Nice. He should work on his miking technique, the sound was not very clear.
Brandon P.says
I believe that they should teach the idea of Poseidon as the cause of earthquakes along with the plate tectonics theory in geology class. It’s teaching the controversy.
While they’re at it, more students in astronomy class need to be exposed to the possibility that the sun’s “movement” in the sky is caused by ripping out the heart during human sacrifice. That would also be teaching the controversy.
Very well done. I’m just glad that we don’t have angry Posidonists who are likely to become hostile.
At least, none that I’m aware of.
6EQUJ5says
Teach the controversy — volcanology and Vulcan taught together!
MartinCsays
I loved the reaction of the Greek Orthodox Christian establishment to a group of Zeus followers who earlier this year tried to gain access to an historical site to hold a religious ceremony.
“The president of the Association of Greek Clergymen, Father Efstathios Kollas, has described the followers of the Olympic gods as a handful of miserable resuscitators of a degenerate dead religion who wish to return to the monstrous dark delusions of the past.”
So near and yet so far.
El Cidsays
What, is he going to also suggest that Poseidon’s trident wasn’t real either?
If Poseidon isn’t real, how come Aquaman still carries a trident?
dcbobsays
Grrrr. You belittle Poseidon … for this you must pay!
Ha ha! I’m in Minnesota, in prairie country — I can mock Poseidon with impunity. As long as I stay off the Great Lakes, that is, and I’m not planning to ship out on the Edmund Fitzgerald II any time soon.
Now come on, who don’t LOVE Aphrodite :-) Or Dionysos :-D
At least they had funny gods back then.
CalGeorgesays
Smote him, Poseidon!
Oh, and could you do something about climate change.
It’s getting hot down here.
ravensays
Everyone knows by now that the Olympians of Zeus and his gang was just a myth. The real gods are Odin, Thor, Frieja, and the rest. And any day Ragnorak (or Gotterdamurung) is scheduled with a starring role for a very large snake.
What is up with these YouTube videos that edit out all of the natural gaps between sentences? Can this guy not speak for a whole minute in a row without goofing up, and thus has to do it in sentence chunks at a time?
My point is not really to criticize him, but I see this all the time on YouTube videos, and it does annoy me. Traditional media simply doesn’t do this, and for good reason. It’s distracting, and rather unlike a traditional face-to-face conversation that we’re all programmed to understand.
This kind of thing: youth communicating with youth, and laughing at the stupid religious people – will do vastly more to help people confront religious delusion than any amount of argumentum-ad-knock-down-drag-out.
I’m in Houston, i’ll keep worshipping Poseidon until the hurricane season is over. Then i’ll go back to being an atheist.
Hanksays
It’s hard to tread the line between sarcasm and smugness. He gladly managed to do it, barely.
Lenisays
I don’t know… I’m pretty sure it was Louise Brooks in that sandwich.
robsays
Can this guy not speak for a whole minute in a row without goofing up, and thus has to do it in sentence chunks at a time?
Try it sometime. Some people do better than others, but when I’ve tried recording myself, I screw up a lot. Probably because I’m not a professional.
Maybe that is the reason traditional media doesn’t use his technique? Because they hire professional talking heads…who, while generally non-creative, have skill at talking without screwing up.
I actually found his editing kind of amusing….rather than it being a liability, he got a bit creative with it and used it to his advantage.
Ha ha! I’m in Minnesota, in prairie country — I can mock Poseidon with impunity. As long as I stay off the Great Lakes, that is, and I’m not planning to ship out on the Edmund Fitzgerald II any time soon.
Uh, do also realize that Poseidon is also the patron god of horses, and earthquakes…
They do have horses in Minnesota, right?
I’ve just spent a year or so diving in Crete and I know Poseidon exists ’cause I’ve seen him…..and the seventeen mermaids and a pink talking octopus.
Nitrogen narcosis? Moi??
raindogzillasays
I thought that all Minnesotans worshiped the Lumberjack God, Paul Bunyan, Creator of All 10,000 Lakes? Man, if religion still had Giants, I’d be all over it. And, fear not, PZ, extremist Grecians can be spotted a mile away by their unnaturally non-grey hair.
windysays
It’s hard to tread the line between sarcasm and smugness. He gladly managed to do it, barely.
Hey, smugness has its place… I like the body language in this video in response to a theist droning on.
Of course he doesn’t believe in Poseidon. This man clearly worships Ze Frank.
Torbjörn Larsson, OMsays
The best strategists, debaters and comedians make it simple – I think that guy did a trifecta.
