Quantcast

«

»

Apr 29 2013

Pseudo-Historian Who Compares Obama to Hitler Invited to Speak at Army Prayer Breakfast

Yeah, I’m talking about everybody’s favorite Christian nationalist history revisionist David Barton. It seems this paragon of lies and propaganda has been invited to speak at the Annual National Prayer Breakfast at Fort Leonard Wood, Missouri, to be held on Thursday, May 2. The topic of Mr. Barton’s presentation is to be “Our American Heritage: Why History Matters.” Well, as anyone familiar with Barton’s work knows, the reason that history matters to him is that it can be distorted to fit his far-right political agenda.

But, besides Mr. Barton’s Christian nationalist version of American history being so inaccurate that his latest book was pulled from the shelves by Christian publisher Thomas Nelson, there are two other reasons that he is an outrageously inappropriate choice to speak at any military event. One is his very public contempt for the President of the United States. This is a man who recently posted an image on his Facebook page grouping President Obama with … you guessed it … Hitler!

hitler-obama

 

Then there’s his constant denigration of faiths other than his own — not just non-Christian faiths, but also those wishy-washy mainline and liberal Christians who are destroying the church.

The Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) has sent a letter to Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel (full letter at end of post) demanding that Fort Leonard Wood rescind its invitation to Mr. Barton and that a more appropriate speaker be chosen for the prayer breakfast.

Mr. Barton, along with far-right Christian groups like the American Family Association, the Family Research Council, and FOX News, will no doubt be crying Christian persecution over MRFF’s demand, and claiming that MRFF and its big, bad “anti-Christian extremist” leader Mikey Weinstein is out to rid the U.S. military of all religion. But nothing could be farther from the truth. These people know damn well that MRFF is not an anti-religious organization, and that 96% of our clients are actually Christians; they just need to keep lying about us to keep up the persecution stories.

Now, those of you who follow the right-wing media may have noticed an uptick lately in the number and far-fetchedness of “news” stories claiming that the U.S. military has become hostile towards Christians.

Rep. Randy Forbes (R-VA) actually told FOX News: “We are getting a lot of calls from soldiers saying ‘we’re afraid of going to church, we’re afraid to be seen praying, we’re afraid that would hurt our careers, our promotions.’” Really, Mr. Forbes? It’s the Christian soldiers who are afraid to express their faith and go to church? Then, please tell us, Mr. Forbes, why the Army is having to build all those mega-churches on Army posts, like that new $30 million dollar one at Fort Hood, to accommodate so many church-going Christians? If they’re afraid to go to church, as you claim, then why on earth did the taxpayers have to pay for these great big churches for them to go to?

Then there’s the one about the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) website being blocked by the Army last week. Headlines like “US Army Labels Southern Baptist Convention ‘Hostile’” have millions of Christians feeding their persecution complexes with tales of the Army saying that the Southern Baptist Convention is “hostile.” Hoo-ah! More Christian persecution! Well, what really happened was that the SBC website was flagged by virus software that detected possible malware, commonly referred to as “hostile content.” In fundie-land, however, the words “hostile content” in the message “The site you have requested has been blocked by Team CONUS (C-TNOSC/RECERT-CONUS) due to hostile content” mean more Christian persecution, dammit, not that some religion-neutral malware was detected.

So, have at us, oh ye persecuted Christians. Here’s our letter to Secretary Hagel:

Monday, April 29, 2013

The Honorable Chuck Hagel
Secretary of Defense
1000 Defense Pentagon
Washington, DC 20301-1000

 

Dear Secretary Hagel,

It has been brought to the attention of the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) that the guest speaker for this year’s annual Fort Leonard Wood, Missouri, National Prayer Breakfast, to be held on the National Day of Prayer, May 2, 2013, is Mr. David Barton.

For the following three reasons, Mr. Barton is an egregiously inappropriate speaker for this or any other military event:

1) his open contempt for and denigration of the President and other government officials;

2) his denigration of faith groups other than his own; and,

3) his revisionism of American history.

Article 88 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) states that:

“Any commissioned officer who uses contemptuous words against the President, the Vice President, Congress, the Secretary of Defense, the Secretary of a military department, the Secretary of Transportation, or the Governor or legislature of any State, Territory, Commonwealth, or possession in which he is on duty or present shall be punished as a court-martial may direct.”

Although Mr. Barton is not himself in the military, the invitation for him to speak at this military event can be considered nothing less than the condoning and endorsement of statements that if made by the officer(s) who invited him to speak would be punishable by their court-martial.

 

Open Contempt for and Denigration of the President of the United States

Mr. Barton, who is above all else a political activist, is well known for his open, vocal, and constant use of contemptuous words against the President. Mr. Barton’s statements are not merely political opinions, but the promoting of a number of conspiracy theories and lies about President Obama, and even equating him with Adolf Hitler.

