Wait And See: No, it’s not ‘ET’ until you prove it

A “candidate” for an alien signal has been detected coming out of Proxima Centauri.  Call me skeptical (gee, on this site?), but this could easily be our own signals bouncing back at us, a new type of pulsar or some other natural phenomenon.  From The Guardian, December 2020:

Scientists looking for aliens investigate radio beam ‘from nearby star’

Astronomers behind the most extensive search yet for alien life are investigating an intriguing radio wave emission that appears to have come from the direction of Proxima Centauri, the nearest star to the sun.

The narrow beam of radio waves was picked up during 30 hours of observations by the Parkes telescope in Australia in April and May last year, the Guardian understands. Analysis of the beam has been under way for some time and scientists have yet to identify a terrestrial culprit such as ground-based equipment or a passing satellite.

It is usual for astronomers on the $100m (£70m) Breakthrough Listen project to spot strange blasts of radio waves with the Parkes telescope or the Green Bank Observatory in West Virginia, but all so far have been attributed to human-made interference or natural sources.

The latest “signal” is likely to have a mundane explanation too, but the direction of the narrow beam, around 980MHz, and an apparent shift in its frequency said to be consistent with the movement of a planet have added to the tantalising nature of the finding. Scientists are now preparing a paper on the beam, named BLC1, for Breakthrough Listen, the project to search for evidence of life in space, the Guardian understands.

The beam that appears to have come from the direction of Proxima Centauri, a red dwarf star 4.2 light years from Earth, has not been spotted since the initial observation, according to an individual in the astronomy community who requested anonymity because the work is ongoing. “It is the first serious candidate since the ‘Wow! signal’,” they said.

From Smithsonian Magazine.

Would I like this to be aliens?  Sure, and at 4.2 light years away, back and forth communication would be possible, if slow.  But I won’t believe it until it’s proven.

The worst part about this, if it’s true?  Windbags like Michio Kaku will seek credit and probably get it instead of the astronomers who did the work.  Known exoplanets went from one in 1983 to four thousand in 2020 because of new technology and techniques to detect them, not wishing they existed.

I’ll Pile On: Happy New Year

I’m not a curmudgeon, I’ m just feeling bleah because of all this week’s bad news.


A thought about the new year:

2020 was rough, and 2021 is going to be even rougher. Don’t kid yourself, there’s still a long way to go before things are “normal” again (and “normal” was a problem to begin with). But getting this far means you’re strong enough to make it the rest of the way. Hold your head up.


Speaking of Argent, Argentina has legalized abortion after its senate voted 38 to 29 in favour, with one abstension.  Abortions will now be available until the fourteenth week.  The news items I’ve seen don’t say if it’s fully on demand abortion with no restrictions, but they do say the reasons for attaining abortion were expanded.  Previously, only rape and the mother’s health were acceptable.  From the BBC (emphasis in the text is mine):

Argentina abortion: Senate approves legalisation in historic decision

Argentina’s Congress has legalised abortions up to the 14th week of pregnancy, a ground-breaking move for a region that has some of the world’s most restrictive termination laws.

Senators voted in favour of the bill after a marathon session with 38 in favour, 29 against and one abstention.

Until now, abortions were only permitted in cases of rape or when the mother’s health was at risk.

The bill had been approved by the Chamber of Deputies earlier this month.

[. . .]

While Argentina’s powerful Catholic Church, and its growing evangelical community, put up strong opposition against this bill, it was Argentina’s mighty “green wave” women’s movement that has been at the forefront of this change.

A grassroots feminist movement that has grown in influence in the past few years, its campaigning prevailed, overturning a law that had been in place since 1921.

What has happened in Argentina has been closely watched across the region.

With Argentina now legalising abortion up to 14 weeks, activists in major neighbours like Chile and Brazil will no doubt use this precedent to help their cause in rewriting the law in their countries and allow broader reproductive rights in a region known for tough restrictions on abortion.


Back to the song, it was released in January 1972, which makes it 49 years old, not 50.

Keep going, so you’re around for the fiftieth anniversary.  Lyrics are below the video.

“Hold Your Head Up”, by Argent:

And if it’s there
Don’t let it get you down,
You can take it.
And if it hurts
Don’t let them see you cry,
You can make it.

Hold your head up, oh
Hold your head up, oh
Hold your head up, oh
Hold your head high.

And if they stare
Just let them burn their eyes
On you moving.
And if they shout
Don’t let it change a thing
That you’re doing.

Hold your head up, oh
Hold your head up, oh
Hold your head up, oh
Hold your head high.

Hold your head up
Hold your head up
Hold your head up
Hold your head up

Hold your head up, oh
Hold your head up, oh
Hold your head up, oh
Hold your head high.