Justice Scalia’s Dissent

And now on the dissent of Justice Scalia, who joined in Chief Justice Roberts’ primary dissent but writes separately to, in his words, “call attention to this Court’s threat to American democracy.” Scalia, like virtually every other judicial and legal conservative, makes arguments against judicial review itself while pretending to make arguments only against the result of a particular case.
[Read more…]

Huckabee’s Ridiculous Response to Obamacare Ruling

Mike Huckabee rarely has anything coherent or intelligent to say about constitutional matters, so it’s hardly surprising that his response to the Supreme Court’s ruling upholding subsidies in the federal exchanges created by the Affordable Care Act contains lots of outrage and nothing remotely reasonable.
[Read more…]

Chief Justice Roberts’ Dissent

The marriage case was a rare one in which every single justice in the minority wrote their own dissent, then joined in the other dissents as well. It seems they really wanted to get their views on the record. I want to take a look at some of those dissents and the sometimes laughable arguments they present, starting with the primary dissent from Chief Justice Roberts.
[Read more…]

Justice Kennedy’s Reasoning in Upholding Marriage Equality

Unless you’ve been vacationing in the jungles of Suriname, you know by now that the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 on Friday that the 14th Amendment requires states to recognize same-sex marriage on equal par with opposite-sex marriages. I want to highlight some of the reasoning and language Justice Kennedy used in his opinion.
[Read more…]

Starnes Asks God to Send Plagues of Hornets on His Enemies

Todd Starns, speaking at the recent Faith and Freedom event put on by Ralph Reed, got himself all worked up into a lather and, citing the sending of plagues that God allegedly sent on his enemies in the Old Testament, asked him to send hornets and cicadas and other bugs on the Supreme Court and anyone else who does things he doesn’t like.
[Read more…]

Fox and Friends Still Pretending Charleston Wasn’t About Race

The three headed idiot known as the Fox and Friends morning show are still defending their ridiculous claim last week that the Charleston shootings were about being anti-Christian rather than anti-black. Even after the killer’s manifesto that explicitly laid out his racist motivations, they still want to pretend otherwise.
[Read more…]

Supreme Court Upholds Federal Subsidies in Obamacare

In a decision that came out pretty much exactly as I expected, the Supreme Court yesterday upheld the distribution of tax subsidies in the federal health care exchanges created by the Affordable Care Act by a 6-3 vote. Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Kennedy joined the four liberals on the court and Roberts wrote the majority opinion.
[Read more…]