I Get Mail – Quality or Quantity »« A Second Letter – Dear Cardinal O’Brien

Historical Revisionism and the Magdalene Laundries

 I’m not saying that the use by the Irish state of the Magdalene laundries as reformatories to which people could be sent without explanation or due process was in any way defensible. And Irish nuns could undoubtedly be tough in those days (my wife has fond memories from her convent school in Swanage, now a holiday hotel, of being called “a bold girl” and having her hand thwacked with a 12-inch ruler). But, says one woman quoted above, there was in the Magdalene laundries no physical punishment that she saw, and though things were “not rosy”, “we were treated good and well looked after”.

Says William Oddie, whose clueless article on the Catholic Herald denigrates the tales of horrific abuse that came from the Magdalene Laundries. In particular? The Throwaway line about his wife surviving her own pointless abuse and being “better” for it.

Beating your kids is abuse. Someone else beating your kids is also abuse. It’s assault and battery and should be punished as such. The sexual and physical brutality of the Magdalene laundries are well known and people such as Oddie actually are trying to say this.

The Laundries aren’t as bad as you make them out to be. The majority of women who were FORCED into them were not abused to the level of the stories. The fact of the matter is the Catholic Church in Ireland with regards to the Magdalene laundries is guilty of Sexual Exploitation, Physical Abuse and one more crime.

Tell me? What crime involves making people work for you without any pay or reward and under compulsion or force?

It’s called “Slavery” mate.

Comments

  1. says

    The Throwaway line about his wife surviving her own pointless abuse and being “better” for it.

    He appears to approve of abuse, then, and surely won’t mind if random strangers just pile on him whenever they feel like it, amirite?

  2. Seeing/analyzing says

    Wow….I’m speechless that someone could basically compare the Magdalene Laundries with, say, at week at weight-loss camp: not a laugh-riot-a-minute, but hey, going through it makes for a better person. Unbelievable.

  3. DumbDrunkAndRacist says

    I was amazed that anyone would rush to the defense of people and places like this that would purpetrate such crimes as this – torture (because it is) abuse, kidnap and slavery – - in such a systemic way.

    But then, religion seems to allow everything as long as the soul is saved.

  4. says

    Let’s get together for lunchMy watch is faster than yours.We look forward to your visit.Have you ever driven a BMW?eventually i caved in.We are prohibited from smoking on school grounds.We are prohibited from smoking on school grounds.What’s your goal in life.Keep your temper under control.I guess I could come ove

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>