An Example Of Getting It Right


A friend of mine told me about this new American TV Series ‘Ironside’ that has just started. I haven’t seen it yet so this isn’t a commentary post on the show. If in case you have, do share your views.

The plot looks interesting. An investigator who is a wheelchair user. And its nice to see a black man lead. Knowing about this show reminded me of a recently watched but not-so-recent film named ‘The Bone Collector’. It stars a black quadriplegic homicide detective, Lincoln Rhyme (Denzel Washington) and a white female patrol cop, Amelia Donaghy (Angelina Jolie). Here are a couple of things about the film that stood out and made it really worthwhile..

1. Black men as protagonists itself are not that usual, but a disabled black man? Only once I’ve seen that.

2. It was ‘HIS’ story. I’m not saying that simply having a disabled character means it should be all about them. But since he’s the lead here. And what’s impressive is that it was done properly. He wasn’t this inspiration porn trope where he ‘overcomes’ his disability by doing ‘amazing’ things or is simply there as some sort of a lesson for non-disabled characters (and non-disabled viewers indirectly). He was lively, happy, sad, angry, funny, etc and doing what he had to do. Neither were the disability-related hurdles he would naturally experience brushed aside. So as a character, he was complete.

3. Now usually what happens if there is a male disabled character is that the female gets portrayed as somehow double inferior than regular. I don’t know if I’m right, but I’ve felt this at times. It’s like their saying, ”See this guy is ‘disabled’. What woman would fall for him? Obviously a really “stupid” type!” That’s like hitting both of them (the man for his disability, and the woman for simply being female). I saw this movie in Malayalam just few days before seeing The Bone Collector (which could also be one of the reasons I immediately liked it). Same, main character is quad. But mainly there to ‘inspire’ others with his cheerfulness and happy-go-lucky attitude. Also it seemed like the writer made him disabled to get away with objectifying women. (”Because c’mon, poor disabled fellow, who cares if he’s sexist. He’s anyway not going to have a woman like him.”) Ugh! So this Rhyme-Amelia relationship was done well in that respect. It showed both their sides and their affection grew in the course of the film.

4. Bonus Point! Prominent and complex black character #2 – Thelma (Queen Latifah). Black and fat actually. And no, she wasn’t just sitting around eating or acting foolish. She was his nurse, a woman who was clever and resourceful.

5. The ending of the film was particularly good. When Richard Thompson, the killer, arrives at Rhyme’s house with the intention of killing him, Rhyme puts up a very practical fight and causes serious injury to his opponent. He wasn’t simply killed with no sign of resistence. Instead, he fought on until Amelia suddenly arrived at the apartment and shot Thompson down.

One minor complaint I had with the film was that initially Amelia had to be given directions for the even the most basic stuff like picking up some evidence on the crime scene (which one would think is lesson #1 in training academy for cops?) Guess they just wanted to show Rhyme’s character as ‘dynamic’ and ‘big bossy’ (as a man). That was unnecessary, but thankfully Amelia’s character evolved later on.

Being happy and having a positive attitude towards life is essential for anyone’s mental peace. No denying that. Likewise, demeaning and insulting words being thrown at disabled people is also no less of a reality. But what differentiates the portrayal of these from reinforcing negative attitudes is how they are responded to in the very same films. If the character, who is obviously living in an ableist environment, appears to be constantly happy and not showing any resentment towards the oppression they face, then it means the oppression is normalized, it’s no big deal. If hurtful and insulting dialogues are met with silent acceptance (or worse, laughter), then it’s just a big screen reminder (or celebration) of the actual prejudices that actually exist. So I think its important to show *some* of the marginalizations at least. Otherwise it becomes unrealistic. And unrelatable for the ‘real’ people with those disabilities. Which means, in reality, their stories are still waiting to be told.

Comments

  1. colnago80 says

    For those too young to remember it, there was a TV series called Ironside back in the late 60s to the mid 70s which starred actor Raymond Burr as a wheelchair police officer named Ironside. Obviously, this is a remake with an Afro-American actor Blair Underwood playing the wheelchair detective.

    http://goo.gl/cdyGAK

  2. NHRN says

    Nice post. To clarify a few things: 1) Ironside is a remake of another show called Ironside http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ironside_(TV_series). 2) Police (at least in the NYPD) aren’t trained to collect evidence to the level that forensic techs are trained to do. It wouldn’t be odd for Rhyme to instruct Sachs on how to do it. Incidentally, in the books, Rhyme’s character is white.

  3. CGM3 says

    One possible obstacle for the new Ironside is that it’s a re-boot of the original Raymond Burr series from the late Sixties/early Seventies. On the other hand, the Battlestar Galactica re-boot proved highly successful, so we’ll have to wait and see.

    And while I’ve seen (and enjoyed) The Bone Collector, I never thought about any resemblance to Ironside; but then, there were a number of “disabled detective” shows during the same period as the original Ironside (Longstreet and Harry O come to mind) so it’s possible my mental categorization kept them compartmentalized.

  4. Alex C. says

    Thank you above commenters for reminding/informing the author about the original Ironside! Although I’ve not watched the original series on TV (being not old enough and not USA-ian), it stands out as one of the better portrayal of disabled people going on leading normal, productive lives. Let’s hope the remake lives up to its mighty predecessor, although I’ll still not get to watch on TV!

  5. says

    @Anita one thing I noticed while watching that first episode – there wasn’t any scene where he encounters structural barriers. The very first sequence has him investigating a crime scene – on a rooftop, but they don’t show him getting there. Partly that’s tight editing perhaps, but I’d have thought things like that would be worth depicting, since as the saying goes, “drama is conflict”. I’ll keep an eye out for all your points while watching it next time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>