Btw, raven, aren’t you afraid you insult your gods by your spelling? That is “Freyja” (old nordic, eng “Freya”), “Ragna rök” (old nordic, sw. “Ragnarök”) and “Götterdämmerung”.
Maybe your joining in Valhöll (sw. “Valhall”, eng. “Valhalla”) with the other einheriars around the feast tables will prove to be more challenging than you think. Or don’t you believe in Pascal’s wager?
Torbjörn Larsson, OMsays
The best strategists, debaters and comedians make it simple – I think that guy did a trifecta.
Btw, raven, aren’t you afraid you insult your gods by your spelling? That is “Freyja” (old nordic, eng “Freya”), “Ragna rök” (old nordic, sw. “Ragnarök”) and “Götterdämmerung”.
Maybe your joining in Valhöll (sw. “Valhall”, eng. “Valhalla”) with the other einheriars around the feast tables will prove to be more challenging than you think. Or don’t you believe in Pascal’s wager?
Beverly Nuckolssays
Which of the religions would encourage followers to pray for and bless this boy?
Irissays
I love the giant picture of Strong Bad in the background. Now there’s a religion I can get behind!
JohnnieCanuck, FCDsays
Lots of people pray to Freyja, even in today’s modern world.
As in TGIF – Thank Goodness It’s Freyja’s Day.
Strange how those Christian missionaries never got around to dumping the old Gods from their places in the days of the week and months of the year. They sure went after their Holy Days.
David Marjanovićsays
Götterdämmerung
That’s just modern German for “twilight of the gods”.
Strange how those Christian missionaries never got around to dumping the old Gods from their places in the days of the week and months of the year.
In some places they tried. Wednesday in German is just “middle of the week”, for example. The Slavic names for the weekdays are just derived from numbers and the like, except for Sunday which is “resurrection”.
David Marjanovićsays
Götterdämmerung
That’s just modern German for “twilight of the gods”.
Strange how those Christian missionaries never got around to dumping the old Gods from their places in the days of the week and months of the year.
In some places they tried. Wednesday in German is just “middle of the week”, for example. The Slavic names for the weekdays are just derived from numbers and the like, except for Sunday which is “resurrection”.
MTransays
Well sure, Poseidon doesn’t really exist, but Rhadamanthus surely does, and he’ll be judging those Christians when they die.
Apparently, Helios continues to exist as well, as you can hear at this youtube link, where atheists attempt to reason about Helios with adamant theists:
Btw, raven, aren’t you afraid you insult your gods by your spelling?
Sorry, couldn’t find my Nordic dictionary. In fact, don’t think there ever was one around. And my keyboard doesn’t have a key for the “o” with two dots above it.
The old Nordic gods seemed to be far more interested in how good one was with a sword and shield than spelling. LOL. Maybe they could use a good medic or two at Ragnarok. LOL
ScienceBreathsays
Cyde Weys sputtered:
Can this guy not speak for a whole minute in a row without goofing up, and thus has to do it in sentence chunks at a time?
I think it’s pretty obvious it’s a stylistic choice. Did you notice how his body is in a different position for each segment? He’s doing it for effect.
My point is not really to criticize him, …
But you will, anyway. And from your own blog you state “I try to be as cynical as humanly possible in all situations.” That says it all really.
Post a video that displays half the talent of this guy and I’ll start paying attention to what you have to say.
Traditional media simply doesn’t do this, and for good reason. It’s distracting, and rather unlike a traditional face-to-face conversation that we’re all programmed to understand.
Yeah, traditional media have got it all figured out. Would you say your blog attracts more comment than his videos?
robsays
I think it’s pretty obvious it’s a stylistic choice.
…
And from your own blog you state “I try to be as cynical as humanly possible in all situations.” That says it all really.
A little pot calling the kettle black maybe? I mean, its pretty obvious the “try to be cynical in all situations” comment was facetious. And if you are complaining about him being critical of someone else, you are doing the same, only with a lot more venom.
yoyosays
I think it’s great to have a cute young aetheist to counter all the smarmy blonde christians (especially christian rock urgh)on our media. so the editing is a little clumsy, it’s funny and approachable which is what we need to make our case(s).
ScienceBreathsays
Rob said
A little pot calling the kettle black maybe?
So we shouldn’t criticise people for being unecesssarily critical because that would be, well, critical?
