You wanna see reductive? She’s gonna give you reductive.
"We're not the same because if aliens invaded and dissected us, we'd be in different piles".
👀
Transphobe… having a normal one. pic.twitter.com/WrMT85eJl5
— Izzy Rizinti 🏳️🌈 (@BellaRizinti) July 25, 2020
My first thought was, “Why are these aliens murdering us all, and why does she care what pile of corpses we end up in? And why are these aliens sorting us this way?” I mean, once we’re reduced to dead meat and tossed into rotting piles for some inscrutable purpose (Mulching into fertilizer? Animal fodder? Party decorations?) why are chromosomes even relevant?
There are also a few people wandering around with fragmented Y chromosomes and translocations that make this distinction difficult. I picture the aliens wandering around the heap of corpses sampling bits of tissue and being totally baffled by the occasional individual and flicking them off to — oh no — a third pile. Maybe that small third pile will be marketed as rare exotic meat.
Of course, if the aliens sorted by some other criterion, like penises, or size, or the presence of the A blood antigen, you could also throw them into two piles by setting your boundary values to whatever you want, and then find there are a few individuals who fall into boundary conditions. This is a pointless thought exercise.
Wouldn’t you know that this TERF also has strange ideas about evolution.
It gets worse.
"Women evolved smaller so that men could rape them easily". pic.twitter.com/nXZ4ulxhBU
— Izzy Rizinti 🏳️🌈 (@BellaRizinti) July 25, 2020
Using this same logic, we could say that humans evolved to be squishy, unarmored, and lacking in natural armament so leopards could eat them more easily. Everything has an evolutionary purpose, after all. As we all know, we men have testicles in a convenient external pouch to simplify extracting gametes with a biopsy needle. The predictive powers of evolutionary prophesying are truly astounding!