Katy Perry’s God


It’s practically unavoidable that the gods people invent will take the form of something that reflects their own desires, preferences, priorities, tastes and distastes. And at the same time, the insertion of a god into their worldview inevitably distorts their thinking, because it elevates their own personal perspectives, incomplete and inconsistent and bizarre as they may be, to the final word and binding command of a perfect and almighty deity – a facet of reality imposed from outside, not a subjective judgment generated from within.

This typically manifests as people picking out verses that disapprove of homosexuality from an entire book of incomprehensible, alien laws that they would otherwise disregard, or preferring to doom a woman and her fetus to die rather than allow an abortion that would save her life, or other instances of completely missing the point and failing to apply even the most basic standards of reason. But sometimes, someone manages to take this in a totally new direction. Sometimes, we get Katy Perry.

Perry, a former gospel singer raised by two Christian pastors who only allowed her to listen to gospel music, burst onto the scene in 2008 with a hit single about casually making out with girls at bars:

No, I don’t even know your name
It doesn’t matter
You’re my experimental game
Just human nature

[…]

I kissed a girl just to try it
I hope my boyfriend don’t mind it

Her later works include asking men to show her their cocks, general drunken rowdiness, and the “California Gurls” video. Nothing is wrong with any of this. But it is interesting to see what’s persisted through all this: an aversion to blasphemy.

Following Gaga’s new music video premiere, which was filled with religious imagery, Perry posted a message on Twitter declaring that “using blasphemy as entertainment is as cheap as a comedian telling a fart joke.” Perry clarified her statement on a French radio station Monday, insisting she was not singling out the 24-year-old singer.

New York Daily News, 15 Jun 2010

“I am sensitive to Russell taking the Lord’s name in vain and to Lady Gaga putting a rosary in her mouth. I think when you put sex and spirituality in the same bottle and shake it up, bad things happen. Yes, I said I kissed a girl. But I didn’t say I kissed a girl while f-ing a crucifix.”

Rolling Stone, 19 Aug 2010

“Russell has made very blasphemous jokes in the past, but he’s making fewer all the time because he knows that I am very sensitive about this subject,” says Perry, whose parents were pastors.

“You can be frivolous and fun without needing to get involved in that. And I don’t know why that only happens to the Christian religion. I don’t see people simulating sex with statues of Buddha, for example.”

[…]

“For me, spirituality is something very important and I don’t like it when people take it lightly. At times, I don’t understand why there are artists who play that card, like when Madonna gets up on a cross to sing.”

The Telegraph, 16 Jan 2011

Yes, apparently blasphemy is “cheap”, but blasting whipped cream from your breasts is not. Spirituality is serious business, but insincere displays of same-sex affection for the attention and titillation of heterosexual men are no big deal. What kind of god would agree with this? The kind of god that’s no brighter than Katy Perry. This is not to say that she’s necessarily a hypocrite, or somehow doing religion “wrong” – this would require that someone be “right” about it. It is, however, stupid, and a probable remnant of her upbringing after any possible distaste for partying, drinking, homosexuality and sexuality in general has fallen away1.

But even if many instances of blasphemy are merely an attempt to stir up controversy, just as cheap as singing about men’s cocks, there’s no particular reason why religion ought to be a subject that’s off-limits here. It makes no sense to home in on the things that particularly offend people and intentionally push those buttons, then cry foul when someone does the exact same thing with a topic you happen to be sensitive about. An objection to Lady Gaga putting a rosary in her mouth should be no more compelling than an objection to Perry putting her tongue in another girl’s mouth.

What many people who decry blasphemy don’t understand is that this sensitivity to it is precisely why it’s used. If religious iconography had no such meanings, cultural associations and delicate feelings surrounding it, there would be no point to anyone using it in this way. The unusually high regard in which religion is held is exactly what gives it its power to convey a message here, however trite that message may be. This is hardly taking it lightly at all – this is the very reason artists choose to utilize religion in an unconventional, possibly offensive context.

Christianity is simply the most commonly referenced religion because it’s the most common religion, but it’s undeniable that almost any religion can, in fact, be funny. For example:

  • Buddhism’s idea of a good life is training yourself to not want anything and put up with everything, because they haven’t yet figured out the latter two thirds of the Serenity Prayer.
  • If you draw an innocuous cartoon and label it “Muhammad”, people will literally set buildings on fire.
  • The world’s largest religion is about a relatively unassuming man who invented moral precepts like “be merciful sometimes”, empathy, and “anyone who disagrees with me can actually go to Hell.”
  • Xenu.
  • People actually believe this.