• In an article on his WallBuilders.com website titled “America’s Most Biblically-Hostile U. S. President,” Mr. Barton accuses President Obama of “Acts of hostility toward people of Biblical faith” and “Acts of preferentialism for Islam.” This article is updated periodically with additional unfounded accusations, with the latest accusation being added on April 17, 2013.

(http://www.wallbuilders.com/libissuesarticles.asp?id=106938)

• He has accused the Obama administration of deliberately allowing the attack on the consulate in Benghazi, claiming that Obama allowed the attack as “the perfect set-up for the anti-blasphemy [United Nations] resolution that we joined on to and said we’re going to be a part of.”

(http://tfninsider.org/2012/11/02/detestable-david-barton-suggests-president-obama-was-complicit-in-the-murder-of-u-s-ambassador-to-libya/)

• He has accused President Obama of exploiting the Sandy Hook tragedy for political purposes, saying he’d “never let a crisis go to waste.”

(http://tinyurl.com/GunsKidsAndCritics)

• He has posted an image on his Facebook page grouping President Obama with Hitler, Stalin, and Castro (see Appendix A):

(https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=475046952532882&set=a.157340314303549.22910.101762193194695&type=1&theater)

• As a frequent guest on Glenn Beck’s former FOX News TV show, radio show, and web-based TV show, Mr. Barton has been an active part of, or complicit in, numerous lies and conspiracy theories about President Obama, such as his being a socialist, Marxist, or communist, and his being affiliated with groups such as the “Muslim Brotherhood.”

Dozens, if not hundreds, of other examples could be given of Mr. Barton’s past and ongoing contemptuous words against the President.

 

Denigration of Faith Groups Other Than His Own

Mr. Barton is also well known for his attacks against faiths other than his own, including Christians who do not subscribe to his narrow, fundamentalist interpretation of Christianity. This is the second reason that Mr. Barton is an altogether inappropriate speaker for the upcoming Prayer Breakfast at Fort Leonard Wood — an event that is supposed to be inclusive of members of all faiths.

• Mr. Barton has regularly attacked mainline Christian denominations for their stances on both theological and political issues.

• He has regularly promoted the conspiracy theory that Muslims seek to place the United States under Sharia law.

• He has hosted virulently anti-Muslim guests on his radio show, WallBuilders LIVE!, to include guests who have been disinvited from speaking at other military events due to their attacks on the religion of Islam. For example, one recent guest on his show was anti-Muslim activist Brigitte Gabriel, who was disinvited from speaking at the Air Force Academy after statements she made at a prior appearance at the Joint Forces Staff College (i.e., saying that Americans of the Muslim faith should not be allowed to serve in the U.S. military or hold political office) were revealed.

 

Revisionism of American History

And last, but certainly not least, Mr. Barton is best known for his revisionism of American history.

• Mr. Barton espouses the belief that America is a Christian nation, and that those of other religions are only tolerated here because America is a Christian nation.

• The politically motivated and deliberate historical falsehoods presented by Mr. Barton in his books and presentations have been well documented by both liberal and conservative historians.

• His latest book, The Jefferson Lies, was pulled by Christian publisher Thomas Nelson due to its historical inaccuracy.

The title of the presentation that Mr. Barton is scheduled to deliver on May 2 at Fort Leonard Wood’s prayer breakfast is “Our American Heritage: Why History Matters,” indicating that his presentation will be one of his propagandist Christian nationalist history lectures.

Given that Mr. Barton has a standard history presentation that has remained virtually unchanged for many years, the content of the presentation he intends to deliver at Fort Leonard Wood can be anticipated. It will undoubtedly contain numerous misquotes and lies about America’s founding, all of which have been proven to be untrue, and a grossly distorted view of the Constitution that our men and women in uniform who will be attending this prayer breakfast have sworn an oath to support and defend.

For the three reasons listed and detailed above, the Military Religious Freedom Foundation demands that the invitation to Mr. Barton to speak at the Fort Leonard Wood prayer breakfast on May 2, 2013 be immediately rescinded and a more appropriate and inclusive speaker be chosen for this event.

 

Sincerely,

 

Michael L. “Mikey” Weinstein, Esq.
Founder and President
Military Religious Freedom Foundation

 

Chris Rodda
Senior Research Director
Military Religious Freedom Foundation

 

CC:
Barack H. Obama, President of the United States of America, Commander-In-Chief, United States Armed Forces
General Martin E. Dempsey, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
John McHugh, Secretary of the Army
General Raymond T. Odierno, Chief of Staff of the Army
Brigadier General Mark S. Inch, Commanding General, Fort Leonard Wood

19 comments

Skip to comment form

  1. 1
    coragyps

    I like it! The only downside is that Barton gets too much press already – but if you keep up the heat on him, maybe only the loons will keep listening to him.
    If only we had fewer damn loons here in Texas…..

