Obama Makes a Dangerous Enemy »« Jerry DeWitt on Morning Joe

USCIRF Condemns Russian Blasphemy Law

The Russian Federation Council approved a bill earlier passed by the Russian Duma that provides criminal penalties for insulting religion, sending it to Putin for his signature. The U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom is strongly criticizing the law:

The Russian State Duma on June 26 passed a controversial bill on “causing offense to the sentiments of religious believers.” The bill now awaits only a presidential signature before becoming law, most likely on July 1. The bill would punish alleged offenses against religious sentiments by up to three years in prison.

“With space for free expression shrinking rapidly in Russia, enactment of this bill would further erode human rights protections in Russia,” said U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) Chair Dr. Katrina Lantos Swett. “Speech limitations violate Russia’s international commitments, and this law will lead to abuse and arbitrary rulings against permissible speech that some deem ‘offensive.”

First introduced last fall, the so-called “blasphemy law” has provoked an outcry from many who warn that the law would violate the Russian constitutional separation of religion and state, and predict that officials will use it to target critics of the Moscow Patriarchate. Many also assert that while the Duma’s Social and Religious Organizations Committee, the Kremlin human rights council, and the Public Chamber all amended the bill, its major flaws were not addressed.

The bill states that “public acts held near religious sites that show blatant disrespect for society and intended to offend believers’ religious sentiments” would be penalized by fines of up to 300,000 rubles (more than $9,000) or punished by forced labor or prison terms of up to one year. If alleged offenses are committed inside religious sites, the bill sets higher penalties, with fines of up to 500,000 rubles (more than $15,000) or up to three-years of forced labor and prison plus post-imprisonment restrictions of up to one year. Russian citizens convicted of obstructing religious activities will face increased fines as will those who use their official positions for committing such an offense who also could face “corrective labor” of up to two years or a prison term of up to one year.

“When I was in Moscow in September 2012, I raised concerns about this measure and the general respect for international human rights norms. If enacted, this new law gives credence to the view Russian human rights activists expressed to me that Russia is in full retreat from democracy and the rule of law,” concluded Dr. Lantos Swett.

The good news is that this provides me with material for my next column in Secular World magazine about religion and free speech. But I’d sure like it a lot better if I had nothing to write about.

Comments

  1. matty1 says

    Ed’s usual targets in the states must be so jealous. Then again maybe they will all flee to Russia on rafts to escape the coming gay oppression.

  2. raven says

    Ed’s usual targets in the states must be so jealous. Then again maybe they will all flee to Russia on rafts to escape the coming gay oppression.

    They won’t have to float on rafts to Russia, which is marginally possible at the Bering Strait. (And in winter, you can just walk across the ice.).

    We would all cheerfully buy them one way airline tickets. On the condition that they don’t let the screen door hit them in the ass on the way out.

    If enough fundie xian bigots could get it together, we would charter a luxury ocean liner.

  3. says

    So, as the USA becomes more of a police state, Russia looking across the table, not to be outdone, says “OK, I raise you 1 blasphemy law”.

  4. skemono says

    I’d kinda like to see one of the rightwing people who still harp about Communists because they apparently never learned the Cold War ended learn that now evil, atheist Russia has such a law.

  5. a miasma of incandescent plasma says

    matty1 @1

    Ed’s usual targets in the states must be so jealous. Then again maybe they will all flee to Russia on rafts to escape the coming gay oppression.

    Nah.
    You know what they’ll say ?? – they’ll say that Murika(!) is becoming more like Russia because now the Supreme Court made LAWS(!) that make it a crime to hurt a gay-homo’s feelings and stuff and things… Ya see it’s all about FREEDUM! dontchaknow

    It’s not your fault you can’t see the REAL issues here like the Bachmann’s of the world…

  6. Pierce R. Butler says

    The bill states that “public acts held near religious sites that show blatant disrespect for society and intended to offend believers’ religious sentiments” would be penalized…

    Does the bill define “near”, or is it simply implicit that it means “within the nearest national borders”?

  7. naturalcynic says

    Will giggling or outright laughing at some religious procession count as blasphemy?
    There will be some grey area where a line has to be drawn.

  8. arakasi says

    With the recent DOMA/Prop 8 decisions, and the growing secular pushback against religion in the US, is Russia going to become the new rightwing utopia? They’re already showing the “benefits” of runaway capitalism mixed with extreme authoritarianism. All that needs to happen is for the US right to overcome decades of viewing Russia as the center of the Evil Soviet Empire, and they will start flocking to Putin.

Leave a Reply