It’s easy to be negative. The critical position is the default for many people and is the easiest to maintain. I see it most in my scientifically literate friends–perhaps because their jobs require them to be constantly critical of new ideas. But it’s become tiresome to the point of boorishness that every achievement of another must be dissected until something negative can be said. Cyde Weys should try doing what Albert Sweigart has done and then he may have some street cred.
Janinesays
Ha ha! I’m in Minnesota, in prairie country — I can mock Poseidon with impunity.
Was that once a seabed millions of years ago? Just give it some time and perhaps Poseidon can poke your ass with his trident. But I wonder, are the followers of Poseidon creationists? And what timescle are they working with?
Torbjörn Larsson, OMsays
In some places they tried. Wednesday …
In swedish we have “lördag” for saturday, a contraction of “lögardag” which is an old name for bath day. (Presumably from old germanic “laugr” – water, water fall.)
Swedish “söndag” for sunday is OTOH from the old sun godess “Sol/Sunna/Sunne”.
perhaps Poseidon can poke your ass with his trident.
I don’t believe in gods that can be hoisted on their own petards. :-P
raven:
And my keyboard doesn’t have a key for the “o” with two dots above it.
…, cough, cough, … google, … cough, cough… :-P
Anyway, perhaps you don’t have the right incantations over ther? I just say the magic words *&*ouml*;* [remove the *s] and out comes ö. (Testing: ö.)
And then I can throw them at my enemies as einheirars could: ö, ö, öö, ööö… No, I @$#! can’t. “Öö, ööö, ööh” are tentative markers and thought pauses in swedish. :-P
Torbjörn Larsson, OMsays
In some places they tried. Wednesday …
In swedish we have “lördag” for saturday, a contraction of “lögardag” which is an old name for bath day. (Presumably from old germanic “laugr” – water, water fall.)
Swedish “söndag” for sunday is OTOH from the old sun godess “Sol/Sunna/Sunne”.
perhaps Poseidon can poke your ass with his trident.
I don’t believe in gods that can be hoisted on their own petards. :-P
raven:
And my keyboard doesn’t have a key for the “o” with two dots above it.
…, cough, cough, … google, … cough, cough… :-P
Anyway, perhaps you don’t have the right incantations over ther? I just say the magic words *&*ouml*;* [remove the *s] and out comes ö. (Testing: ö.)
And then I can throw them at my enemies as einheirars could: ö, ö, öö, ööö… No, I @$#! can’t. “Öö, ööö, ööh” are tentative markers and thought pauses in swedish. :-P
MartinCsays
It just shows that theres an exceedingly fine line between ‘having a good point’ and ‘coming across as an annoying smug geek’.
Ryansays
I just love that he is a Homestar fan. He may not justify anyone’s beliefs, but he justifies my sense of humor.
That was brilliant.
HA! Genius (well, maybe not the editing). Gotta love that kid.
And logic. Gotta love logic.
And sarcasm. Don’t forget sarcasm.
sarcasm + logic = family fun for everyone!
Evidence of Poseidon? Here’s a Cyclops.
Nice. He should work on his miking technique, the sound was not very clear.
I believe that they should teach the idea of Poseidon as the cause of earthquakes along with the plate tectonics theory in geology class. It’s teaching the controversy.
While they’re at it, more students in astronomy class need to be exposed to the possibility that the sun’s “movement” in the sky is caused by ripping out the heart during human sacrifice. That would also be teaching the controversy.
Very well done. I’m just glad that we don’t have angry Posidonists who are likely to become hostile.
At least, none that I’m aware of.
Teach the controversy — volcanology and Vulcan taught together!
I loved the reaction of the Greek Orthodox Christian establishment to a group of Zeus followers who earlier this year tried to gain access to an historical site to hold a religious ceremony.
“The president of the Association of Greek Clergymen, Father Efstathios Kollas, has described the followers of the Olympic gods as a handful of miserable resuscitators of a degenerate dead religion who wish to return to the monstrous dark delusions of the past.”
So near and yet so far.
What, is he going to also suggest that Poseidon’s trident wasn’t real either?
If Poseidon isn’t real, how come Aquaman still carries a trident?
Grrrr. You belittle Poseidon … for this you must pay!
Ha ha! I’m in Minnesota, in prairie country — I can mock Poseidon with impunity. As long as I stay off the Great Lakes, that is, and I’m not planning to ship out on the Edmund Fitzgerald II any time soon.
Now come on, who don’t LOVE Aphrodite :-) Or Dionysos :-D
At least they had funny gods back then.
Smote him, Poseidon!
Oh, and could you do something about climate change.
