize Ares/Mars-ism, Thuggee, Mithraism, Molochism, or some other representation of Necrolatry.

  12. StevoR says

    @ ^ Pierce R. Butler : Sauronism.

    Or Trumpism. Or Fascism. But I repeat myself. Same diff. In essence.

  13. says

    So, now the murderous magat administration, embodied in crusader pigseth, is also targeting people who don’t believe in the ‘pedophile approving sky fairy’? Everywhere I look responsible reports keep emphasizing, with FACTS, that this entire nation is becoming a ‘xtian terrorist magat billionaire owned trailer trash empire’.

    Lumping us rational atheists (and maybe humanists and unitarian universalists, which are mostly benign and marginally superstitious) in with all the other crackpot superstitious religions is an ignorant insult.

  14. says

    Bobby Henderson had a great idea to combat the xtian terrorist regime in the kansas school system when he creating the Flying Spaghetti Monster church. I have to grant some respect to him and his pastafarians.

  15. Bruce says

    By definition, to be in a foxhole is to rely for salvation on physics to avoid attack, instead of relying on a deity. Thus, everyone in a foxhole is an atheist, and believers are apparently trying to leave the military by unaliving themselves. There are no sincere theists in foxholes, so all theists are unfit for military duty and should be dismissed. That’s just logic. So all military chaplains should be versions of atheists only.

  16. Bruce says

    By definition, to be in a foxhole is to rely for salvation on physics to avoid attack, instead of relying on a deity. Thus, everyone in a foxhole is an atheist, and believers are apparently trying to leave the military by unaliving themselves. There are no sincere theists in foxholes, so all theists are unfit for military duty and should be dismissed. That’s just logic. So all military chaplains should be versions of atheists only.

  17. birgerjohansson says

    Yog-Sototh is the opener of ways, so if you pray to him for a way to get out of encirclement would be a very military- relevant religion.
    .
    BTW we know Pigseth has blocked a disproportionate number of black and women servicemembers from promotion. Is he basing this on some old-testament bible verse.

  18. John Morales says

    Meh. I don’t see the problem.
    It’s supposed to be the military, not a church.
    And atheists don’t need any of it.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_symbolism_in_the_United_States_military

    Religious symbolism in the United States military includes the use of religious symbols for military chaplain insignia, uniforms, emblems, flags, and chapels; symbolic gestures, actions, and words used in military rituals and ceremonies; and religious symbols or designations used in areas such as headstones and markers in national cemeteries, and military ID tags (“dog tags”).

    Symbolism sometimes includes specific images included or excluded because of religious reasons, choices involving colors with religious significance, and “religious accommodation” policies regarding the wear of “religious apparel” and “grooming” (such as “unshorn” hair and beards worn for religious reasons) with military uniforms. Additionally, military chaplains themselves are sometimes regarded as “symbols of faith” for military personnel who face challenges to their faith and values.[1]

    Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth announced on March 24, 2026 that chaplains in all military branches would cease wearing insignia of grade and only wear their religious insignia.[2]

  19. Akira MacKenzie says

    Gomer Pyle-USMC a little before my time. However, as a kid, the local UHF TV stations played plenty of synchronized re-runs along with The Andy Griffith Show. Never watched it because it wasn’t my thing, but I got the reference.

    The entire list of excluded groups reads like a who’s-who of Bible-fucker boggeyfoks: atheists, pagans, Wiccans, and anyone else that doesn’t embrace trinitarian Christianity. I’m surprised Muslims weren’t excluded as well. Agnostics probably get a free ride because they are open to the idea that the Christian magical cosmic tyrant might exist.

  20. robert79 says

    @19 Bruce, “So all military chaplains should be versions of atheists only.”

    No, you also need chaplains for the non-atheists not-in-foxholes. Those who think god will save them as they rush into machine gun fire… These chaplains have a tough job…

  21. says

    Comrade Pete has failed: Russian Orthodox is not on list. Just “Orthodox” is not clear enough, could be Greek Orthodox or Ethiopian Orthodox. Comrade Vlad is not pleased and will send detailed specifications at later date.

    Some of us who had responsibility for sending real, live people Over There in 1990 — with real potential “need” for final services — are having really serious flashbacks without the benefit of any psychotropics. (Mine said “no religion” because that’s what was offered.)