  2. 2
    usna1960

    Chris … wouldn’t it be sweet if there coud be a booth set up at the venue with flyers documenting barton’s BS, references to/excerpts from your exposés on this pseudo-historian, christo-fascist, dominionist, “amerikan taliban” asshole … does Jason have minions at Ft, Leonard Wood who could/would make this happen ?

  3. 3
    grumpyoldfart

    My prediction:
    He will speak at the breakfast and he will be loudly applauded.

  4. 4
    Alverant

    My prediction is that Barton will use this as an example of how he’s persecuted by the evil MRFF who insists that the military follow their own rules.

  5. 5
    Gregory in Seattle

    I’ve never understood this Christian idolatry with the military. Jesus said to turn the other cheek, not pick up a combat rifle and go to town on the “infidel”.

  6. 6
    lochaber

    Gregory in Seattle>

    I don’t know my bible quotes, but I’ve heard 2nd amendment fans often quoting some passage where Jesus supposedly told his followers to arm themselves, or something similar. (I’m thinking it’s probably right before he got nailed, but I’ve pretty much given up on reading through the bible after the boring parts of exodus…)

    Anyways, funny thing about religion, is that it almost always supports the priveleges and biases of the person wielding it like a club. :(

  7. 7
    Jeremy Shaffer

    Jesus said to turn the other cheek, not pick up a combat rifle and go to town on the “infidel”.

    When Jesus said to turn the other cheek he meant it so you could do that cool draw a gun from your shoulder rig during a slow- motion spin whenever someone slaps you. It’s all right there in the bible.

  8. 8
    Raging Bee

    and claiming that MRFF and its big, bad “anti-Christian extremist” leader Mikey Weinstein is out to rid the U.S. military of all religion.

    They say that like it’s a bad thing.

  9. 9
    Raging Bee

    PS: calling Barton a “pseudo-hisotorian” give pseudo-history a bad name.

  10. 10
    hexidecima

    whatever officer asked Barton to speak should have his ass courtmartialed. Outright encouragement of attacks against the Commander in Chief should be enough with no problem.

    and the verse from the bible “defending” the second amendment is when JC says go get a sword. However, it isnt’ in all gospels and at the last, JC prevents anyone from using a sword. So it’s just the usual Christian bullshit.

  11. 11
    baal

    You know, if they can’t invite Mr.Barton or anyone who distorts the truth like Mr.Barton; they would have trouble finding any right wing christian to speak!

  12. 12
    patricksimons

    David Barton may as well be calling himself an astronaut. He isn’t qualified to teach history at the grade school level.

  13. 13
    redmann

    A little OT but I’m claiming, so far, a small victory at the Navy pharmacy where I get my prescriptions. I was in there a couple of months ago and Fox News was on the TV. When I got home I sent an email to the pharmacy HQ in Portsmouth VA pointing out the Fox routinely broadcast insults and lies against the currnt administration and should not be shown at a military installation. The next time I went there MSNBC, yeah I know not stupenously better, was on and has been on every time since. I hope Fox is gone for good.

  14. 14
    Chris Rodda

    That’s not OT at all, redmann. It’s the same issue — the military condoning and promoting contempt for the commander-in chief. MRFF gets constant complaints about FOX being on in almost all public places on military bases – stores, gyms, etc. Kudos for speaking up and stopping it in your neck of the woods!

  15. 15
    bmiller

    Great essay and I totally agree with the vileness of barton.

    One BIG disagreement, however. This might even be off-topic, but Obama, frankly, is pretty terrifyingly bad. How can he not be…he is an American President? The man worships Ronald Reagan, is now mouthing platitudes about how great George W. Bush is, and wants very badly to get involved in Syria and Iran, Maybe not “Hitler”, but his policies and the ideologies he supports ARE terrible.

    In fact, many of the worst excesses of foregin policy are started or ramped up by our supposedly “liberal”Democratic Party. Vitenam. Afghanistan. Central America.

    Sorry for the off-topic digression. i just can’t take the defense of this man, President Hopeless and No Change.

  16. 16
  17. 17
    sleepingwytch(inactive)

    “My prediction is that Barton will use this as an example of how he’s persecuted by the evil MRFF who insists that the military follow their own rules.”

    I think this is the sad truth Alverant. I feel disgusted having to agree that what you typed is probably the most accurate guestimate of what’s going to actually occur. Sickening

  18. 18
    mikecline

    Great letter. Between Mikey Weinstein’s tenacity and Chris Rodda’s research, I’d say this letter has a good chance of making an impact. Thanks for doing this invaluable work.

  19. 19
    obscure1

    David Barton is to History what Albert Einstein was to muskrat trapping.

Leave a Reply