Every time I try to feel sympathy for a church, they push me away


I had no idea what Cities Church was like. This is the church in St Paul were protesters disrupted a service, horrified at the fact that one of the pastors was also an ICE field agent. Several people have been arrested, and Bondi’s Department of Justice promises a full investigation of the affair.

I think it is rightful to protest a church that takes advantage of the separation of church and state to get tax exemptions, but then hosts a clergy that preaches against secular government. Don’t burn them down, but at the very least the people should have the right to alert the community that one of the pastors is a hypocrite, on the one hand preaching the gospel of Jesus Christ and on the other hand arresting and deporting and bullying the poor and needy. Let everyone know what a lying fraud he is.

But now I learn about Cities Church’s long-running reputation. One protest is not enough.

“[T]hey are insecure little sexist and racist power-mongers who desire to be God,” wrote Rick Pidcock, a former fundamentalist and worship music expert, in a lengthy exposé for Baptist News Global. According to Pidcock, Cities Church is rooted in a network of far-right churches that teach “male headship and female submission” so extreme that their thought leader, John Piper, has argued that women shouldn’t even occupy management positions where men might have to answer to them.

Parnell himself has written extensively about how men “are given a charge to lead.” Under his leadership, female parishioners teach courses on learning to submit to your husband even when it’s “overwhelming, frustrating, or maybe even impossible,” as it seemed to be for a former church member who told Pidcock that the pastors pressured her to stay in a marriage with an emotionally abusive man who bankrupted his family by spending money on online sex workers.

Among Cities Church’s pastors is Joe Rigney, who has recently become a MAGA media darling because he, along with podcaster Allie Beth Stuckey, has been pushing the idea that empathy is a sin. Rigney has partnered with Doug Wilson, a pastor who has praised race relations under slavery and denounced women’s suffrage, to argue that people are “being manipulated by empathy.” Rigney’s misogyny is never far from the surface, including when he denounced empathy as evidence that “feminism is a cancer” because it allows women to move beyond just being “life-givers and nurturers” and into public spaces, where their allegedly toxic compassion is a “curse.”

“Cities Church is part of the Southern Baptist Convention, which was founded in 1845 over the right to own slaves,” Tim Whitaker, a former Christian nationalist who now works to expose the movement on his YouTube channel, told Salon. “This church should be disrupted. As far as I’m concerned, Jesus would’ve been right with those protesters.”

Whitaker’s view illuminates what the MAGA freakout over this protest is ignoring: that freedom of religion is not a shield against criticism of a church’s teachings, especially when those teachings are impacting the lives of other people. Cities Church, he said, “is home to a pastor that works for a federal agency kidnapping brown-skinned immigrants and killing unarmed citizens.” The anti-empathy and bigoted views taught inside the church are directly affecting people outside of it.

This is the Church of Doug Wilson, not the Church of Jesus, and it’s nothing but a sheltered little pocket of poison infesting the body politic. We have a system in which you are not even allowed to criticize the most evil, odious views if they are said by a man wearing a clerical collar, and it has to stop.

I don’t agree that empathy is a sin, but that’s OK because I feel no empathy for a nest of vipers in my state.

Comments

  1. Akira MacKenzie says

    Can we NOT play “What Would Jesus Do” especially when 1) we don’t actually know what the real Jesus would have actually thought (All we have are the Gospels which were written by his cult.), and 2) century upon century of “mainstream” Christian theologians and leaders cheering on and participating in this sort of tyranny.

  2. drewl, Mental Toss Flycoon says

    Ok, my eyeballs were exploding at “worship music expert” but then Doug Wilson had to show up. I’ve been watching that motherfucker destroy my hometown of Moscow, Idaho for decades. Now they’re hurt because of some blowback?

    Get used to it, assholes.

    Emo Phillips’ “Die, Heretic!” joke is evergreen.

  3. says

    Religion has always been an evil, murderous, superstitious, dystopian fantasy that the drooling imbecilic masses cling to as an insane, irrational hope that a sky fairy will save them from the disaster that is human society.

  4. Ridana says

    Do they cite any biblical edicts declaring empathy a sin, or is that just their opinion? oO If the latter, aren’t they usurping their god in declaring what is and isn’t a sin? Sounds kinda sinful to me.

  5. timmyson says

    This is the Church of Doug Wilson, not the Church of Jesus

    You’re going soft, PZ! The whole church-structure of subservience to the father-god tends towards this fascist veneration of power. I think resisting that tenancy requires continual work, and sooner or later, any given organization will lapse.

    I don’t know who coined it, but I got this phrase from Wil Wheaton: “I like fandom-Jesus a whole lot less than canon-Jesus.” There’s always gonna be someone who wants to take the caché of the latter to get support for their version of the former.

  6. John Morales says

    Akira:

    [T]hey are insecure little sexist and racist power-mongers who desire to be God,” wrote Rick Pidcock, a former fundamentalist and worship music expert, in a lengthy exposé for Baptist News Global.
    […]
    As far as I’m concerned, Jesus would’ve been right with those protesters.

    Can we NOT play “What Would Jesus Do”

    Two things; note the writer is a religious type (not part of ‘we’ atheists), and the Church supposedly is Christian and worthips the Babblical Jesus. So, quite apposite.

  7. says

    this feels like dangerous cult shit. like a recipe for jonestown. fucked up as hell this can happen anywhere in the US anytime and get a pass because it’s in jeebus name.

Leave a Reply