It’s getting hot down here.
Everyone knows by now that the Olympians of Zeus and his gang was just a myth. The real gods are Odin, Thor, Frieja, and the rest. And any day Ragnorak (or Gotterdamurung) is scheduled with a starring role for a very large snake.
Whoa! No Atlantis? And, hello … Mr. Ed? They’ve got him on film!
I’m reminded once again of Terry Pratchett:
“Err… how far away’s the snow line?” “Couple thousand miles.” “Ah. God of avalanches? Relic of an outmoded belief system! Mere fairy tale!”
(Quoted from memory, probably screwed it up.)
ODIN! ;)
http://www.thepaincomics.com/weekly041229a.htm
I don’t care what this guy says, I still think Calypso it HOT!
What is up with these YouTube videos that edit out all of the natural gaps between sentences? Can this guy not speak for a whole minute in a row without goofing up, and thus has to do it in sentence chunks at a time?
My point is not really to criticize him, but I see this all the time on YouTube videos, and it does annoy me. Traditional media simply doesn’t do this, and for good reason. It’s distracting, and rather unlike a traditional face-to-face conversation that we’re all programmed to understand.
This kind of thing: youth communicating with youth, and laughing at the stupid religious people – will do vastly more to help people confront religious delusion than any amount of argumentum-ad-knock-down-drag-out.
I’m in Houston, i’ll keep worshipping Poseidon until the hurricane season is over. Then i’ll go back to being an atheist.
It’s hard to tread the line between sarcasm and smugness. He gladly managed to do it, barely.
I don’t know… I’m pretty sure it was Louise Brooks in that sandwich.
Try it sometime. Some people do better than others, but when I’ve tried recording myself, I screw up a lot. Probably because I’m not a professional.
Maybe that is the reason traditional media doesn’t use his technique? Because they hire professional talking heads…who, while generally non-creative, have skill at talking without screwing up.
I actually found his editing kind of amusing….rather than it being a liability, he got a bit creative with it and used it to his advantage.
Uh, do also realize that Poseidon is also the patron god of horses, and earthquakes…
They do have horses in Minnesota, right?
I’ve just spent a year or so diving in Crete and I know Poseidon exists ’cause I’ve seen him…..and the seventeen mermaids and a pink talking octopus.
Nitrogen narcosis? Moi??
I thought that all Minnesotans worshiped the Lumberjack God, Paul Bunyan, Creator of All 10,000 Lakes? Man, if religion still had Giants, I’d be all over it. And, fear not, PZ, extremist Grecians can be spotted a mile away by their unnaturally non-grey hair.
It’s hard to tread the line between sarcasm and smugness. He gladly managed to do it, barely.
Hey, smugness has its place… I like the body language in this video in response to a theist droning on.
Of course he doesn’t believe in Poseidon. This man clearly worships Ze Frank.
The best strategists, debaters and comedians make it simple – I think that guy did a trifecta.
Btw, raven, aren’t you afraid you insult your gods by your spelling? That is “Freyja” (old nordic, eng “Freya”), “Ragna rök” (old nordic, sw. “Ragnarök”) and “Götterdämmerung”.
Maybe your joining in Valhöll (sw. “Valhall”, eng. “Valhalla”) with the other einheriars around the feast tables will prove to be more challenging than you think. Or don’t you believe in Pascal’s wager?
The best strategists, debaters and comedians make it simple – I think that guy did a trifecta.
Btw, raven, aren’t you afraid you insult your gods by your spelling? That is “Freyja” (old nordic, eng “Freya”), “Ragna rök” (old nordic, sw. “Ragnarök”) and “Götterdämmerung”.
Maybe your joining in Valhöll (sw. “Valhall”, eng. “Valhalla”) with the other einheriars around the feast tables will prove to be more challenging than you think. Or don’t you believe in Pascal’s wager?
Which of the religions would encourage followers to pray for and bless this boy?
I love the giant picture of Strong Bad in the background. Now there’s a religion I can get behind!
Lots of people pray to Freyja, even in today’s modern world.
As in TGIF – Thank Goodness It’s Freyja’s Day.
Strange how those Christian missionaries never got around to dumping the old Gods from their places in the days of the week and months of the year. They sure went after their Holy Days.
That’s just modern German for “twilight of the gods”.
In some places they tried. Wednesday in German is just “middle of the week”, for example. The Slavic names for the weekdays are just derived from numbers and the like, except for Sunday which is “resurrection”.
That’s just modern German for “twilight of the gods”.