  22. seversky says

    No atheists in foxholes? I would have thought the opposite was true, For men who have experienced the horrors of trench warfare they would have concluded that no merciful God could possibly have permitted that to happen. And, no, free will does not solve the problem of evil.

  23. numerobis says

    seversky: that would argue for there being no believers in a benevolent god once they’re back from the foxhole.

    In the foxhole, I can easily believe that people get irrational. Especially today with drones hunting individual soldiers in the foxhole.

  24. birgerjohansson says

    (Crossposted)
    Scathing Atheist interview with Promise Backlund, author of Gospel of Lies; surviving and resisting Evangelical extremism

    [Judging by the surname, her family are descended from ‘Bäcklund’ Swedish emigrants. Bäck: stream, lund:grove. ]

     .https://youtube.com/watch?v=LEZODoSmQSg

  25. birgerjohansson says

    Numerobis @ 27
    In Glen Cook ‘s novers about Garrett, the veterans home from the century-long war have little respect for gods.

  26. John Morales says

    Birger, apparently in those novels ‘gods’ are totally real.

    It is therefore not an atheistic series, is it?

    Also, gods that need respect are by definition puny gods; bah.

    Also, no smiting? :| Most puny.

    Bet the scathing atheist would scathe that, were the scathing atheist actually scathing.
    But I can scathe it, see?

  27. JM says

    Newsweek: Utah Lawmakers Criticize Pentagon After LDS Religious Designation Removed

    Republican Senators Mike Lee and John Curtis of Utah are challenging a recent Department of Defense policy directive that omits The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) from its designated list of Christian faiths. Labeling the administrative decision “unacceptable,” both lawmakers are pressing the Pentagon for an immediate corrective update.

    The LDS was not included as a Christian faith, members would have to select Other. The rest will be ignored but the LDS has enough sway among Republicans that the DOJ may have to issue a quick fix.
    This is one of those things where if a competent administration made this mistake I would assume it was an intentional snub. With this administration the chance it’s just incompetence is too high.

  28. Owlmirror says

    there are only 31 religions that will be officially recognized by the US military

    I do wonder if there is some trolling going on. Hegseth is probably too stupid to do it deliberately, but maybe some underling was being a cleverboots when the list was cut to exactly that number.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baskin-Robbins

    The company is known for its “31 flavors” slogan, with the idea that a customer could have a different flavor every day of any month. The logo includes a stylized “31” formed from the letters “B” and “R”.

  29. Owlmirror says

    Because Mormons are not Christians,

    Neither are Muslims, Hindus, or Sikhs, yet Islam, Hinduism, and Sikhism are on there.

    Hegseth is notorious for having shouted “Kill all Muslims!” in the past, but he was apparently convinced not to leave them off of this list..

  30. JM says

    Freethoughtblogs Infinite Thread: Originally from Washington Post

    The Defense Department on Monday edited its new list of religious “codes” for service members so that no group is labeled “Christian” — drawing praise from Mormon lawmakers who were angered last week when their faith was categorized as outside of Christianity.

    After the outcry from several leaders who are members of the Mormon Church, the revised list simply states religious groups, without adding the tag “Christian” to any.

    I figured there was a good chance the LDS would get what they wanted. The Republican position in congress is too weak to go angering members over this.
    A reasonable conclusion, getting the DOD out of the business of categorizing the religions. I expect some political appointees couldn’t bring themselves to include the LDS under Christian but realized that fighting this would result in a lawsuit the DOD would lose.
    Anything that looks like a categorization of what is Christianity and what is not from a government organization is difficult under the US constitution. Only the most absurd of category claims can be rejected.

  31. John Morales says

    A reasonable conclusion, getting the DOD out of the business of categorizing the religions.

    But they didn’t, really. And nothing has changed.

    For the Mormons, they were not categorised as ‘Christian’ by your own adduced claim, so they have not actually conceded the categorisation. They merely elided their categorisation’s overt labeling.

    And quite clearly, the mere act of determining what is a religion and what is not is basically the same thing. Same list, merely no more label. Same categorisation.

Trackbacks

Leave a Reply