Terrifying? Undoubtedly. Funny? Yes! With things like this occupying our reality, how can anyone really expect artists not to borrow from it and use it to make a point? Maybe these beliefs do need to be questioned. Maybe some sensibilities need to be offended. And I really wish you all could be California girls. Amen.

1. “My closest friends happen to be gay… I came from a very strict household, where any of that taboo stuff was wrong. I don’t say I hate where I came from, I love my parents and was happy to… have that opportunity to grow, but I came from a strict, suppressed household where that was wrong.” (The New Gay, 10 Jun 2008)

Comments

  1. StarmanReturns says

    This is the first time I’ve ever heard of Katy Perry,but I’m not surprised after learning about her of life story about how she turned out.I’ve heard many times that people who lead shelterd lives with very religious parents become Hellraisers when they become adults.For one example screenwriter Paul Schrader (who wrote that Ultraviolent movie Taxi Driver,which I’ve seen a dozen times)had a similar upbringing as Katy Perrys.

    From watching some of Katy Perry’s videos she seems to want to be a young Madonna Popstar singing about everything you can imagine about sex.She has some nerve saying “using blasphemy as entertainment is as cheap as a comedian telling a fart joke”when her own credibility has ben blown to smithereens.

    It would be like former (and current ) disgraced pastor Ted Haggard returning to becoming a pastor so that he can preach to people on how to not live a sinfull life, In a July 2010 interview he gave to CNN,Haggard claims that his feelings of sexual attraction to other men have miraculously disappeared. Haggard now portrays his encounter with the prostitute as a massage that went awry.I feel very sorry for the confused people who go to this man’s church and donate money to him,do they know where it will eventually go to?

  2. Abby says

    I remember being kind of saddened reading about Katy Perry’s upbringing. Sure, she doesn’t seem too bright (and that definitely shows), but I’m pretty sure religion fucked her up, for lack of a better term.

    Regardless, I really enjoyed reading this. Once again, you eloquently phrase what I’ve been thinking but am I too inarticulate to say.

    • Lilith Schienberg says

      Meh. I’d do Katy! But yes, I’m saddened by EVERYONE who is religious! We are Human beings and now possess enough knowledge of the Universe to finally let go of ancient superstition and imaginary friends… at least conventional wisdom would say.

  3. says

    I suspect that she’s hanging on to that last particular shred of her upbringing because it’s too close to rejecting her parents. Since both were ministers, blasphemy might be too entertwined in her head with saying her parents are horrible. After all, it’s “God the Father” anyway, and if the minister is actually *your* father, it gets worse.

    I don’t think she’s quite ready to tackle that little pyschological issue head on yet. Maybe one day.

    • Lilith Schienberg says

      Sounds about right… Knowing how devout believers are, she fears being disowned. Devout Christfags somehow find it very easy to disown their offspring for saying/doing anything against the Christian faith. Religion is counter-productive, illogical, inconducive to intellectual integrity, and flat-out dangerous!

  4. says

    How do you decide what to say in a video instead of a blog, or vice versa? In general I’d assume that a video is more work, and gets more exposure. Do you decide some things aren’t worth making into videos? ..then again, this isn’t just a flippant blog, its very thorough, so could take just as much effort. Though I doubt its possible that it gets nearly as much exposure.

  5. says

    My celebrity crush on Katy Perry reminds me of a pastor’s daughter I once courted. It fell apart because I was an atheist. Apparently the fact that I knew what I was doing in the sack was a bad thing. She wanted someone pure for her honeymoon.

  6. mthrnite says

    There’s a simple reason why she does all this other crap that’s “shameful in the eyes of the lord” but draws the line at blasphemy.. that’s the scary sin.. the unforgivable sin.. maybe.. The verses relating to it are vague enough and the penalty severe enough that if you accidentally blaspheme the amorphous blob that is the “holy spirit”, you could be doomed to eternal hotness. So, a lot of “spiritual” people play it safe there, for selfish reasons.

  7. c. says

    Saying that using religious iconography for shock value is “cheap” rings a little hollow from Katy Perry.

Trackbacks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>