In some places they tried. Wednesday in German is just “middle of the week”, for example. The Slavic names for the weekdays are just derived from numbers and the like, except for Sunday which is “resurrection”.
Well sure, Poseidon doesn’t really exist, but Rhadamanthus surely does, and he’ll be judging those Christians when they die.
Apparently, Helios continues to exist as well, as you can hear at this youtube link, where atheists attempt to reason about Helios with adamant theists:
Atheist Explains Why We Don’t Die When the Sun Goes Down
Sorry, couldn’t find my Nordic dictionary. In fact, don’t think there ever was one around. And my keyboard doesn’t have a key for the “o” with two dots above it.
The old Nordic gods seemed to be far more interested in how good one was with a sword and shield than spelling. LOL. Maybe they could use a good medic or two at Ragnarok. LOL
Cyde Weys sputtered:
I think it’s pretty obvious it’s a stylistic choice. Did you notice how his body is in a different position for each segment? He’s doing it for effect.
But you will, anyway. And from your own blog you state “I try to be as cynical as humanly possible in all situations.” That says it all really.
Post a video that displays half the talent of this guy and I’ll start paying attention to what you have to say.
Yeah, traditional media have got it all figured out. Would you say your blog attracts more comment than his videos?
A little pot calling the kettle black maybe? I mean, its pretty obvious the “try to be cynical in all situations” comment was facetious. And if you are complaining about him being critical of someone else, you are doing the same, only with a lot more venom.
I think it’s great to have a cute young aetheist to counter all the smarmy blonde christians (especially christian rock urgh)on our media. so the editing is a little clumsy, it’s funny and approachable which is what we need to make our case(s).
Rob said
So we shouldn’t criticise people for being unecesssarily critical because that would be, well, critical?
It’s easy to be negative. The critical position is the default for many people and is the easiest to maintain. I see it most in my scientifically literate friends–perhaps because their jobs require them to be constantly critical of new ideas. But it’s become tiresome to the point of boorishness that every achievement of another must be dissected until something negative can be said. Cyde Weys should try doing what Albert Sweigart has done and then he may have some street cred.
Was that once a seabed millions of years ago? Just give it some time and perhaps Poseidon can poke your ass with his trident. But I wonder, are the followers of Poseidon creationists? And what timescle are they working with?
In swedish we have “lördag” for saturday, a contraction of “lögardag” which is an old name for bath day. (Presumably from old germanic “laugr” – water, water fall.)
Swedish “söndag” for sunday is OTOH from the old sun godess “Sol/Sunna/Sunne”.
I don’t believe in gods that can be hoisted on their own petards. :-P
raven:
…, cough, cough, … google, … cough, cough… :-P
Anyway, perhaps you don’t have the right incantations over ther? I just say the magic words *&*ouml*;* [remove the *s] and out comes ö. (Testing: ö.)
And then I can throw them at my enemies as einheirars could: ö, ö, öö, ööö… No, I @$#! can’t. “Öö, ööö, ööh” are tentative markers and thought pauses in swedish. :-P
In swedish we have “lördag” for saturday, a contraction of “lögardag” which is an old name for bath day. (Presumably from old germanic “laugr” – water, water fall.)
Swedish “söndag” for sunday is OTOH from the old sun godess “Sol/Sunna/Sunne”.
I don’t believe in gods that can be hoisted on their own petards. :-P
raven:
…, cough, cough, … google, … cough, cough… :-P
Anyway, perhaps you don’t have the right incantations over ther? I just say the magic words *&*ouml*;* [remove the *s] and out comes ö. (Testing: ö.)
And then I can throw them at my enemies as einheirars could: ö, ö, öö, ööö… No, I @$#! can’t. “Öö, ööö, ööh” are tentative markers and thought pauses in swedish. :-P
It just shows that theres an exceedingly fine line between ‘having a good point’ and ‘coming across as an annoying smug geek’.
I just love that he is a Homestar fan. He may not justify anyone’s beliefs, but he justifies my sense of humor.
One word: Groundwater,
You’re standing on it;
without it the prairies
would become deserts.
Funny, with that in mind,
how “groundwater-table” puts
a twist on the 23rd psalm
“leads me to still waters”
& “table of my enemies”
hail poseiden, neptune rains
snow bizness like show bizness
it’s all metaphor donchano!
How fast do gods evolve,
do they truly go extinct or
do they remain recessive
among the dominant deities,
is their lineage a tree or
a (burning) bush?
Ah rhetoric, thank A
I’m not a philosopher.